The main aim of using nanoparticles in soilless farming is to minimize nutrient losses while also increasing yields through better nutrient and water management. Due to their high specific surface and related reactivity (particle size less than 100 nm), nanoparticles can provide the plant with more soluble and usable forms of nutrients, restricting precipitation and insolubilization processes that are widely established for many conventional fertilizers (e.g., phosphate fertilizers). Nanoparticle’s unique properties, such as tunable physico-chemical properties and the ability to cross the plant cell wall, can increase nutrient uptake in the plant root. As a result, nanoparticles are more effective nutrient carriers for plants than conventional fertilizers, proving that nanoparticles are a promising tool in general, particularly for soilless growing systems.
2.1. R&D and Innovation on Nanotechnology Approaches in Aerated Soilless Farming
As previously stated, the R&D focus in aerated soilless farming is on optimizing nutrient solutions to increase nutrient uptake and minimize nutrient wastage, as well as the growing system method. The role of nanotechnology in this particular aspect is to resolve several issues involved in the mixture of nutrient solutions, as previously explained, and to maximize nutrient uptake, thereby increasing crop productivity and quality. Plant trait improvement against environmental disease and stress has also been studied. The recent R&D on nanotechnology approaches to improving soilless nutrient solutions is tabulated in Table 1. Positive effects of high uptake of Fe
2O
3 nanoparticles on hydroponically grown spinach were observed; increased stem and root lengths, biomass production, and magnetic properties [
99]. The high magnetic properties indicate a high iron content, which is known to be beneficial to human health. Another study examined the effects of ZnO nanoparticles (25 nm) and bulk or natural form (1000 nm, bulk ZnO) on tobacco (
Nicotiana tabacum L.) seedlings for 21 days in a nutrient solution supplemented with either ZnO nanoparticles, bulk ZnO, or ZnSO
4 (as a control) [
100]. ZnO nanoparticles outperformed bulk-ZnO in terms of growth (root and shoot length/dry weight), leaf surface area and its metabolites, leaf enzymatic activities, and anatomical properties (root, stem, cortex, and central cylinder diameters). Haghighi et al. successfully alleviate the negative effects of heat stress in hydroponically grown tomatoes by incorporating bulk Se and Se nanoparticles in abiotic stress management, specifically with exposure to high and low-temperature stress [
101]. When compared to bulk Se and the control, Se nanoparticles significantly increased chlorophyll content. SiO
2 nanoparticles have been shown to promote seed coat resistance and improve nutritional availability in maize plants [
102]. Direct uptake of nano-sized silica by seeds is improved in a hydroponic incubation, which creates a potential barrier for plants such as maize. Zein nanoparticles derived from the maize enzyme have been proposed as effective delivery systems for agrochemicals to sugar cane plants, with a significant amount successfully translocated to the leaves using the fluorescence tracking method [
103]. Therefore, all of these studies demonstrated that nutrient nanoparticles outperformed their bulk counterparts, proving our previous claim that nanoparticles are more efficient nutrient carriers for plants than conventional fertilizers.
Aside from that, contaminated water is a major issue in the soilless farming industry because water is a key component in the nutrient solution. Water contaminants include nitrates, phosphates, fertilizers, pesticides, bacteria, viruses, and toxic metals. As a result, eliminating these contaminants is critical to avoid unnecessary residue in food, as well as crop growth and productivity disruption. In this regard, research has shown that nanomaterials can be tailored to curtail this contaminant found in water that occurs naturally or as a result of industrial activity. For example, in hydroponically cultured garlic, Se nanoparticles were found to be less phytotoxic and to have a greater capacity for Hg sequestration than SeO
32− and SeO
42− [
104]. The study also discovered that Se nanoparticles captured a large amount of Hg
2+ by forming HgSe and HgSe nanoparticles, preventing Hg
2+ from entering the root stele and thus inhibiting Hg translocation and accumulation in the aerial parts. In addition to immobilizing Hg, Se nanoparticles promoted the conversion of Hg
2+ in plants to less toxic binding forms. Another study looked at the effect of ZnO nanoparticles on heavy metal uptake and accumulation in hydroponically grown romaine lettuce [
105]. Cd and Pb accumulation in roots was reduced by 49% and 81%, respectively, according to the findings. Huang et al. discovered that adding nanomaterials such as graphene oxide, hydroxyapatite nanoparticles (20 and 40 nm), Fe
3O
4 nanoparticles, and nano-zerovalent Fe to hydroponically grown rice reduced arsenic uptake [
106]. As the arsenic concentration increased, the weight of the aboveground parts of the seedlings decreased with the addition of nanomaterials. When compared to the control, the addition of various nanomaterials could boost seedling growth without the use of arsenic. Fe
3O
4 nanoparticles and nano-zerovalent Fe outperformed other nanomaterials in preventing arsenic from reaching the aboveground parts of rice seedlings. The addition of Ag nanoparticles has been reported to have potential in reducing antimony uptake and translocation in hydroponically grown soybean, opening up new avenues for food safety in antimony-contaminated areas [
107].
Some nanomaterials have been shown in early nano-ecotoxicological studies to be toxic not only to plants, but also to a variety of soil microorganisms such as bacteria, fungi, and yeast [
108,
109]. In this regard, achieving sustainable agriculture intersects with the need to balance the benefits of nano-products in addressing environmental issues with the identification and management of potential environmental, health, and safety threats posed by nanoscale materials [
110]. Because nanomaterials or nano-products are not intended to harm human health or the environment over the course of their life cycle, they should be included in the design and safety evaluation of engineered nanomaterials (ENMs) [
111]. The method would promote nanomaterials that are safer by nature by taking into account both applications and consequences. This means that before the preparation of nanomaterials, their actions should be thoroughly investigated. ZnO nanoparticles, for example, were discovered to be capable of concentrating in the rhizosphere, entering root cells, and inhibiting ryegrass (
Lolium perenne L.) seedling growth [
112]. According to Zhao et al., Y
2O
3 nanoparticles and released Y
3+ did not affect rice germination rate. Low concentrations of Y
2O
3 nanoparticles (1, 5, and 10 mg/L) improved rice root elongation [
113]. Notably, when the concentration of Y
2O
3 nanoparticles reached 20 mg/L or higher, root elongation was significantly inhibited. According to physiological and biochemical characteristics, Y
2O
3 nanoparticles at concentrations ranging from 20 to 100 mg/L significantly reduced chlorophyll contents and root activity in rice seedlings. ICP-MS and TEM analyses revealed that Y
2O
3 nanoparticles and Y
3+ were primarily absorbed and accumulated in the roots. ZnO nanoparticles treatments at all tested concentrations (10, 50, and 250 mg/L) decreased growth, total chlorophyll content, and soluble proteins while increasing carotenoids, lipid peroxidation, hydrogen peroxide, and electrolyte leakage in leaf when compared to the control [
114]. These modifications, along with increased proline content and activities of superoxide dismutase, catalase, and guaiacol peroxidase in the treated plants, suggest that ZnO nanoparticles induced oxidative stress. The phytotoxicity effect of ZnO nanoparticles is indicated by a reduction in nettle-leaved goosefoot (
Chenopodiastrum murale L.) growth.
In terms of sensing applications in soilless farming systems, nano-sensing R&D focuses on detecting and quantifying the amount of supplemental nutrients to ensure the availability of the interested nutrient throughout the cultivation process. Xu et al. developed a disposable phosphate sensor using a screen-printed electrode (SPE) modified with cobalt nanoparticles [
115]. The results showed that cobalt nanoparticles improve the sensor’s detection limit in the initial state. Meanwhile, the corrosion of cobalt nanoparticles causes significant time drift and electrode instability. The disposable phosphate detection chip, on the other hand, has a linear range of 10
−1–10
−5 mol/L, a coefficient of variation of 0.5%, and a sensitivity of 33 mV/decade.
Other soilless farming techniques, such as aquaponics and aeroponics, are advancing at a rapid but limited rate in nanotechnology research. Luo et al. investigated the effects of nano-Se supplementation on Koi carp growth, ornamental features, and health status, as well as lettuce yield and water quality, in aquaponic conditions [
116]. Nano-Se, Premix, spirulina, bentonite, Ca(H
2PO
4)
2, soybean meal, wheat flour, rice bran, fish meal, and water make up the dietary supplement. When compared to the control group, the addition of nano-Se increased the weight gain rate of Koi carp in the 0.6 and 1.2 mg/kg nano-Se groups. Nano-Se supplementation was found to improve koi growth performance, health status, and ornamental quality while not reducing lettuce yield. In another study, the foliar spray of nano-fertilizer containing 60% of humic acid on aquaponically grown mint plants (
Mentha × piperita L.) increased the fresh and dry weight of the shoot and root as compared to the control [
117]. Nano-fertilizer increased chlorophyll content, soluble sugars, photochemical quantum yield, and photosynthesis efficiency index when compared to the control plants. In an aeroponic method, the effect of iron chelate and nano iron chelate fertilizer supplementation on chicory (
Cichorium intybus L.) was investigated. The plant treated with nano-Se had the highest plant height, root length, root and shoot dry weight, leaf area, chlorophyll content, and carotenoid content.
Invention on aerated soilless farming is primarily concerned with improving the culture method and developing novel nutrient solutions as shown in Table 2. A patent has been filed, for example, to introduce the utility model of an indoor micro-bubble hydroponic device [
114]. The utility model effectively incorporates micro-nano bubbler techniques and a controllable planting environment, makes full use of the family’s indoor environment, improves plantation efficiency, is simple to manage, saves energy, and has a variety of cultivation functions. A hydroponic seedling method of producing strong seedlings in a short period of time by using a hydroponic culture medium containing micro-nano bubbles has also been patented [
114]. This method can reduce seedling damage and fall, thereby improving seedling quality and yield.
Hiking University of Science and Technology, Taiwan, patented a modified aquaponics system or fish-and-food symbiosis system in 2017 to reduce the cost and efficiency of the aquaponic system [
114]. They use a photocatalytic catalyst reduction reaction filtration mode so that the water in the aquaculture tank containing fish excrement passes through a composite filter material of activated carbon nano-silver photocatalyst that has been irradiated with ultraviolet light. Following filtering, the water flows to the planting tube for plant cultivation, effectively overcoming the shortcomings of the traditional fish and vegetable symbiosis method, which involved complicated filtering devices, and achieving the breeding habit of changing fish and vegetable symbiosis, as well as a low-cost advantage. Seed germination and subsequent plant cultivation on agar nutrient medium containing nanoparticles such as Fe nanoparticles, Zn nanoparticles, and Cu nanoparticles of copper were patented as part of the proposed method for plant cultivation [
118]. The invention aims to develop a method for cultivating plants on a nutrient medium containing nanoparticles of essential elements that improve seed germination as well as morphometric and/or physiological parameters of plants, resulting in higher-quality planting content.
An invention on a nano concentrate, a nano-lipid stable emulsion, a method of preparing a nano lipid concentrate, and a lipid delivery device for use as a carrier for the industrial, medical as well as animal, horticultural and agricultural chemistries were also patented [
119]. Moreover, a process for delivering a liquid nano lipid particle system to a target that includes a plant, water for hydroponics, water for aeroponics, soil, manure, potting soil, an insect, an animal, a human being, machinery, pest surface areas, and plant surface areas has also been introduced [
120]. The aquaponic system’s fish culture water body was treated with a nano catalyst composed of TiO
2 nanoparticles, magnesia nanoparticles, medical stone, purple clay, tourmaline, and zeolite. These nanocatalysts are intended to accelerate the decomposition and fermentation of fish excrement, resulting in a small molecular nutrient that can be consumed by vegetables as soon as possible. The nano-catalysis aquaponics method has the advantages of a fast catalysis rate, rapid decomposition of fish excrement, and the ability to reduce aquaponics startup time, save energy, and increase aquaponics production performance.
Table 1. Some of the most recent R&D on nanotechnology approaches to improving hydroponic nutrient solutions.
The Incorporation of Nanoparticles into Nutrient Solutions |
Type of Crops |
Method of Soilless Cultivation |
Finding |
Ref. |
Fe2O3 nanoparticles (30–40 nm) at concentrations of 100, 150, and 200 mg are mixed with Hoagland nutrient solution |
Spinach (Spinacia oleracea L.) |
Hydroponic |
According to the findings, adding nano Fe2O3 to spinach boost its growth rate in a dose- and time-dependent manner. After 45 days, the stems and roots of spinach grown in various Fe2O3 concentrations at 100, 150, and 200 mg, are approximately 1.45, 1.91, respectively, and 2.27 and 1.25, 1.38, and 1.75, respectively, times longer than the control spinach. |
[99] |
ZnO nanoparticles (25 nm) at concentrations of 0.2, 1, 5 and 25 µg are mixed with Johnson nutrient solution |
Tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) |
Hydroponic |
When compared to the control, Nano-ZnO increased biomass indices such as root and shoot main and lateral lengths, as well as root and shoot weight. Low or middle levels of ZnO nanoparticles increased amino acids, phenolic compounds, proline, reducing sugars, and flavonoids whereas 25 µM ZnO nanoparticles did not increase proline or flavonoids. Nano-ZnO application increased the activity of superoxide dismutase, peroxidase, glutathione peroxidase, and polyphenol oxidase more than bulk-ZnO application. |
[100] |
Se nanoparticles (8–15 nm) at concentrations of 1, 4, 8 and 12 µM are mixed with a nutrient solution mixture of N (116 mg L−1), P (21 mg L−1), K (82 mg L−1), Ca (125 mg L−1), Mg (21 mg L−1), S (28 mg L−1), Fe (6.8 mg L−1), Mn (1.97 mg L−1), Zn (0.25 mg L−1), B (0.70 mg L−1), Cu (0.07 mg L−1), and Mo (0.05 mg L−1) |
tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.) |
Hydroponic |
The study discovered that both bulk Se (at concentrations of 2.5, 5, and 8 µM) and Se nanoparticles (at concentrations of 4, 8, and 12 µM) had positive effects on tomato growth parameters by increasing the fresh and dry weight and diameter of the shoots, as well as the fresh and dry weight and volume of the roots. In terms of chlorophyll content of tomato leaves grown under low-temperature stress (10 °C for 24 h), Se nanoparticles (27.5%) outperformed bulk Se (19.2%). |
[101] |
SiO2 nanoparticles (20–40 nm) at a concentration of 1% w/v is mixed with Hoagland nutrient solution |
Maize (Zea mays L.) |
Hydroponic |
Hydroponically grown maize absorbed SiO2 nanoparticles at a rate of 18.2%, resulting in a 95.5% increase in germination, a 6.5 % increase in dry weight, and better nutrient alleviation in seeds exposed to SiO2 nanoparticles than in seeds exposed to bulk silicon of SiO2, Na2SiO3 and H4SiO4 and control. |
[102] |
Zein nanoparticles (135 nm) at concentrations of 0.88 and 1.75 mg/mL are mixed with Hoagland nutrient solution |
Sugar cane (Saccharum officinarum L.) |
Hydroponic |
After 12 h of exposure to zein nanoparticles, the concentration of nanoparticles adhering to sugar cane roots varied with dosage, with 110.2 µg NPs/mg dry weight of root in a low dose nanoparticle suspension (0.88 mg/mL) and 342.5 µg NPs/mg dry weight of root in a high dose nanoparticle suspension (1.75 mg/mL). The translocated nanoparticles were then observed in leaves with 4.8 µg NPs/mg dry weight of leaves in a low dose nanoparticle suspension (0.88 mg/mL) and 12.9 µg NPs/mg dry weight of leaves in a high dose nanoparticle suspension (1.75 mg/mL). |
[103] |
Hoagland nutrient solution was used in the early phase, and after the third leaf had fully expanded, hydroxyapatite nanoparticles (94–163 nm) at concentrations of 2, 20, 200, 500, 1000, and 2000 mg L−1 were mixed with 1% w/v carboxymethylcellulose |
Tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.) |
Hydroponic |
There were no phytotoxic effects on tomato plants grown in hydroponics with hydroxyapatite nanoparticles and increasing the concentration of the nano-mixture induces root elongation. For 200 and 500 mg L−1, the increase in root length was +64% and +97%, respectively, when compared to the control. |
[108] |
Fe3O4 nanoparticles or TiO2 nanoparticles (10–30 nm) at concentrations of 50 and 500 mg/L are mixed with nutrient solution mixture of N (11.0 mM), P (1.2 mM), Ca (4.0 mM), K (7.0 mM), S (2.41 µM), Fe (17.8 µM), Zn (5.0 µM), Mn (10.0 µM) and Cu (2.7 µM) |
Tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.) |
Hydroponic |
When compared to the control and seedlings exposed to Fe3O4 nanoparticles, seedlings grown with high concentrations of TiO2 nanoparticles displayed an irregular proliferation of root hairs one week after the start of the nanoparticle treatment. Tomato seedlings grown under different conditions had similar shoot morphology, and plants treated with nanoparticles showed no signs of toxicity. |
[121] |
Cu-Fe2O4 nanoparticles at concentrations of 0.0, 0.04, 0.2, 1, and 5ppm are mixed with Hoagland nutrient solution |
Cucumber (Cucumis sativus L.) |
Hydroponic |
After being exposed to Cu-Fe2O4 nanoparticles, cucumber plants’ fresh weight and protein content increased. The activities of superoxide dismutase and peroxidase were also substantially higher in cucumber shoots and roots. The use of Cu-Fe2O4 nanoparticles improved the absorption of Fe and Cu by cucumber tissues significantly. |
[122] |
Chitosan nanoparticles (149 nm) or chitosan-indole-3-acetic acid nanoparticles (183 nm) at various ratio are mixed with La Molina nutrient solution |
Lettuce (Latuca sativa L.) |
Hydroponic |
Hydroponically grown lettuce treated with chitosan nanoparticles and chitosan-indole-3-acetic acid nanoparticles exhibits significant increases of 42.6% and 30.9%, respectively, compared to the control. In terms of the effect on leaf size, chitosan nanoparticles outperformed other treatments with the largest leaves. |
[123] |
Table 2. Some of the recent patent on nanotechnology approaches in aerated soilless farming.
Patent No./Year/Title |
Method of Soilless Cultivation |
Invention |
Ref. |
N102701844B/2012/Rich-selenium-germanium trace element nanometer nutrition fertilizer for vegetable and fruit soilless culture |
Hydroponic |
The invention describes the preparation and manufacture of nutritional fertilizer rich in selenium and germanium trace elements for vegetable and fruit cultivation in courtyards or balconies using soilless cultivation. |
[124] |
CN206354136U/2017/A kind of indoor micro-nano bubble hydroponic device |
Hydroponic |
The current utility model’s cultivation cabinet is a semi-hermetic layer stereo system, with the bottom opening passage effectively carrying out indoor and cultivation cabinet air exchange with reference to the ventilation ventilating fan. Aeration will be used by the micro-nano bubble generator to generate the other micro/nano level water vapor bubbles. The amount of dissolved oxygen increases the nutrient solution essentially. |
[125] |
JP2015097515A/2013/Hydroponic raising seedling method, and hydroponic culture method |
Hydroponic |
The invention is to provide a hydroponic seedling system capable of raising a strong seedling and shortening the seedling raising period by adding a hydroponic solution containing micro-nano bubbles during the plant seedling period. |
[126] |
KR20130086099A/2012/The method manufacture silver nano antimicrobial & lacquer tree a composite in uses functionality crop |
Hydroponic |
The current innovation is a method of growing functional crops using a silver nano antibacterial agent and a lacquer composition through hydroponic cultivation. |
[127] |
CN105417674A/2015/Preparation method and application of micro-nano sparkling water |
Hydroponic |
The invention reveals a method for preparing micro-nano sparkling water, which benefits the field of scientific and technological agriculture in areas such as soilless production, fruit and vegetable washing, biological repair, dirty water processing, and so on. |
[128] |
WO2017101691A1/2015/The method for cultivation of plants using metal nanoparticles and the nutrient medium for its implementation |
Hydroponic |
Seed germination and subsequent plant cultivation on an aseptic agar nutrient medium containing a variety of organic and inorganic components important for plant growth, such as iron, zinc, and copper in the form of electro-neutral metal nanoparticles. Chitosan can also be added to the nutrient medium. This process improves seed germination as well as plant physiological and morphological indices such as root length and root behavior, chlorophyll content in leaves, sprout length, and green mass yield. |
[118] |
KR20060055895A/2004/Silver nano-containing bean sprouts manufacturing equipment |
Hydroponic |
The present invention relates to the production of bean sprouts for cultivation with silver-containing water when the bean sprouts are cultivated. |
[129] |
CN203482710U/2013/Oxygenation and disinfection device for soilless cultivation nutrient solution |
Hydroponic |
A filter, an oxygen generator, an ozone generator, a rapid micro-nano bubble generator, and an ultraviolet disinfector are all part of the soil-free nutrient solution oxygenation and disinfection system. |
[130] |
AU2015370052B2/2014/Nano particulate delivery system |
Hydroponic and aeroponic |
The invention describes a system for delivering nano lipids, more specifically a nano concentrate, a nano lipid stable emulsion, a method for preparing nano lipid concentrates, and a system for delivering lipids for use as a carrier in manufacturing, medical, animal, horticultural, and agricultural chemistry. |
[119] |
AU2016202162B2/2012/Plant nutrient coated nanoparticles and methods for their preparation and us |
Hydroponic and aeroponic |
The invention describes a nanofertilizer with at least one plant nutrient coated on a metal nanoparticle that is made by combining a metal salt and a plant nutrient in an aqueous medium and then adding a reducing agent to the solution to form a coated metal nanoparticle. |
[131] |
TW201902343A/2017/Fish and vegetable symbiosis system including a support, at least one planting unit, a filtering unit, and a breeding unit |
Aquaponic |
The invention discloses a fish and vegetable symbiosis system comprising a support, at least one planting unit, one filtering unit, and one breeding unit. For water quality filling, the fish and vegetable symbiosis device is outfitted with an artificial closed form of composite filter material-activated carbon nano silver photocatalyst. |
[132] |
CN104719233A/2015/Nano-catalysis aquaponics method |
Aquaponic |
The invention includes nano-catalyst aquaponics preparation steps involving the use of purple grit dust, tourmaline, nano-titanium, nano-magnesia, medical stone, and zeolite. |
[120] |