Electric Vehicle Charging Connector Standards: Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 2 by Shahid Jaman and Version 3 by Catherine Yang.

For Electric Vehicles (EVs), the electric charge of the battery is the main fuel to drive the car. To refuel the EV, we have to connect the EV to a charging station. For the EV charging pile, there are two options are available: (a) AC charging pile and (b) DC charging pile. The dedicated connector standards are used to connect the EV with AC and/or DC charging stations. The specifications of different connector standards are described in detail with pin configuration and comparative discussion.  

  • AC Connector
  • DC Connector
  • CHAdeMO
  • Combo CCS Connector

1. IEV Chargintroductiog Connector Standards

International organizations have been working for many years to enact their connection standards regarding the high-power charging of EVs. The commonly used technologies are (a) AC on-board charging and (b) DC off-board charging. In previous years, European EV manufacturers have rather produced EVs with on-board chargers which are compatible with a high-power AC supply. However, since the company TEPCO introduced a standard Japanese socket for DC connection, namely CHAdeMO, DC off-board charging is becoming more common. CHAdeMO is now available in several European countries, and although it is not internationally standardized yet, it is widely used in the US and Japan[1]. The SAE also has been developing its own connector standard called Combo. In SAE J1772, the Combo coupler features extra pins compared to the standard version[2].

2. AC Charging Connector

1.1. AC Charging Connector

The IEC 62196-2 standard defines three types of connectors for AC supply power in Europe. These types of connectors are described in Table 1.

Table 1.

IEC 62196-2 Connector Standard for AC charging

[3]

.

IEC 62196-2

Type 1

Type 2

Type 3

Coupler

1-phase

1-phase and 3-phase

1-phase and 3-phase with shutters

Related standard

SAE J1772 Type 1

VDE-AR-E 26232-2

-

Maximum current

32 A (80 A at the US)

70 A (1-phase)

63 A (3-phase)

16 A (1-phase)

32 A (3-phase)/63 A(3-phase)

Maximum voltage

250 V

480 V (3-phase)

250 V/400 V

Maximum power

19 kW

43.5 kW

22 kW (3-phase)

Pin and interlock

5 pins, mechanic lock

7 pins, electronic lock

4 pins or 5 pins

Control pin

Two short pins

One short, one long pin

-

Communication

PWM over CP

PWM over CO

-

 

The IEC 62196-2 Type 1 is not different compared to the SAE J1772 which is widely used in the US and Japan. In China, the IEC 62196-2 Type 1 is also known as GB/T 20234.2-2015 connector. Notice that China has modified it by changing it from an electronic lock into a mechanic lock (with the option of an electronic lock) and the control pilot is using two short pins.

3. DC Charging Connector

1.2. DC Charging Connector

The most common use of fast charging technologies is to supply direct current to the EV battery. This requires an off-board charging station to supply high levels of current and to transform the AC of the distribution grid to DC for the charging of the EV’s battery. CHAdeMO was the first fast-charging method in the world, specified by the Japan Electric Vehicle Standard (JEVS) G105-1993 from the JARI (Japan Automobile Research Institute), and it has been developed by the Japanese company TEPCO. CHAdeMO is an abbreviation of “CHArge de MOve” or “move by charge”[4]. The connector includes two large pins for DC power, plus other pins to carry CAN-BUS connections. The CHAdeMO transmits the information by CAN-BUS and analog control lines. This hybrid communication protocol has more advantages compared to pure digital control since it can let the system double-check the digital control system. Once the analog signal is lost, an immediate charging operation shutdown can be performed [28]. The CHAdeMO specifications comply with the international standard IEC 62196-3. The characteristics of CHAdeMO are shown in Table 2.

Table 2.

CHAdeMO connector characteristics

[5]

.

Parameter Description

Rated Values

Maximum current

120 A

Maximum voltage

500 V DC

Maximum power

50 kW

Maximum current (control system)

7 A

Maximum voltage (control system)

12 V DC

Level of charging

DC level 3

Control pin

7 pins

Communication protocol

CHAdeMO (CAN communication)

The configuration of CHAdeMO only specifies the necessary and effective parts for connection. A summary and pinout of CHAdeMO are shown in Table 3.

Table 3.

CHAdeMO pinout functionalities

[6]

.

Pin ID

Wire Cross Section (mm2)

Description

1

0.75

Ground

 

2

0.75

Start/stop charging 1

3

 

None

4

0.75

Permission/prohibition charging

5

22 or 40

DC supply negative

6

22 or 40

DC supply positive

7

0.75

Verification of the connector connection

8

0.75

CAN High

9

0.75

CAN Low

10

0.75

Start/stop charging 2

4. Combined Charger Connector (J1772-2009 Combo)

1.3. Combined Charger Connector (J1772-2009 Combo)

In parallel to CHAdeMO, the US and some European EV manufacturers such as Audi, BMW, Daimler, Ford, General Motors, Porsche, or Volkswagen have been developing a new system for fast charging: the Combined Charging System (CCS), i.e., J1772-2009 Combo. The main goal of this standard is to allow the EV to charge in both AC (slow/medium charging) and DC (fast charging), which is different from CHAdeMO as it only allows DC and needs an extra socket for AC charging.

There are two types of Combo CCS currently available. The Combo Type 1 connector for the US has been developed based on the AC Type 1 connector (specified by the standards SAE J1772/UNE EN 62196-2). The Combo Type 2 for Europe integrates a Type 2 connector as defined in the standard UNE EN 62196-2[7]. The main characteristics of Combo connectors Type 1 and Type 2 are summarized in Table 4.

Table 4.

Main characteristics of Combo connectors Type 1 and type 2

[5]

.

Parameters

Combo Type 1 (US)

Combo Type 2 (EU)

DC Charging

Maximum current

150 A

200 A

Maximum voltage

600 V

850 V

Charging mode

4

4

Maximum power

90 kW

170 kW

Connector type

Combo 1 (IEC 62196-3)

Combo 2 (IEC 62196-3)

AC Charging

Nominal current

32 A

70 A (1-phase)/63 A (3-phase)

Nominal voltage

250 V

230 V (1-phase)/400 V (3-phase)

Charging mode

3

3

Maximum power

13 kW

44 kW

Connector type

Type 1 (IEC 62196-2, SAE J1772)

Type 2 (IEC 62196-2)

The Combo Type 1 and Type 2 have different pinout configurations based on their different functionalities. Table 5 shows the configuration and the functions of the pins in Combo Type 1 and Type 2.

Table 5.

The pin configuration and functionality of Combo connectors Type 1 and Type 2

[6]

.

Pin

Functions

Comments

Combo Type 1

PP

Communication/Charging process control

Proximity inlet

CP

Control pilot

PE

Earth ground

EV to earth ground

L1/N

AC 1-phase charging

Phase 1/Neutral

L2

Phase 2

DC+

DC charging

DC positive terminal

DC-

DC negative terminal

Pin

Functions

Comments

Combo Type 2

PP

Communication/Charging process control

Proximity inlet

CP

Control pilot

PE

Earth ground

EV to earth ground

L1

AC 3-phase Charging

Phase 1

L2

Phase 2

L3

Phase 3

N

Neutral

DC+

DC Charging

DC positive terminal

DC-

DC negative terminal

Currently, GB/T was giving just 237.5 kW at 950 V and 250 A; thus, this will be about four times more competent in terms of power than other DC charging connectors. Power will be more than twice as high as the new 400 kW CHAdeMO and 350 kW CCS Combo specs, too. However, the V2G features are not supported by GB/T connector standard. The feature comparison among the DC charging connector standards is listed Table 6 below:

Table 6.

Specification comparison of different DC charging connector standards

[7]

.

Specification

New GB/T

GB/T

CHAdeMO

CCS Type 1

Tesla

 

Max Power

900 kW

237.5 kW

400 kW

400 kW

135 kW

No. of Control Pilot

2

0

3

1

1

Communication

CAN (SAE J1939)

CAN (SAE J1939)

CAN (ISO 11898)

PLC (ISO 15118)

CAN (SAE J2411)

+12 V Power Supply

Yes

Optional

Yes

No

No

V2G Compatible

Unknown

Under R&D

Yes

Under R&D

No

Coupler Lock

Inlet

Connector

Connector

Inlet

Inlet

Availability

China

China, India

Global

EU, US, A

Global

Related Standards

IEC 61851-23-1

IEC 61851-23-2

IEC 61851-23-1

IEC 61851-23-1

IEC 61851-23-2

IEEE 2030.1

IEC 61851-23-1

SAE J1772

None

Cooling Technique

Liquid-Cooled

Cable Under

Development

Liquid-Cooled

Cable Not

Available

Liquid-Cooled

Cable Under

Development

Liquid-Cooled

Cable Under

Development

Liquid-Cooled

Cable

Discontinued

References

  1. M. D. Yoshida and T. Blech. ”CHAdeMO DC Charging: Successful Transition Towards Nation- and Region-Wide Ze-ro-Emisson”. CHAdeMO association, April 2021. Available online: https://movelatam.org/portfolio-item/chademo-charging-protocol-for-electric-vehicles/ (accessed on 24 July 2022).
  2. Myles, B., & Robert, E. , " Making the right connections General procurement guidance for electric vehicle charge points," 2015. [Online]. Available: http://ukevse.org.uk/resources/procurement-guidance/.
  3. Luyten, Leemput, N., Geth, F., Van Roy, J., Büscher, J., & Driesen, J. (2013). Standardization of Conductive AC Charging Infrastructure for Electric Vehicles. In IET Conference Publications (Vol. 2013, Issue 615 CP). https://doi.org/10.1049/cp.2013.0751
  4. Schwarzer, V.; Ghorbani, R. Current State-of-the-Art of EV Chargers; EVTC Electric Vehicle Transportation Centre: Cocoa, FL, USA, 2015; pp. 1–13.
  5. Quílez, M.G.; Abdel-Monem, M.; El Baghdadi, M.; Yang, Y.; Van Mierlo, J.; Hegazy, O. Modelling, analysis and performance evaluation of power conversion unit in G2V/V2G application-a review. Energies 2018, 11, 1082.
  6. Cuma, M.U.; Tümay, M.; Yirik, E.; Ünal, E.; Dericioğlu, Ç.; Onur, B. A review of charging technologies for commercial electric vehicles. Int. J. Adv. Automot. Technol. 2018, 2, 61–70.
  7. “China is Developing New GB/T Fast Charging Standard at 900kW”. Insideevs Press Release, 19 Jun 2018. Available Online: https://insideevs.com/news/338620/china-is-developing-new-gb-t-fast-charging-standard-at-900-kw (accessed on 29 Septem-ber 2022).
More
ScholarVision Creations