The flowdiagram (Figure 1) summarizes the study selection process, specifying the reasons for study exclusion. The main reason for exclusion was the absence of variables related to the sleep cycle or DF in the main objective of the study. There were 12 articles selected that were published since 2009 and included DF and sleep outcome variables.
All selected studies were observational, most of them cross-sectional (n = 6). The remaining studies were cohort studies (n = 2), case-control studies (n = 2), one case-report and one case series study. The sample size varied from n = 3 [19
] to n = 1,656,739 [20
], with the total sample size being n = 1,659,699. In 3studies [21
], the type of diabetes in the sample was not specified. In 6studies [19
], the sample subjects had type 2 diabetes mellitus (DM2), and in 3studies [28
], they had both type 1diabetes mellitus (DM1)and DM2. In all of them, the population was adults(>18 years old) (Table 1).
3. Is There an Association between Sleep Disorders and Diabetic Foot? A Scoping Review
Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is a common sleep disorder in which a partial or complete obstruction of the upper airway occurs [31
]. These obstructions will lead to a greater division of sleep, a decrease in oxygen saturation and a reduction in air flow [32
]. OSA is an independent risk factor for cardiovascular disease [33
], cognitive disorders [34
] and metabolic dysfunction [35
].Intermittent hypoxia increases sympathetic activation and oxidative stress, impairing arterial function and generating inflammation [36
It is known that untreated OSA leads to morbidity and worsening of glycemic control (insulin resistance and glucose intolerance), along with diabetic angiopathy. Research has shown that OSA is related to insensitivity of the foot and diabetic peripheral neuropathy, all of which contributes negatively to DFU healing [37
]. In four of the studies included, DF variables were associated with OSA-related variables. Altaf et al. [24
] found a positive correlation between small fiber neuropathy and OSA severity, and between the prevalence of DFUs and OSA. This suggested that OSA patients should be considered to be high risk, although the sample size did not allow regression analyses. Subramanian et al. [20
] recommended anticipating the development of OSA as a risk factor in patients with DF.
Maltese et al. [28
] highlighted the high prevalence of OSA among patients with DFUs, concluding that OSA severity is directly related to poor healing and re-ulceration.They used the STOP-Bang Questionnaire for OSA severity, a widely used instrument with high levels of sensitivity and specificity [39
]. Therefore, the presence and severity of OSA should be considered in the treatment and prevention of DFUs. As a matter of fact, Vas et al. [19
] described three cases of patients with DM2 and obesity, in which they studied how the impact of severe OSA interfered with DFU healing, despite a good local treatment. Patients under OSA treatment with continuous positive airway pressure showed significantly improved DFU healing, while patients who refused OSA treatment did not improve. Despite sample limitations, the results were promising and could represent a breakthrough in DFU treatment in patients with similar characteristics.
In another four of the studies included, sleep quality was related to DFU-related variables. Haveleia and Gayatri [23
] found a significant correlation between the levels of stress and pain and subjective sleep quality in DFU patients, although they found no relationship between the severity of DFUs and sleep quality. However, it must be taken into account that this study did not include a control group in the sample. Conversely, Salomé et al. [30
] did provide results that supported DFU patients having poor sleep quality, although this study did not include a control group without DFUs. Puspita et al. [26
] addressed this same relationship and included a control group of people with diabetes without DFUs. As in the previous study, most of the subjects with DFUs and/or pain had poor sleep quality, although no significant differences were found.
All of these studies used the Pittsburgh sleep quality index (PSQI) to measure sleep quality, which is valid, reliable and widely used [40
]. This lack of relationship between sleep quality and the presence or severity of DFUs could be explained by the high probability of DFUs not causing any pain (because of DN) [41
]. Moreover, not all DFU patients suffer from sleep disorders [42
Nairetet al. [22
] analyzed the effectiveness of microcurrent therapy for the healing of chronic ulcers (including DFUs), and one of the outcome variables was sleep quality. Both sleep quality and neuropathic pain improved in most patients after receiving the therapy, however, the sleep quality measurement instrument was not specified, nor was a control group used. These results should be taken with caution and the use of microcurrent therapy should be studied in detail in future works.
Another important variable regarding sleep is its duration, which was studied by Sheahan et al. [27
] in patients with DFUs under different conditions, as follows: minor amputation, major amputation, with and without off-loading elements, or peripheral neuropathy. These groups were compared to each other and did not show a significant decrease in quality or duration of sleep. This lack of correlation can be explained in a similar way as before, in that the absence of pain and psychogenic or sleep disorders may be the reason for the sleep not being impaired.
The study by Andruskiene et al. [21
] found an association between diabetic foot pain and depressive states in a female population, however, no correlation was found with variables regarding the sleep. According to other authors, the depressive state can cause sleep disturbances [43
]. This study was the only one included in this review that took into account the consumption of sedative, antidepressant, analgesic or antitussive drugs.
In two of the studies included, DF and sleep variables were not related to each other. In the study by Bener et al. [25
], sleep variables and DF variables were studied separately as risk factors for hearing loss. Rutkove et al. [29
] also did not relate them. Instead, thermoregulation in the foot and DN during sleep and wakefulness were measured, and it was concluded that nocturnal thermoregulation is affected in patients with ND.
Along with our results, recent systematic reviews and meta-analyses show the association between DM on the sleep. Reutrakul et al. [45
] found an association between DM1, poor sleep quality and prevalence of OSA, while another review [46
] also associated the latter with DM2. Lee et al. [47
] and Grandner et al. [48
] found that the quality and duration of sleep influenced both glycemic metabolism in patients with DM2 and the risk of suffering from DM2. Several authors concluded that there is a high prevalence of sleep disturbances in patients with DM [35
]. In the recent work by Nefs et al. [51
], the reciprocal relationship between DM and sleep was approached from a behavioral science perspective, and it was stated that sleep quality should be considered with the same importance as diet and exercise in DM care.
Our results lead to several applications in clinical practice. Since the relationship between OSA and DF is the most studied, clinicians should consider OSA as a component of the multifactorial condition of DF. In addition, it may be appropriate for a diabetic foot specialist and a sleep disorder specialist to work in a multidisciplinary way with OSA and DF patients, to address prevention and treatment strategies.
Although there is a lack of evidence on the relationship between DF and the quality and duration of sleep, it is known that DFU healing is associated with poor coping and high levels of depression [52
], which in turn are associated with poor quality and duration of sleep [36
]. To improve the multidisciplinary treatment of patients with DF and psychological disorders or sleep disturbances, research linking these variables should be conducted in the future.
One limitation of this study is that there might be scientific literature published in a different language than those included in the inclusion criteria. In addition, a trend to link sleep disturbances with neuropathic pain has been found in the available literature. However, since neuropathic pain is not exclusive to DF, studies concerning neuropathic pain have not been the topic of this review. The same can be said for PAD, which is multifactorial and not exclusive to DM, and thereforeit has not been considered in the present work either.