2. The Role of CFTR Dysfunction in Phagocytes: A Paradigm Shift
2.1. Monocyte/Macrophages
Macrophages represent the first line of defense against pathogens in the lungs and are divided into tissue-resident and recruited (monocyte-derived macrophages [MDMs]); tissue-resident macrophages are further divided in alveolar (which reside in the airway lumen) and interstitial (located in the lung parenchyma)
[31][16].
Alveolar macrophages are the dominant immune cell in the steady state and conduct several functions: ensure and modulate the inflammatory response, either directly or by the crosstalk with the adaptive immune system, actualize the bacterial killing through a complex mechanism called phagocytosis, maintain tissue homeostasis acting as scavenger cells, and participate in regeneration processes
[32,33][17][18]. The ability to promote all these functions is due to their plasticity. In 2000, Mills et al. distinguished macrophages in M1/kill and M2/repair profile on the basis of the pathway they utilize to metabolize arginine; specifically, M1 metabolize arginine to nitric oxide, an inhibitor of proliferation, whereas M2 produce ornithine, a promoter of proliferation. Macrophages are able to switch between classes, and such plasticity is important in the macrophage’s ability to regulate the acute inflammatory response
[34,35][19][20].
Whether macrophages display an M1 or M2 phenotype is dependent upon the tissue milieu. M1 responses are associated with IL-6, IL-8, IL-12, and TNF-α production and cell surface expression of CD80 or CD86, which attract neutrophils and stimulate Th1 responses and further M1-type activation. On the contrary, M2 responses are linked with TGF-β, VEGF, EGF, IL-4, and IL-13 production, cell surface expression of CD163 or CD206, and the propensity to stimulate Th2 responses such as antibody production and further amplification of M2-type activation. Appropriate activation of the inflammatory response and subsequent resolution requires a balance between macrophage subpopulations
[33,35,36][18][20][21].
Despite the clear predominance of neutrophilic infiltration, in the airways of PWCF, the absolute number of macrophages is not only increased during lung exacerbations but even from the later stages of fetal development and in young children with CF without detectable infection
[37,38,39][22][23][24]. Furthermore, as demonstrated by Meyer et al., CF macrophages display both an augmented M1 profile, responsible for a proinflammatory phenotype with high levels of IL-8, IL-6, and TNF-α and low levels of IL-10, and an exaggerated M2 profile that might contribute to remodeling processes and fibrotic changing typical of CF. In addition, the authors concluded that Azithromycin regulates profile shifting by inhibiting M1 polarization and favoring the M2 profile
[40][25]. However, bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) obtained from CF lungs contains large concentrations of TNF-α, IL-1β, IL-6, and IL-8, but little IL-10, a pattern associated with M1 polarization
[35][20]. Tarique et al. clarified these findings, obtaining MDMs from people with CF and healthy volunteers, and demonstrating that CF M2 polarization was dysfunctional as evidenced by the decreased ability to perform endocytosis
[41][26]. On the other hand, CF M1 macrophages showed a decreased phagocytic activity and the inability to switch to the M2 phenotype with a consequent imbalance of the immune-inflammatory cascade towards a pro-inflammatory state
[41][26].
Yoshimura et al. in 1991 demonstrated that
CFTR is expressed not only in epithelial cells that strongly influence the lung milieu but also in human macrophages and neutrophils
[42][27]; moreover, in macrophages, it has been detected both at the surface and intracellularly
[43][28]. Mutations in the
CFTR gene can affect macrophage function with different effects based on mutation type and in different phases of phagocytosis. In CF, the impaired macrophage function is not due exclusively to the altered epithelial environment, a hallmark of the disease, but also to a direct effect on macrophages
[43][28].
The involvement of macrophages in the creation of the proinflammatory status typical of CF was demonstrated by Bruscia et al. in their work
[44][29]. They compared the cellularity and cytokine levels in the BAL of wild-type (WT), heterozygous (HET), and CF mice after
P. aeruginosa LPS exposure using a murine in vivo model of inflammation. The lungs of CF mice showed a more robust neutrophil infiltration with higher levels of macrophage-derived cytokine that promote their migration (KC, MIP-2, IL-8) and survival (G-CSF) with a slower neutrophil clearance in comparison with WT lungs. Furthermore, the BAL of CF mice was characterized by higher concentrations of macrophage-derived cytokine that stimulate the acute inflammatory response (IL-1α, IL-6) and innate immunity (IL-12) and lower levels of IL-10 (a cytokine with anti-inflammatory function) in comparison with WT mice. In addition, authors found that HET mice and cells have a phenotype between WT and CF, and thus, a single allelic
CFTR mutation is sufficient to augment proinflammatory activation in response to LPS in CF, implying
CFTR-dependent defects in CF macrophages
[44][29]. Moreover, the direct role of CF macrophages in exacerbating the immune-inflammatory cascade was demonstrated by transplanting the bone marrow of WT into CF mice. Indeed, authors highlighted that
CFTR+/+ myeloid cells, including macrophages, significantly reduce the inflammatory response to
P. aeruginosa LPS in
CFTR−/− animals
[31,44][16][29].
Bonfield et al. reached the same conclusions using an in vivo mouse model, showing that defective myeloid
CFTR contributes to increased inflammation with elevated cytokine production, the recruitment of neutrophils, and the inability to resolve infection even in presence of functional epithelial
CFTR [45][30]. However, in the case of
CFTR dysfunction, the macrophage function is not only affected at the level of the promoted altered inflammatory response but also at the level of the phagocytosis and autophagy processes
[32,46][17][31]. When a pathogen is encountered, alveolar macrophages initiate the immune response releasing cytokines and chemokines and recruiting neutrophils and monocyte-derived macrophages (MDMs) that drive inflammation; specifically, MDMs are recruited through the release of monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1/CCL2) by macrophages that can also impact leukocyte behavior, influencing adhesion, polarization, effector molecule secretion, autophagy, killing, and survival
[32,47][17][32].
In response to pathogens, macrophages also initiate the phagocytosis process that involves several phases: (i) detection of the particle to be ingested, (ii) activation of the internalization process, (iii) formation of a specialized vacuole called a phagosome, and (iv) maturation of the phagosome to transform it into a phagolysosome
[48][33]. Macrophages sense pathogens by recognizing pathogen-associated molecules (PAMPs), such as lipopolysaccharide (LPS), flagellin, and dsRNA, through receptors known as pattern-recognition receptors (PRRs), expressed also on immune and structural cells, including airway epithelium. Furthermore, PRRs recognize the damage-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs), cytoplasmic and nuclear components such as HMGBI, ATP, and adenosine that are released into the extracellular environment by damaged cells
[31][16]. There are several types of PRRs, but TLRs have been studied most intensely in CF. In non-CF patients, when exposed to
P. aeruginosa, macrophages through the TLR4 and TLR5, expressed on their surface, initiate the pro-inflammatory cascade that activates NF-κB and MAPK signaling. On the CF macrophage surface, TLR4 is increased, whereas TLR5 is decreased, leading to excessive pro-inflammatory signaling
[35][20]. Studies suggest CF macrophages have defective bacterial killing, but the underlying mechanisms are not fully understood
[35][20]. Di et al. in their study were the first to associate the defective
CFTR function with failed alveolar macrophage lysosomal acidification, a crucial process for efficient bactericidal activity. Indeed, they showed that
CFTR protein participates in phagosomal pH control and therefore its dysfunction leads to a defective killing of internalized bacteria although the retained ability to phagocytose and generate an oxidative burst
[49][34]. Deriy et al. reached a similar conclusion finding a tight correlation between
CFTR genotype and levels of lysosomal acidification in alveolar macrophages
[50][35]. Nevertheless, these data were subsequently confuted by two studies that showed that phagolysosomal acidification in alveolar macrophages is not dependent on
CFTR channel activity
[51,52][36][37]. More recently, similar results were highlighted by Law et al. on MDMs using optical nanosensors, a novel means that accurately measures macrophage phagolysosomal pH, although this finding has to be confirmed on alveolar macrophages using the same technique
[53][38].
However, a study conducted by Riazanski et al. demonstrated that drugs are able to facilitate the activity of transient receptor potential canonical-6 (TRPC6) channel potentiating phagosome acidification and the bacterial-killing of CF macrophages
[54][39]. The major difficulty in studying the impact of a dysfunctional
CFTR on the bacterial-killing function of CF macrophages lies in the reproducibility of the observations, strongly influenced by the sensitivity of these cells to minimal changes in the environment of culture or purification. In addition, the complex cell signaling promoted in macrophages by live bacteria is extremely difficult to reproduce with opsonized beads
[31][16]. Furthermore,
CFTR−/− cell lines used in some studies as a surrogate for F508del cells represent a possible bias due to the lack of unfolded protein response (UPR); indeed, F508del mutation causes misfolding of the CFTR protein triggering the UPR, involving endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress, and NF-κB activation
[55][40].
Some studies have focused on the killing of specific pathogens by CF macrophages. A recent study demonstrated that they have impaired lysosomal degradative capacity of
B. cenocepacia, a highly virulent member of BCC, which resides in LC3-labeled autophagosomes but not of
Escherichia coli, which are enclosed in vacuoles that do not acquire LC3
[56][41]. Regarding the impaired killing of
P. aeruginosa by CF macrophages, both defective phagocytosis function and activation of autophagy might contribute to this phenomenon. Indeed, Caveolin-1, which mediates
P. aeruginosa internalization, is expressed at low levels in activated CF macrophages
[31,57,58][16][42][43].
Moreover, autophagy, a fundamental mechanism of cytoplasmic protein turnover, has been directly linked to the ineffective bactericidal function in CF macrophages. Specifically, it is defective in CF airways because of the depletion of the autophagy-related protein Beclin 1 (BECN1) with consequent accumulation of SQSTM1/p62 substrate which promotes a pro-inflammatory status sequestering misfolded ubiquitinated F508del-CFTR and anti-inflammatory proteins, such as PPARγ and IK-Bα. In their study, Ferrari et al. demonstrated that the proteostasis regulator cysteamine, which restores the function of F508del-CFTR mutant, reestablished the autophagy mechanism of CF MDMs, restoring both bacterial internalization and clearance of
P. aeruginosa through a process that involves upregulation of BECN1
[31,32,46][16][17][31].
In addition to acidification defects, CF macrophage phagosomes also have alterations in NADPH oxidase assembly and subsequent ROS production based on a decreased activation of cytosolic NADPH oxidase components, such as p47phox and p40phox, crucial for complex formation. This evidence, independent of pathogens but amplified by
B. cenocepacia, results in an impaired bacterial killing with intracellular growth of bacteria such as
B. cenocepacia,
P. aeruginosa, and
Mycobacterium abscessus [31,59,60,61][16][44][45][46].
Another alteration that might influence innate response was reported by Wright et al. who reported a failed expression of scavenger receptors such as the mannose receptor (CD206) and the macrophage receptor with collagenous structure (MARCO) by CF macrophages with consequent impaired binding and internalization of unopsonized particles as well as microbes resulting in dysfunctional phagocytosis
[62,63][47][48].
Finally, given the key role of macrophages in extracellular iron depletion, an impairing in their iron-related protein expression profile in CF, as showed by Hazlett et al., might contribute to the elevated iron levels found in CF sputum and BAL fluid. Specifically, in their study authors reported reduced ferroportin (Fpn) and augmented transferrin receptor 1 (TfR1) levels in CF MDMs compared to non-CF MDMs with consequent advantage for pathogens such as
P. aeruginosa, in whose metabolism iron plays a crucial role
[64][49].
2.2. Neutrophils
Polymorphonuclear neutrophils (PMNs) play a central role in host defense against microbes and are early mobilized during an inflammatory response, both infectious and noninfectious, from the bone marrow, where they mainly reside
[65][50]. In case of infectious stimulus, once arrived at the inflammation site driven by AECs and macrophage-derived cytokine and chemokine, they produce ROS, secrete antimicrobial peptides via the degranulation mechanism, eliminate microorganisms through phagocytosis process, and trap bacteria in neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs) endowed with antimicrobial activities
[35,66][20][51].
Neutrophils, besides their involvement in primary host defense, also contribute to the regulation of immune responses, including the amplification of inflammatory cascade. Indeed, they produce pro-inflammatory cytokines such as IL-1, IL-6, IL-7, IL-17, IFN-γ, and TNF-α
[67][52]. During phagocytosis, they confine pathogens in the phagosome and release into it different bioactive agents. These molecules are divided into two categories based on their provenience: proteins synthesized in myeloid precursors during granulopoiesis and stored in granules (serine proteases [azurocidin, proteinase-3, cathepsin G, and elastase], MMP [MMP-9], MPO, defensins, and lactoferrin) and ROS, produced de novo at the time of PMN activation by the NADPH oxidase
[65,68,69][50][53][54].
In neutrophils, granules are divided into at least four different types: (i) primary granules, also known as azurophilic granules, that are the main storage site of the most toxic mediators; (ii) secondary granules, also known as specific granules; (iii) tertiary granules, that like secondary ones contain lactoferrin and MMP-9; and (iv) secretory vesicles that contain human serum albumin. These granules are also released during the degranulation process, strictly controlled by different pathways in turn activated by receptors in the plasma membrane or by the phagosomal membrane
[70][55]. After the elimination of the pathogen, the cessation of the inflammatory response is achieved through the apoptosis of recruited neutrophils
[65][50]. In case of failed eradication of pathogens, neutrophils continue to release their arsenal of destructive enzymes and amplify the immune-inflammatory cascade, especially in diseases such as CF, in which the epithelial lung milieu is impaired in a proinflammatory sense.
In CF, neutrophils are the predominant immune cells infiltrating the airway mucosa and the intralumenal space of bronchioles (accounting for ~70% of the total cell count in BAL fluid) driven by IL-8 and IL-17 secretion; their load as well as the extracellular activity of the protease NE in BAL fluid correlates well with disease progression in CF patients, from infancy to adulthood
[71,72,73][56][57][58]. In normal homeostatic conditions, neutrophils are short-lived and undergo spontaneous apoptosis to guarantee the termination of the inflammatory insult but, similarly to macrophages, are also characterized by remarkable plasticity. Indeed, although when they leave the bone marrow neutrophils have already a default pro-apoptotic program, it can be modified by stimuli received in the target tissue including IL-8 and GM-CSF, that promote their persistence and longevity
[71,74,75][56][59][60]. IL-8, also known as CXCL8, is mainly produced by AECs and macrophages, and one of its major functions is to attract and activate neutrophils and delay their apoptosis via their IL-8 receptor (mainly CXCR2)
[76,77][61][62].
The elevated levels of IL-8 that characterize CF, given its anti-apoptotic action on neutrophils, contribute to determining the remarkable neutrophilic infiltration of the CF lung. Roussel et al. demonstrated that a dysfunctional
CFTR leads to enhanced IL-8 synthesis upon exposure to
P. aeruginosa because of the action of multiple TLRs acting redundantly. Furthermore, the decreased level of extracellular glutathione present in CF with consequent higher sensitivity to ROS further results in an increased production of IL-8 via the function of NADPH oxidase
[76,78][61][63].
In CF, in addition to IL-8/IL8R derived signaling, other pathways such as the CXCR4/CXCL12 axis and the oxygen-dependent transcription factor hypoxia-inducible factor-1α (HIF-1α) might concur in prolonging the lifespan of neutrophils consequently increasing the neutrophilic infiltration
[76,79,80][61][64][65].
Figure 1 summarizes the involvement of phagocytes and neutrophils in driving lung disease progression in CF.
Figure 1. The involvement of phagocytes and neutrophils in driving lung disease progression in cystic fibrosis. CFTR = cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator, MDMs = monocyte-derived macrophages, NETs = neutrophil extracellular traps.
Moriceau et al. theorized that the impaired apoptosis of CF neutrophils is not only linked to the chronic infectious state of CF disease, but also to CF intrinsic factors
[81][66]. They arrived at this theory by comparing the lifespan of neutrophils of CF children with that of their parents, who were heterozygotes for the
CFTR mutation but without chronic bacterial infection, without finding differences in the ability of PMN to undergo apoptosis, thus highlighting an innate PMN perturbation in CF. Nevertheless, in their study, they did not find a direct modulation of chloride conductance activity of
CFTR on this programmed death mechanism suggesting that other
CFTR functions, unknown modulatory factors, or modifying genes intrinsic to CF might be involved
[81][66].
The common thread between the high neutrophilic infiltration that characterizes CF lungs and the recurrent lung infections is represented by the altered bactericidal activity of neutrophils, notably affected by the availability of chloride
[82][67]. In detail, chloride is pivotal to modulating the phagosomal proteolytic activity of multiple serine proteases (proteinase 3, cathepsin G, NE); furthermore, it influences the phagosomal pH, in turn, a determinant for optimal activity of hydrolytic and proteolytic enzymes and for the formation of hypochlorous acid (HOCl), a potent phagosomal microbicide
[73,82][58][67]. As stated so far, it is not surprising that when bathed in a chloride-rich buffer, normal neutrophils kill
P. aeruginosa twofold faster than they do in a chloride-free buffer
[65][50]. The
CFTR channel, present in phagosomal membranes, is crucial for the chloride influx from the cytoplasm into the phagosomes; thereby a
CFTR mutation results in impaired chlorination and killing of phagocytosed pathogens, especially those that require relatively high levels of HOCl to eradicate, such as
P. aeruginosa, translating into a survival advantage
[65,83,84,85][50][68][69][70].
The impaired microbial killing of neutrophils is also linked to intracellular calcium (Ca
2+) homeostasis dysregulations. Robledo-Avila et al. in their study suggested that, in CF neutrophils, the increased intracellular concentrations of Ca
2+ may be affected by
CFTR malfunction through the involvement of the transient receptor potential (TRP) Ca
2+ channels, which allow the influx of Ca
2+ from the extracellular compartment, with consequent diminished NADPH oxidase response and impaired secretion of NETs
[73,86][58][71].
Despite the impaired bactericidal function, neutrophils are responsible for the unchecked release of proteolytic enzymes with destructive implications on lung architecture. A major product of activated neutrophils, with a critical role in CF physiopathology, is the serine protease NE, a pivotal contributor to the structural damage of airway walls (hydrolyzing many proteins in addition to elastin), implicated also in the mucin hypersecretion, impaired MCC, inhibition of several innate immune functions by digesting opsonins and opsonin receptors, airway inflammation, and impaired macrophage phagocytosis
[65,87][50][72]. Nevertheless, it plays a fundamental role in host defense underlined by the evidence that NE-knockout mice are highly susceptible to sepsis induced by Gram-negative bacteria
[88][73].
In adult and pediatric CF BAL, the increased presence of active NE has been correlated with impaired structural integrity, worsening lung function, and decreased body mass index over time. In a study conducted by Sly et al. on CF children, the free NE in BAL fluid at 3 months of age was associated with increased odds of persistent bronchiectasis; the odds were seven times as high at 12 months of age and four times as high at 3 years of age
[71,89][56][74]. In another study, conducted by Sagel et al., the NE in BAL fluid of children with CF correlated inversely with forced expiratory volume in the 1st second (FEV1)
[90][75]. Moreover, increased NE activity is responsible for
CFTR degradation and activation of ENaC with subsequent further aggravation of electrolyte imbalances typical of CF
[87,91,92][72][76][77].
In addition, NE modulates the function of several proteins, most notably the matrix metalloproteinase 9 (MMP9), another neutrophil protease that plays a key role in CF disease progression, whose quantity and activity were found to increase in BAL fluid of PWCF. Indeed, although the production of MMP9 by peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) was found constitutively augmented in CF patients homozygous for F508del mutation because of impairment in PBMCs Ca
2+ homeostasis, NE potentiates MMP9 activity through a direct activatory cleavage and/or the degradatory cleavage of its inhibitor, the tissue inhibitor of metalloprotease-1 (TIMP-1) with subsequent augmented collagen degradation and tissue damage
[71,93,94,95,96][56][78][79][80][81]. The NE is also able to impair the bacterial-killing activity of neutrophils via the cleavage of the IL-8 receptor CXCR1 expressed on their surface and to repress flagellin transcription in
P. aeruginosa, which facilitates biofilm formation
[71,97,98][56][82][83]. Additionally, as shown by Devaney et al. in their work, NE degrades TLR4 on HECs reducing bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS) sensitivity and increasing inflammation
[5,99][5][84].
Another mechanism that impairs bacterial killing and prolongs the lifespan of neutrophils in CF is related to resistin (RETN), an inflammatory cytokine significantly upregulated in this condition
[100,101][85][86]. As demonstrated by Miller et al., this protein promotes an efficient uptake and utilization of glucose in neutrophils, fueling their pro-survival pathways. Furthermore, RETN impairs their bactericidal ability by inhibiting actin polymerization, crucial for the phagocytosis process, and ROS production, as has been observed for the pathogens
P. aeruginosa and S.
aureus [100,102][85][87].
Another key protein in CF physiopathology, significantly increased in this disease, is the pro-inflammatory cytokine IL-17 that regulates granulopoiesis and neutrophil recruitment; it is produced mainly by CD3+CD4+ T-helper (Th), although was also identified in other “innate-like” tissue-resident lymphocytes and in neutrophils
[35,103][20][88]. In a study conducted by Taylor et al. on a cohort of F508del CF subjects, authors found elevated levels of IL-17, NE, and MMP9 in sputum at the time of pulmonary exacerbation due to
P. aeruginosa infection with decreased levels of IL-17 IV antibiotics; furthermore IL-17 producing neutrophils were the predominant cell in sputum of that cohort during the pulmonary exacerbation and a statistically significant inverse correlation between them and FEV1 was demonstrated
[75][60].
As mentioned above, an alternative microbicidal mechanism of neutrophils is represented by the releasing of NETs, a mesh-like network that consists of neutrophil chromatin complexed with histones, pro-inflammatory mediators, and neutrophil granule contents, in a process known as “NETosis”. This process can be activated by various pathogens and their components (e.g., LPS), antibodies and immune complexes, cytokines, and chemokines (e.g., IL-8, TNF), and is distinguished in two forms: classical or suicidal and vital NETosis, both present in CF
[35,104][20][89]. However, in CF lung disease, this process has limited efficacy except for the early stages and, on the contrary, it turns out to be counterproductive; indeed, as demonstrated by Gray et al., NETs provided a proinflammatory stimulus to macrophages. Moreover, pathogens can develop escape mechanisms from NET-mediated killing such as degradation of NETs using pathogen-derived DNases or developing resistance to their microbicidal components
[35,105,106][20][90][91].
Interestingly, Nadesalingam et al. in their study showed that hypertonic saline suppresses NETosis induced by
E. coli LPS (0111:B4 and O128:B12), and
P. aeruginosa and LPS-induced ROS production
[107][92].