Effects of Physical Activity and Type 2 Diabetes: History
Please note this is an old version of this entry, which may differ significantly from the current revision.
Contributor: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) is one of the most widespread diseases worldwide. Lifestyle interventions, including diet and physical activity (PA), are fundamental non-pharmacological components of T2DM therapy. Exercise interventions are strongly recommended for people with or at risk of developing or already with overt diabetes, but adherence to PA guidelines in this population is still challenging. Furthermore, the heterogeneity of T2DM patients, driven by differing residual β-cell functionality, as well as the possibility of practicing different types and intensities of PA, has led to the need to develop tailored exercise and training plans.

  • type 2 diabetes
  • physical activity
  • exercise
  • β-cell function
  • insulin resistance

1. Introduction

T2DM is a chronic metabolic disorder characterized by high glucose levels, driven by the disruption of the physiologic balance between tissue sensitivity to insulin action, changes in plasma glucose and insulin secretion, β-cell function, and mass. In particular, impairments in β-cell function [1,2] can affect the dynamics of insulin secretion even at a very early stage of the disease [3,4]. The increased morbidity and mortality in T2DM patients [5] can be mostly ascribed to metabolic dysregulation and chronic inflammation leading to atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease (ASCVD). Lifestyle interventions, including appropriate diet and physical activity (PA), constitute an important non-pharmacological aspect of T2DM therapy, and their effectiveness in the prevention of T2DM-associated ASCVD has been amply demonstrated [6]. PA improves glycemic control [7] in patients with diabetes by enhancing insulin secretion and insulin sensitivity [8,9], and by stimulating glucose uptake by skeletal muscle and reducing body weight against a background of poor β-cell function. In addition, PA may counter inflammation related to pancreatic β-cell dysfunction [10] via circulating mediators, reducing oxidative stress and increasing the levels of antioxidants [11,12,13]. In this regard, some meta-analyses have shown that aerobic training, resistance training, and the combination of the two improve glycemic control and HbA1c levels [14,15,16], together with significant improvements in anthropometric, cardiovascular, and metabolic risk factors [16,17]. Other studies have found associations between PA and diabetes remission rate in newly diagnosed subjects [18,19,20]. Anyway, it should be underlined that improvements in glucose tolerance and glucose homeostasis were only achieved through PA in combination with pharmacologic treatment and/or an appropriate dietary regimen in these studies, providing evidence that PA is a necessary, but not sufficient, strategy for achieving partial or complete remission from the disease.

3. Effects of Physical Activity on β-Cell Function and Insulin Secretion

Insulin resistance and β-cell dysfunction are fundamental metabolic defects of T2DM, and these conditions are already partially present in obese subjects with prediabetes [25]. The preservation of residual β-cell function in individuals with obesity and IGT—who have already lost up to 50–70% of β-cell function—is an effective strategy to prevent T2DM [26,27]. The mechanism linking PA and β-cell function is still not fully understood; however, it has been demonstrated that exercise interventions and correct dietary management may protect β-cell function by reducing metabolic stress [28]. Exercise training has a potential role in preserving β-cell health, and, therefore, represents an effective strategy to prevent or delay diabetes onset in individuals at risk of or already affected by the disease; moreover, PA supports pharmacological effectiveness to prevent β-cell failure [10].
It can be difficult to estimate the relative contribution of a single type of PA to β-cell protection, as well as the correct timing for exercise interventions in patients with metabolic impairments, but there is evidence that exercise, when started at an early stage, may delay disease progression by increasing β-cell resistance to endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress [29] and other mediators of immune damage [10]. Several trials have studied the effect of exercise on insulin secretion in individuals with T2DM and prediabetes [8,9,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37], as well as in sedentary overweight or obese subjects [8,35,36,38,39,40,41]. Some of these studies have investigated the effects of different intensities of aerobic training [8,9,30,32,34,35,36,37,40], while others have evaluated high-intensity interval training (HIIT) [42,43], resistance training [31,36], and simultaneous aerobic and resistance training or a combination of the two [38,39,41] on metabolic outcomes.
In conclusion, in the cited trials, it is important to note that only interventions lasting more than 2 months resulted in improvements in insulin secretion, and that all training regimens led to benefits regarding insulin secretion. This emphasizes that significant results can only be achieved following an appropriate exercise program, whereas random exercise sessions might not result in significant improvements in glucose metabolism or cardiovascular outcomes.

4. Responsiveness to Physical Activity

Despite the well-recognized positive impact of PA on β-cell function and insulin secretion, individuals with different secretory functions at baseline may show different responses to interventions, and a variable proportion of patients have been described as exercise resistant in several studies. Dela et al. [9] stratified patients with T2DM into “moderate” and “low” secretors according to individual C-peptide responses to an intravenous glucagon test. They found that only moderate secretors obtained positive responses from an aerobic training program, thus highlighting that a residual β-cell secretory capacity is required in order to maximize the beneficial effect of aerobic exercise on glycemic control. In addition, to further investigate how baseline β-cell function may influence training-induced changes in glycemic control, the HERITAGE study [34] assessed insulin secretion patterns during an IVGTT in a large heterogenic population to detect possible differences in β-cell functional effects in response to a 20-week endurance training program (cycle ergometers 3 days/week for 60 sessions). Participants with better glucose tolerance at baseline showed reduced insulin secretion following regular exercise, while those with poorer glucose tolerance at baseline showed an increase in insulin secretion after exercise. These results suggest that intersubject variability in baseline β-cell function could partially explain the different effects of exercise on glucose homeostasis. In this context, intersubject variability in basal insulin secretion could provide an effective explanation for the different secretory responses to exercise and should be considered when prescribing tailored and individualized treatments. Consistently, another study confirmed this variability by demonstrating that long-term exposure to hyperglycemia –leading to reduced β-cell function [48] and low insulin secretory function—before the introduction of PA predict a poorer training-induced outcome. Thus, aerobic exercise may be less effective in improving glucose control in patients with poorly controlled long-term T2DM. Accordingly, another study [36] confirmed that the response to exercise in prediabetic and diabetic subjects largely depends on basal β-cell function: in particular, basal HbA1c, BMI, and β-cell function were all predictors of exercise response in elderly patients with prediabetes; by contrast, the type of PA did not predict the effectiveness of the response. In this context, residual β-cell function should be restored through appropriate pharmacological treatment by eliminating the noxious effects of gluco- and lipotoxicity before therapeutic aerobic exercise can provide effective improvements in glucose homeostasis. Collectively, these data strongly support the need for individualized treatments in order to maximize the benefit of exercise.
A recent study [18] investigated the effectiveness of a 12- or 24-month intensive lifestyle program in inducing partial or complete T2DM remission compared to standard of care, demonstrating that 23% of participants in the lifestyle intervention group met the criteria for any T2DM remission compared to 7% in the standard care group. Further, the highest remission rate was obtained in participants with well-controlled short-duration T2DM.

5. Exercise Regimens for T2DM

As shown in Table 2, many types of PA can improve glycemic control and lead to overall benefits in people with T2DM. To date, aerobic and resistance training, and the combination of both, have formed the cornerstone of lifestyle intervention for T2DM patients, as previously mentioned. Aerobic training, like running and cycling for about 1 h, is a moderate-intensity type of PA and represents the best activity to reduce body fat mass when required. Moreover, it leads to improvements in oxygen transport and metabolism in the skeletal and heart muscle [50]. Resistance training, on the other hand, is strength-building, as it increases lean body mass, and is characterized by short-term exercise repetitions performed by using, for example, external resistance tools like dumbbells, kettlebells, and barbells, or using body weight, weight machines, or elastic resistance bands.

Table 2. Type of physical exercise for adults with T2DM.
Type of Exercise Description Intensity Frequency Duration Proven Benefits Additional Specification
Aerobic Training Rhythmic and repetitive PA that uses large muscle groups, e.g., running, cycling, swimming, dancing, jogging Moderate
(55–74% HRmax)
or
Vigorous
(75–95% HRmax)
5–7 d/week with no more than two consecutive days between bouts At least 30′/session for
≥150′/week of moderate activity
or ≥75′/week of vigorous activity
(or an equivalent combination of moderate- and vigorous-intensity, preferably spread throughout the week).
↓ Glycemia with fewer daily hyperglycemic excursions
↓ HbA1c
↑ Insulin sensitivity
↓ Blood lipids
↓ BP
↑ Fitness levels, even without weight loss
-
Resistance Training Short-term repetition exercises performed using external resistance tools like dumbbells, kettlebells, and barbells, or using body weight, weight machines, or elastic resistance bands Moderate (50–69% of 1-RM)
or
Vigorous (70–85% of 1-RM)
2–3 d/week on non-consecutive days 10–15 repetitions/set with 1–3 sets per type of specific exercise ↑ Strength
↑ Bone mineral density
↑ Lean mass
↓ BP
↓ Blood lipids
↑ Insulin sensitivity
↓ HbA1c
-
Pilates Specific targeted exercises to improve strength, flexibility, and posture, with particular focus on the core Light ≥2–3 d/week - ↑ Blood glucose management
↑ Functional capacity
For patients with low levels of fitness and insufficient balance
Yoga Breath, movement, and meditation to unite mind, body, and spirit Light ≥2–3 d/week - ↓ HbA1c
↓ Blood lipids
↑ Improvement body composition
For patients with low levels of fitness and insufficient balance
Balance Focuses on the ability to maintain proper posture and refers to exercises that are designed to improve and maintain balance Light ≥2–3 d/week - - ↓Risk of falls by improving balance and gait, even in adults with peripheral neuropathy
Flexibility Stretching and moving a joint through its range of motion Light ≥2–3 d/week 10″–30″ per
stretch (static or dynamic) group; 2–4 repetitions of each
- ↑ Joint range-of-motion; facilitates participation in activities that require flexibility
HIIT
F-HIT
HIIT: repetitions of short intervals of vigorous aerobic training (running or cycling) alternating with a short period of active or passive recovery.
F-HIT: based on real-world situational exercises at a high intensity by combining resistance training, gymnastics (body weight), and aerobic exercise
Vigorous (75–95% HRmax) follow by active or passive recovery 3 d/week Repetitions of 10″–4′ of vigorous activity with 12″–5′ of active or passive recovery ↑ Insulin sensitivity
↑ β-cell function in T2DM with preserved residual β-cell secretory capacity
↑ Fitness levels
↓ HbA1c
↓ BMI
↑ CGM
-
Key and abbreviations: ↑: increased; ↓: decreased; HIIT: high-intensity interval training; F-HIT: functional high-intensity training; T2DM: type 2 diabetes mellitus; HbA1c: glycosylated hemoglobin; 1-RM: 1-repetition maximum; HRmax: heart rate max; BMI: body mass index; CGM: continuous glucose monitoring; BP: blood pressure; PA: physical activity.

6. Adherence and the “Lack of Time”

Currently, there are many lifestyle-related obstacles to the achievement of the minimum recommended PA levels. One of the main barriers to adherence is “lack of time” [69]. Guidelines advocate at least 5 h of aerobic, resistance, and flexibility training spread out over 5 days per week, but compliance and adherence to these recommendations is very low; in fact, only 10–23% of people adhere to these recommendations in the USA [70]. In addition, the estimation of PA, using a structured 7-day physical activity recall interview in medically treated T2DM individuals with atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease or with cardiovascular risk factors, revealed that fitness levels were very low and almost half the participants failed to reach the minimum PA recommendation levels [71]. In this context, “lack of time” represents one of the main reasons for non-adherence to therapeutic exercise programs. Thus, additional efforts are needed in order to promote greater adherence to guidelines by prescribing tailored PA programs. In addition, it should be considered that the extent of the beneficial effects—such as the improvement of glucose homeostasis and the reduction in cardiometabolic risk factors in people with diabetes—is dependent on the total energy expenditure of training rather than exercise duration or intensity [72,73]. In particular, the American College of Sports Medicine (ACSM) recommends that T2DM patients undergo at least 1000 kcal/week of energy expenditure and that men and women expend between 1000 and 2000 kcal/week to obtain cardiometabolic benefits [23]. Therefore, new PA high-intensity exercise protocols (e.g., HIIT and F-HIT) have been studied as possible alternatives with which to improve adherence in people with a “lack of time”. High-intensity exercise protocols have been proposed as time-efficient methods to achieve cardio-metabolic health outcomes, equivalent to traditional aerobic training programs [74]. In addition, HIIT could be an effective protocol to use to meet the 1000–2000 kcal/week expenditure goal.

7. Nutrition and Physical Activity

Together with PA, nutrition is another fundamental non-pharmacological milestone in T2DM therapy. Over the last years, many recommendations [78,79,80,81] have been put forth by scientific communities to help clinicians in the prescription of the most appropriate nutritional intervention in subjects with T2DM: in fact, by promoting weight loss and ameliorating insulin sensitivity, diet and PA together can lead to improved blood glucose and blood pressure profiles, as well lipid levels, with effectiveness for CV safety [82]. However, adherence in clinical practice seems to be generally poor [25], and more effort should be put in building combined and tailored nutritional/exercise plans to improve overall compliance. The study of food metabolism is complex, and its consequences on overall health depend on the interrelationships among nutrients and bioactive non-nutrients (antioxidants, fiber, minerals, etc.) rather than single nutrients alone; for these reasons, in recent decades, more emphasis has been put on the quality of one’s diet [83] and possible dietary patterns according to individual goals. The Mediterranean diet deserves special mention: it is characterized by the consumption of whole grain, legumes, fruits, vegetables, nuts, olive oil, and moderate intake of wine and meat, providing an important apport of vitamins, minerals, anti-oxidants, mono- and poly-unsaturated fatty acids, and fibers. It has recently been demonstrated to correlate with more favorable cardiovascular risk factors profile, better glucose control, and lower BMI [84].
In accordance with the 2020–2025 US Dietary Guidelines for Americans, a healthy eating plan should provide the appropriate daily caloric intake. It should emphasize the consumption of fruits, vegetables, and whole grains; include reduced or non-fat dairy products, lean meats, poultry, fish, beans, eggs, and nuts; and keep saturated and trans fats, cholesterol, salt, and added sugar intake low. A whole foods-based diet is rich in micronutrients and antioxidants, and is beneficial for preventing and managing T2DM [85]. 
Among all dietary approaches, carbohydrate restriction has been shown to reduce body weight and improve glycemia [25], and the use of popular diet options (i.e., low carbohydrate, ketogenic diet) and other eating patterns (i.e., Mediterranean, vegan) are frequently followed for T2DM management [86].

8. Conclusions

Future approaches to lifestyle intervention in patients with T2DM should certainly consider customized prescription of PA. A tailored training plan should be based on accurate phenotyping, which takes into account the type of diabetes, time since diagnosis, age, sex variabilities, and the presence of diabetes-related complications. Moreover, PA regimens should consider intrasubject variabilities driven by different residual β-cell function; in this scenario, the assessment of the disposition index could be an effective way to establish residual β-cell capacity. To date, considerable evidence has shown that the combination of aerobic and resistance training exerts major effects on glucose regulation in T2DM patients, as well as on the prevention of T2DM-associated ASCVD. However, alternative regimens, such as high-intensity exercise protocols, should be considered in selected patients to maximize the time-effectiveness of PA.

This entry is adapted from the peer-reviewed paper 10.3390/nu15194202

This entry is offline, you can click here to edit this entry!
ScholarVision Creations