Occurrences of Endotoxin in Agriculture: Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 2 by Catherine Yang and Version 1 by Dipendra Mahato.

Agricultural operations and the processing sector generate dust laden with endotoxin in the workplace. Endotoxin, a pro-inflammatory agent, has adverse effects on health, especially in the lungs, as exposure to endotoxin reduces lung function capacity. Endotoxin exposure to workers and its harmful impact on the health of agricultural workers needs to be studied in detail for future interventions to reduce exposure to endotoxin.

  • endotoxin
  • lung function
  • gram-negative bacteria

1. Introduction

Agriculture can be related to the generation of enormous amounts of dust, of which organic dust from agricultural activities is the primary source of endotoxin. The endotoxin concentration is a significant concern in agricultural operations and sectors because the exposure value exceeds the recommended threshold value. The occurrence of endotoxin in different animal housing, food processing and other agricultural industries, such as hemp and cotton, are presented in Table 21, Table 32 and Table 43. The location of dust measurements was inside the farms or industries.
There is a variation in the occurrence of endotoxin in agricultural settings. This variation may be due to different sources of dust in agricultural settings. The harvesting of crops (nuts) using a mechanical harvester results in a higher concentration of dust [81,82][1][2]. Endotoxin has a significant correlation with the temperature [60,82,83][2][3][4]. The endotoxin concentration increases with an increase in the temperature [82][2] and relative humidity [60,84,85][3][5][6]. The endotoxin concentration is significantly higher on warmer days than on cold days [86,87][7][8]. In poultry and swine buildings, there is an increase in the dust and endotoxin concentration on winter days as ventilation is reduced to conserve heat [88][9]. The concentration of endotoxin in dust decreases due to the growth of fungi and bacteria in the livestock feed in poultry and swine farms [66][10]. The animal feeds may contribute to endotoxin contamination, but the major source of endotoxin inside animal houses is animal feces [88,89][9][11].
Endotoxin assessments depend on different sampling, extraction and analysis procedures followed [24][12]. The endotoxin concentration is higher during livestock farming than during crop farming [81][1]. The endotoxin concentration increases with an increase in the density of animals that are reared (pig) and a reduction in the frequency of cleaning in swine houses [88][9]. The concentration of endotoxin depends on the duration of exposure [88][9] and the type of workplace [90][13].
Table 21.
Occurrence of endotoxin in animal housing around the world.
Table 43.
Occurrence of endotoxin in other different agricultural industries around the world.
Table 32.
Occurrence of endotoxin during different agricultural operations around the world.

2. Occurrence of Endotoxin in Animal Housing

Any structure that houses livestock is certain to produce dust. Dust can be generated from feed, excreta, feathers, fur etc. The occurrence of endotoxin in animal housing around the world is presented in Table 21. The animals and workers are exposed to different levels of dust in animal housing. The floor-housed poultry rearing system in Canada has the highest level of total dust (9.56 mg/m3) [48][15]. The cage-housed poultry system has lower dust concentrations due to the fact that the poultry is kept in the layer system and the poultry cannot perform dust bathing on the floor, which reduces the dust. The endotoxin concentration was found to be lower in the floor-housed poultry rearing system than in the cage system. In a floor-housed poultry rearing system, the excreta are collected in the floor and the moisture is absorbed by the bedding material, which is not the case with the cage-house poultry rearing system. The inhalable dust concentration in poultry farms of Denmark has a dust concentration of 5.7 mg/m3, which is above the permissible exposure limit [91][16]. In the case of the swine/pig farms, the dust generated was found to be in the range of 0.128 [92][17] to 5.0 mg/m3 [21][14] and the geometric mean of endotoxin concentration varies from 16.261 [93][18] to 1500 EU/m3 [94][19] The reason for higher endotoxin levels is due to concentrated animal feeds.
In dairy farms, the dust and endotoxin concentrations were measured at the milking section and feeding sections and in free stall dairy farms. The geometric mean of the dust concentration varies from 0.2 [96][21] to 1.7 mg/m3 [97][22], and the endotoxin concentration varies from 128 [98][23] to 448 EU/m3 [91][16]. The lowest concentration of dust was observed in a mink farm (7 mg/m3) [95][20], and the highest concentration of dust was reported in horse stables of the Netherlands (95 mg/m3) [102][27], and the endotoxin concentration was 214 [95][20] to 555 EU/m3 [102][27]. The endotoxin and dust concentrations were higher in pig farms than in cattle and poultry farms due to the higher density of animals and use of concentrated feeds in pig farms. Environmental factors, such as temperature, relative humidity and wind velocity, affect the levels of airborne endotoxins at the farms [82,90,103][2][13][28]. Endotoxin exposure is higher for persons living in rural regions with intense livestock production [10][43].

3. Occurrence of Endotoxin in Food Processing Industries

In food processing industries, water is used while processing the food. Endotoxin varies with the pre-processing methods used in food processing plants. Dry pre-processed methods (sun dried cherries of coffee) result in higher concentrations of endotoxin than wet pre-processed food processing methods by using water to depulp coffee cherries [104][31]. The occurrence of endotoxin in food processing industries around the world is presented in Table 32. The presence of water helps to reduce dust and endotoxin exposure to the workers, as the dust gets absorbed in the water [24][12]. Yang, 2013, reported that the total suspended dust increases on colder days [66][10].

4. Occurrence of Endotoxin in Other Industries

Byssinosis is commonly developed in workers who are exposed to cotton dust [5][33]. In rice mills, dust can be generated due to abrasion of the paddy. The occurrence of endotoxin in other agricultural industries around the world is presented in Table 43. During the post-harvest handling of cereal/fruit crops, dust is generated due to the breaking of plant materials. The workers are exposed to this contaminant and are exposed to dust, which can reduce the forced vital capacity of the workers [28,33,35,36,37,38,39][44][45][46][47][48][49][50]. Many researchers have collected data on inhalable, thoracic and total dust, but very few researchers have sampled the respirable fraction of dust samples [88,92,101,110][9][17][26][42]. The respirable dust fraction can penetrate beyond the terminal bronchioles of the lungs [28,41][44][51]. Respirable dust laden with endotoxin can cause serious health issues for the workers.

References

  1. Nieuwenhuijsen, M.J.; Noderer, K.S.; Schenker, M.B.; Vallyathan, V.; Olenchock, S. Personal Exposure to Dust, Endotoxin and Crystalline Silica in California Agriculture. Ann. Occup. Hyg. 1999, 43, 35–42.
  2. Carty, C.L.; Gehring, U.; Cyrys, J.; Bischof, W.; Heinrich, J. Seasonal Variability of Endotoxin in Ambient Fine Particulate Matter. J. Environ. Monit. 2003, 5, 953–958.
  3. Allen, J.; Bartlett, K.; Graham, M.; Jackson, P. Ambient Concentrations of Airborne Endotoxin in Two Cities in the Interior of British Columbia, Canada. J. Environ. Monit. 2011, 13, 631–640.
  4. Rolph, C.A.; Gwyther, C.L.; Tyrrel, S.F.; Nasir, Z.A.; Drew, G.H.; Jackson, S.K.; Khera, S.; Hayes, E.T.; Williams, B.; Bennett, A.; et al. Sources of Airborne Endotoxins in Ambient Air and Exposure of Nearby Communities–A Review. Atmosphere 2018, 9, 375.
  5. Vučemilo, M.; Matković, K.; Vinković, B.; Macan, J.; Varnai, V.M.; Prester, L.; Granić, K.; Orct, T. Effect of Microclimate on the Airborne Dust and Endotoxin Concentration in a Broiler House. Czech J. Anim. Sci. 2008, 53, 83–89.
  6. Salonen, H.; Duchaine, C.; Létourneau, V.; Mazaheri, M.; Laitinen, S.; Clifford, S.; Mikkola, R.; Lappalainen, S.; Reijula, K.; Morawska, L. Endotoxin Levels and Contribution Factors of Endotoxins in Resident, School, and Office Environments—A Review. Atmos. Environ. 2016, 142, 360–369.
  7. Morgenstern, V.; Carty, C.L.; Gehring, U.; Cyrys, J.; Bischof, W.; Heinrich, J. Lack of Spatial Variation of Endotoxin in Ambient Particulate Matter across a German Metropolitan Area. Atmos. Environ. 2005, 39, 6931–6941.
  8. Morgenstern, V.; Bischof, W.; Koch, A.; Heinrich, J. Measurements of Endotoxin on Ambient Loaded PM Filters after Long-Term Storage. Sci. Total Environ. 2006, 370, 574–579.
  9. Chang, C.W.; Chung, H.; Huang, C.F.; Su, H.J.J. Exposure Assessment to Airborne Endotoxin, Dust, Ammonia, Hydrogen Sulfide and Carbon Dioxide in Open Style Swine Houses. Ann. Occup. Hyg. 2001, 45, 457–465.
  10. Yang, X.; Wang, X.; Zhang, Y.; Lee, J.; Su, J.; Gates, R.S. Monitoring Total Endotoxin and (1→3)-β-d-Glucan at the Air Exhaust of Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations. J. Air Waste Manag. Assoc. 2013, 63, 1190–1198.
  11. Thedell, T.D.; Mull, J.C.; Olenchock, S.A. A Brief Report of Gram-negative Bacterial Endotoxin Levels in Airborne and Settled Dusts in Animal Confinement Buildings. Am. J. Ind. Med. 1980, 1, 3–7.
  12. Spaan, S.; Wouters, I.M.; Oosting, I.; Doekes, G.; Heederik, D. Exposure to Inhalable Dust and Endotoxins in Agricultural Industries. J. Environ. Monit. 2006, 8, 63–72.
  13. Halstensen, A.S.; Heldal, K.K.; Wouters, I.M.; Skogstad, M.; Ellingsen, D.A.G.G.; Eduard, W. Exposure to Grain Dust and Microbial Components in the Norwegian Grain and Compound Feed Industry. Ann. Occup. Hyg. 2013, 57, 1105–1114.
  14. Radon, K.; Danuser, B.; Iversen, M.; Monso, E.; Weber, C.; Hartung, J.; Donham, K.; Palmgren, U.; Nowak, D. Air Contaminants in Different European Farming Environments. Ann. Agric. Environ. Med. 2002, 9, 41–48.
  15. Kirychuk, S.P.; Dosman, J.A.; Reynolds, S.J.; Willson, P.; Senthilselvan, A.; Feddes, J.J.R.; Classen, H.L.; Guenter, W. Total Dust and Endotoxin in Poultry Operations: Comparison between Cage and Floor Housing and Respiratory Effects in Workers. J. Occup. Environ. Med. 2006, 48, 741–748.
  16. Basinas, I.; Schlünssen, V.; Heederik, D.; Sigsgaard, T.; Smit, L.A.M.; Samadi, S.; Omland, Ø.; Hjort, C.; Madsen, A.M.; Skov, S.; et al. Sensitisation to Common Allergens and Respiratory Symptoms in Endotoxin Exposed Workers: A Pooled Analysis. Occup. Environ. Med. 2012, 69, 99–106.
  17. Shin, S.J.; Song, E.S.; Kim, J.W.; Lee, J.H.; Gautam, R.; Kim, H.J.; Kim, Y.G.; Cho, A.R.; Yang, S.J.; Acharya, M.; et al. Major Environmental Characteristics of Swine Husbandry That Affect Exposure to Dust and Airborne Endotoxins. J. Toxicol. Environ. Health Part A Curr. Issues 2019, 82, 233–243.
  18. Traversi, D.; Alessandria, L.; Schilirò, T.; Gilli, G. Size-Fractionated PM10 Monitoring in Relation to the Contribution of Endotoxins in Different Polluted Areas. Atmos. Environ. 2011, 45, 3515–3521.
  19. Basinas, I.; Schlünssen, V.; Takai, H.; Heederik, D.; Omland, Ø.; Wouters, I.M.; Sigsgaard, T.; Kromhout, H. Exposure to Inhalable Dust and Endotoxin among Danish Pig Farmers Affected by Work Tasks and Stable Characteristics. Ann. Occup. Hyg. 2013, 57, 1005–1019.
  20. Basinas, I.; Sigsgaard, T.; Heederik, D.; Takai, H.; Omland, Ø.; Andersen, N.T.; Wouters, I.M.; Bønløkke, J.H.; Kromhout, H.; Schlünssen, V. Exposure to Inhalable Dust and Endotoxin among Danish Livestock Farmers: Results from the SUS Cohort Study. J. Environ. Monit. 2012, 14, 604–614.
  21. Pfister, H.; Madec, L.; Le Cann, P.; Costet, N.; Chouvet, M.; Jouneau, S.; Vernhet, L. Factors Determining the Exposure of Dairy Farmers to Thoracic Organic Dust. Environ. Res. 2018, 165, 286–293.
  22. Basinas, I.; Cronin, G.; Hogan, V.; Sigsgaard, T.; Hayes, J.; Coggins, A.M. Exposure to Inhalable Dust, Endotoxin, and Total Volatile Organic Carbons on Dairy Farms Using Manual and Automated Feeding Systems. Ann. Work Expo. Health 2017, 61, 344–355.
  23. Garcia, J.; Bennett, D.H.; Tancredi, D.; Schenker, M.B.; Mitchell, D.; Reynolds, S.J.; Mitloehner, F.M. Occupational Exposure to Particulate Matter and Endotoxin for California Dairy Workers. Int. J. Hyg. Environ. Health 2013, 216, 56–62.
  24. Dungan, R.S.; Leytem, A.B.; Bjorneberg, D.L. Concentrations of Airborne Endotoxin and Microorganisms at a 10,000-Cow Open-Freestall Dairy. J. Anim. Sci. 2011, 89, 3300–3309.
  25. Davidson, M.E.; Schaeffer, J.; Clark, M.L.; Magzamen, S.; Brooks, E.J.; Keefe, T.J.; Bradford, M.; Roman-Muniz, N.; Mehaffy, J.; Dooley, G.; et al. Personal Exposure of Dairy Workers to Dust, Endotoxin, Muramic Acid, Ergosterol, and Ammonia on Large-Scale Dairies in the High Plains Western United States. J. Occup. Environ. Hyg. 2018, 15, 182–193.
  26. Hwang, J.; Golla, V.; Metwali, N.; Thorne, P.S. Inhalable and Respirable Particulate and Endotoxin Exposures in Kentucky Equine Farms. J. Agromedicine 2020, 25, 179–189.
  27. Samadi, S.; Wouters, I.M.; Houben, R.; Jamshidifard, A.R.; Van Eerdenburg, F.; Heederik, D.J.J. Exposure to Inhalable Dust, Endotoxins, β(1→3)-Glucans, and Airborne Microorganisms in Horse Stables. Ann. Occup. Hyg. 2009, 53, 595–603.
  28. De Rooij, M.M.T.; Heederik, D.J.J.; Borlée, F.; Hoek, G.; Wouters, I.M. Spatial and Temporal Variation in Endotoxin and PM10 Concentrations in Ambient Air in a Livestock Dense Area. Environ. Res. 2017, 153, 161–170.
  29. Shakri, S.F.M.; Anua, S.M.; Safuan, S.; Mohamad Asri, A.A. Endotoxin Exposure and Lung Function among Rice Millers in Malaysia. J. Health Transl. Med. 2020, 23, 31–40.
  30. Smit, L.A.M.; Wouters, I.M.; Hobo, M.M.; Eduard, W.; Doekes, G.; Heederik, D. Agricultural Seed Dust as a Potential Cause of Organic Dust Toxic Syndrome. Occup. Environ. Med. 2006, 63, 59–67.
  31. Sakwari, G.; Mamuya, S.H.D.; Bråtveit, M.; Larsson, L.; Pehrson, C.; Moen, B.E. Personal Exposure to Dust and Endotoxin in Robusta and Arabica Coffee Processing Factories in Tanzania. Ann. Occup. Hyg. 2013, 57, 173–183.
  32. O’Shaughnessy, P.; Peters, T.; Donham, K.; Taylor, C.; Altmaier, R.; Kelly, K. Assessment of Swine Worker Exposures to Dust and Endotoxin during Hog Load-out and Power Washing. Ann. Occup. Hyg. 2012, 56, 843–851.
  33. Pranav, P.K.; Biswas, M. Mechanical Intervention for Reducing Dust Concentration in Traditional Rice Mills. Ind. Health 2016, 54, 315–323.
  34. Sauvé, J.F.; Locke, S.J.; Josse, P.R.; Stapleton, E.M.; Metwali, N.; Altmaier, R.W.; Andreotti, G.; Thorne, P.S.; Hofmann, J.N.; Beane Freeman, L.E.; et al. Characterization of Inhalable Endotoxin, Glucan, and Dust Exposures in Iowa Farmers. Int. J. Hyg. Environ. Health 2020, 228, 113525.
  35. Paudyal, P.; Semple, S.; Niven, R.; Tavernier, G.; Ayres, J.G. Exposure to Dust and Endotoxin in Textile Processing Workers. Ann. Occup. Hyg. 2011, 55, 403–409.
  36. Krysińska-Traczyk, E.; Pande, B.N.; Skórska, C.; Sitkowska, J.; Prazmo, Z.; Cholewa, G.; Dutkiewicz, J. Exposure of Indian Agricultural Workers to Airborne Microorganisms, Dust and Endotoxin during Handling of Various Plant Products. Ann. Agric. Environ. Med. 2005, 12, 269–275.
  37. Doctor, P.B.; Bhagia, L.J.; Derasari, A.Y.; Vyas, J.B.; Amin, R.J.; Ghosh, S.K. A Preliminary Study on Gram-Negative Bacteria (GNB) and Their Endotoxins in a Gin House in India. J. Occup. Environ. Hyg. 2006, 3, 707–712.
  38. Fishwick, D.; Allan, L.J.; Wright, A.; Curran, A.D. Assessment of Exposure to Organic Dust in a Hemp Processing Plant. Ann. Occup. Hyg. 2001, 45, 577–583.
  39. Tefera, Y.; Schlünssen, V.; Kumie, A.; Deressa, W.; Moen, B.E.; Bråtveit, M. Personal Inhalable Dust and Endotoxin Exposure among Workers in an Integrated Textile Factory. Arch. Environ. Occup. Health 2020, 75, 415–421.
  40. Viet, S.M.; Buchan, R.; Stallones, L. Acute Respiratory Effects and Endotoxin Exposure During Wheat Harvest in Northeastern Colorado. Appl. Occup. Environ. Hyg. 2001, 16, 685–697.
  41. Straumfors, A.; Olsen, R.; Daae, H.L.; Afanou, A.; McLean, D.; Corbin, M.; Mannetje, A.; Ulvestad, B.; Bakke, B.; Johnsen, H.L.; et al. Exposure to Wood Dust, Microbial Components, and Terpenes in the Norwegian Sawmill Industry. Ann. Work Expo. Health 2018, 62, 674–688.
  42. Pipinić, I.S.; Varnai, V.M.; Lučić, R.B.; Čavlović, A.; Prester, L.; Orct, T.; MacAn, J. Endotoxin Exposure Assessment in Wood-Processing Industry: Airborne versus Settled Dust Levels. Arh. Hig. Rada Toksikol. 2010, 61, 161–166.
  43. Liebers, V.; Raulf-Heimsoth, M.; Brüning, T. Health Effects Due to Endotoxin Inhalation (Review). Arch. Toxicol. 2008, 82, 203–210.
  44. Srinivasulu, M.; Begum, S.A. Assessment of Pulmonary Function Tests Among Rice Mill Workers. Int. J. Adv. Res. 2020, 8, 733–737.
  45. Musa, A.I.; Orelaja, O.A. Ergonomic Consideration of the Effect of Flour Dust on Peak Expiratory Flow Rate of Bakers in Abeokuta, Ogun State. Trans. VŠB Tech. Univ. Ostrava Saf. Eng. Ser. 2017, 12, 19–24.
  46. Mohammadien, H.A.; Hussein, M.T.; El-Sokkary, R.T. Effects of Exposure to Flour Dust on Respiratory Symptoms and Pulmonary Function of Mill Workers. Egypt. J. Chest Dis. Tuberc. 2013, 62, 745–753.
  47. Wickramage, S.P.; Rajaratne, A.A.J.; Udupihille, M. Are Rice Millers an At-Risk Group for Lung Disease?—An Occupational Health Concern in Rural Sri Lanka. Indian J. Physiol. Pharmacol. 2017, 61, 340–347.
  48. Habybabady, R.H.; Nasibi Sis, H.; Paridokht, F.; Ramrudinasab, F.; Behmadi, A.; Khosravi, B.; Mohammadi, M. Effects of Dust Exposure on the Respiratory Health Symptoms and Pulmonary Functions of Street Sweepers. Malays. J. Med. Sci. 2018, 25, 76–84.
  49. Sundaram, P.; Shankar, M.S.V.; Aswathappa, J.; Kutty, K. Evaluation of Pulmonary Function in Rice Mill Workers. Indian J. Physiol. Pharmacol. 2019, 63, 192–197.
  50. Suryadi, I.; Matin, H.H.A.; Suhardono, S.; Rinawati, S.; Rachmawati, S.; Kusumaningrum, L. Correlation with Dust Exposure Rice Milling Worker’s Lung Function Capacity in Sub-District Kerjo. In Proceedings of the IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, Jakarta, Indonesia, 9 January 2021; Volume 623, p. 012033.
  51. Ateş, I. Occupational Mineral Dust Induced Toxicity and Cytokines. Turk. J. Pharm. Sci. 2011, 8, 81–90.
More
Video Production Service