Excipients Used for Modified Nasal Drug Delivery: Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 1 by Angeliki Siamidi and Version 2 by Peter Tang.

Intranasal absorption is a favored route because it avoids the gastrointestinal and hepatic metabolism, leading to an increase in drug bioavailability, and a reduction in the side effects and the required dose administered. The ongoing challenging task in the field of nasal drug delivery is the maintenance of an efficient concentration of the active substance in the target area for an adequate period of time. 

  • nasal drug delivery
  • poloxamer
  • chitosan
  • gellan gum
  • vaccines
  • excipients
  • nanoparticles

1. Introduction

Oral administration of medicines is the most convenient method of drug dispensing with the highest compliance rates, as patients can self-administer their medications in a noninvasive and painless manner, providing a variable and customizable dosing schedule at home [1]. On the other hand, the harsh chemical environment in the stomach and intestines, the first-pass effect, and the barrier of the gastrointestinal tract pose major difficulties for the efficacy of drugs [2][3][2,3]. Thus, alternative routes of administration have been developed to circumvent those hurdles and achieve the requisite results (Figure 1). The major alternative routes are pulmonary, transdermal, buccal, nasal, and parenteral [2], and each of these has its own advantages and disadvantages, as shown in Table 1.
Figure 1.
Different routes of drug administration.
Table 1.
Advantages and disadvantages of each route of administration.
Intranasal absorption is a favored route because it avoids the gastrointestinal and hepatic metabolism, leading to an increase in drug bioavailability, and a reduction in the side effects and the required dose administered [4]. Furthermore, the intranasal route also has several practical advantages for both the patient and the pharmaceutical industry. The former can benefit from the non-invasive, highly tolerable, easy to administer, and pain-free drug delivery systems, and pharma avoids the need to sterilize the nasal products [5]. Moreover, acid-sensitive drugs, such as biologics (peptides, hormones, etc.), which are prone to degradation in the gastrointestinal tract, and drugs that cannot be absorbed orally, may be administered nasally. The inclusion of enhancers, mainly excipients, can increase the nasal absorption of such drugs [6]. Recently, many pharmaceutical companies have become involved in the commercialization of absorption promoters and absorption modulators for nasal drug delivery [7].
Even though the nasal epithelium acts as a tight barrier, the intercellular junctional complex of the nasal mucosa is not impervious, due to the leaky epithelial tissue [8][9][8,9]. Thus, in combination with the high vascularization of the nasal surface, a favorable profile for therapeutic purposes, more than just the topical nasal drug delivery is achieved [10][11][10,11].

2. Anatomy and Physiology of the Nose

The primary roles of the nasal cavity are olfaction and breathing [12]. Nonetheless, the breathing air is filtered, humidified, and headed by the nasal cavity before reaching the lungs, whilst the inhaled particles and pathogens are trapped from the hair and the mucus layer present in the nasal cavity. Other functions of the nasal structure are the metabolism of endogenous substances and the immunological activities [13][14][13,14]. The nasal cavity is located between the roof of the mouth and the base of the skull supported from above by the ethmoid bones and from the side by the ethmoid, maxillary, and inferior conchae bones. The entire surface area is almost 150 cm2 and has a total volume of 15–20 mL [11][15][11,15]. The nasal cavity consist of three definite parts: the vestibule, the respiratory, and the olfactory regions (Figure 2) [16]. The anterior part of the nasal cavity is the nasal vestibule, which is part of the nostrils, covering an area of about 0.6 cm2, and includes the nasal hairs (vibrissae) [17]. Histologically this part is covered by a keratinized and stratified squamous epithelium with sebaceous glands [10]. These nasal regions prevent the insertion of toxic materials, but at the same time, drug absorption is also limited [18]. The respiratory region represents the largest part of the nasal cavity. It is split into three turbinates—the superior, middle, and inferior—which are responsible for the humidification and temperature adjustment of the inhaled air [19].
Figure 2.
Schematic representation of the nasal cavity.
The most important area for systemic drug delivery is the nasal respiratory mucosa, which consists of the epithelium, the basement membrane, and the lamina propria. The epithelium contains the pseudostratified columnar epithelial cells, goblet cells, basal cells, and mucous and serous gland cells. Many of the epithelial cells are coated by microvilli, which enhance the respiratory surface area, and the cilia, which are fine projections essential for mucus transport towards the nasopharynx [20]. The secretory glands and the goblet cells produce mucus through granules filled with mucin, a glycoprotein that define the mucus viscosity. The mucus is deposited as a thin layer (about 5 μm) in the epithelium, composed of water (95%), 2.5–3% of mucin, and 2% of other substances, such as electrolytes, proteins, enzymes, lipids, antibodies, sloughed epithelial cells, and bacterial products [21]. It is responsible for the humidification and warming of the inhaled air, it has a pH between 5–6.5, and it provides protection to the nasal epithelium against foreign particles and drugs [22][23][22,23]. The olfactory region is located on the top of the nasal cavity and continues down the septum and the lateral wall. The olfactory epithelium is pseudostratified and consists of specialized olfactory receptor cells essential for smell recognition [24].

3. Nasal Drug Delivery

The nasal route of administration is used for treating local inflammation, allergic and common rhinitis, and nasal congestion. The active compounds that are commonly used against these diseases are antihistamines, glucocorticoids, or decongestants in the form of nasal spray, drops, solutions, gels, or powders and other types of formulations, including emulsions, suspensions, and microparticles [6][25][6,25]. The nasal route is used for either local or systemic action. The drug is administered locally for rapid alleviation of the symptoms of the disease, reducing the administered dose, as the drug is placed directly in the affected area, thus avoiding the systemic metabolism. On the other hand, the nasal administration of pharmacologically active substances for systemic action is used in the case of drugs with poor intestinal absorption and limited stability in the gastrointestinal fluids, with extensive hepatic first-pass metabolism, such as biologics and polar drugs [10][11][10,11]. The administration of the drug through the nasal passages can also bypass the blood–brain barrier (BBB), so it can be used for central nervous system (CNS) action. This route has been further studied for administrating vaccines [11][26][11,26]. The drug absorption through the nose is based on the physicochemical properties of the administered drug. The drug cannot penetrate the mucosa and manifest its action if it has a large size (greater than 1 kDa), a high degree of ionization, or is too lipophilic. Another factor that can affect absorption is the drug’s pH, which may affect the stability and the ionization of the drug, as well as cause nasal irritation. Formulations that have high viscosity can more easily enter the nasal mucosa, but simultaneous, they may be less absorbed. When the hyper- or hypotonicity is very high, the ciliary movement can be altered, resulting in lower absorption [6]. Finally, the drug’s concentration and quantity, the position of the head during administration, the nasal surface, and the physical condition of the dosage form all play a vital role in the absorption of the drug [27].

4. Factors That Affect the Nasal Drug Absorption

Drug delivery through the nasal route of administration has some limitations, which are crucial because they influence drug concentration and bioavailability and therefore, the absorption and the pharmacological effect of the administered drug. The first main barrier is the range of pathological and physiological conditions linked to the nasal mucosa, which can affect the absorption and efficacy of the drug [28]. For example, a physiological change in nasal mucosa based on illness and allergy (irritation and the inflammation of the nasal cavity, which is intensified by itching and sneezing) may influence drug absorption [6]. In addition, there is a restriction regarding the absorption of the poorly water-soluble drugs due to the low volume of the nasal cavity, which reduces the administered amount to 100–150 μL [28]. The permeability also decreases for the polar and large molecules and for peptides and proteins [25]. However, by using the correct excipients, including bioadhesive polymers, enhancers, and enzymatic inhibitors, the drug permeability and residency in the nasal cavity can be improved [29]. Another crucial barrier is the mucociliary clearance (MCC) of the mucosa, which by replacing the mucus layer every ~15 min with 5–6 mm/min, the transmucosal absorption is decreased. The mucus can also decrease the drug absorption by binding the drug to mucin, which is the primary protein of the mucus. While the small moieties can pass through easily, the charged or larger units can be caught in the mucus gel [25]. Mucus also contains different enzymes which can influence the stability of protein- and peptide-based drugs; proteases degrade peptides and proteins by attacking them. These xenobiotic enzymes [e.g., P450 monooxygenase, Phase I enzymes (flavin monooxygenases, aldehyde dehydrogenases, epoxide hydrolases, carboxylesterases, etc.) and Phase II enzymes (glucuronyl and sulphate transferases, glutathione transferase) can also metabolize intranasally administered small-molecule drugs, such as opioids, histamines, corticosteroids, etc. [30]. Last but not least, there will always be concerns about the safety of nasal medicines, even though recent breakthroughs in both in vitro and in vivo models are a major benefit in speeding up clinical development and eventually, the time-to-market of new treatments [31][33].

5. Excipients Used in Modified Drug Release Semi-Solid Pharmaceutical Dosage Forms for Nasal Administration

To improve nose-to-brain drug transfer and to extend drug residence time in the nasal cavity, several approaches could be employed, such as the use of semi-solid dosage forms, permeation enhancers, mucoadhesive and temperature responsive gels, or nano-sized drug carriers (Figure 3). In this section, the excipients and methods used in the recent achievements (2017–2022) in the modified release semi-solid formulations for nasal administration are reviewed and summarized, as shown in Table 2.
Figure 3.
Different semi-solid formulations for nasal administration.
Table 2.
Semi-solid formulations for modified release nasal drug delivery. 

Nasal Dosage Form

Drug Release Rate *

API

Excipients

Refs.

in situ gel

biphasic

huperzine A

poloxamers (407, 188), CS, castor oil, polyoxyl 40 hydrogenated castor oil, 1,2- propanediol, Ringer’s solution

[32]

[37]

in situ gel

biphasic

almotriptan

poloxamer (407, 188), Na-CMC, glyceryl behenate glyceryl palmitostearate, glyceryl monostearate, precirol

[33]

[38]

in situ gel

biphasic

sumatriptan

poloxamers (407, 188), carrageenan, soybean phospholipids, cholesterol, tween 80, sodium caprate, sodium cholate, clostridium perfringens enterotoxin, sodium caprate

[34]

[39]

in situ gel

controlled

hydrogel

ziprasidone

poloxamers (407, 188) β-cyclodextrin, HPMC E5, PEG 6000, PEG 4000, polyethylene, HPMCK4M

prolonged

[35]

antigen that generates nasal tissue resident memory CD8+ T cells

CS, poloxamers (188 and 407), ovalbumin protein, lipopolysaccharide

[40]

[

54

]

[65]

in situ gel

controlled

NPs

biphasic

geniposide

r4M2e.HSP70c

antigen

poloxamers (407, 188), HPMC, borneol, benzalkonium chloride, NaCl

N,N,N-trimethyl CS, trimethyl CS, glycerin

[36]

[41]

[

55

]

[66]

in situ gel

sustained

rivastigmine

hydrogen tartrate

poloxamer 407, poly (lactic-co-glycolic acid), polymeric NPs

NPs

[

biphasic

tetanus toxoid

37]

[42]

CS, NPs, paraffin oil, nanospheres

[56]

[67]

in situ gel

sustained

mometasone furoate

NPs

biphasic

tetanus toxoid

poloxamer 407, Carbopol® 974P NF, PEG 400, NaCl, benzalkonium chloride, dexpanthenol, triethanolamine

N-trimethyl CS, CS, dextran microspheres, tripolyphosphate, lactose, Span 80, Tween 80

[38]

[43]

[

57

]

[68]

in situ gel

controlled

montelukast

sodium

poloxamer 407, HPMC K4M, PEG 400, methyl paraben

[39]

[44]

NP

gradual

bovine serum albumin, ovalbumin, and myoglobin

low molecular weight CS, Compound 48/80, MTT (3-[4, 5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl]-2,5-diphenyl tetrazolium bromide), albumin-fluorescein isothiocyanate conjugate (FITC-BSA), trehalose, Dulbecco’s modified Eagle medium (DMEM) and Roswell Park Memorial Institute (RPMI), Bicinchoninic acid (BCA) assay and micro BCA kits, Fetal bovine serum (FBS), wheat germ agglutinin Alexa Fluor® 350 Conjugate and Lysotracker® Red DND 99

[58]

[69]

in situ gel

controlled

hydrocortisone

NPs

extended

PPE17 antigen

(for tuberculosis)

poloxamer 188, Carbopol 934, PG, benzalkonium chloride, triethanolamine, isopropyl alcohol

CS, SA

[40]

[45]

[

59

]

[70]

NP

biphasic

pramipexole dihydrochloride

CS, sodium tripolyphosphate

[41]

NP

burst release prevented

PR8 influenza virus

SA, CS, N,N,N-trimethyl CS, concanavalin A

[46]

[

60

]

[71]

NP

biphasic

efavirenz

NPs

biphasic

inactivated influenza virus

CS chloral hydrate, glucosamine chloral hydrate, N-acetylglucosamine, HP-β-CD, Tween 80

SA powder, class B CpG ODN 2007 with a phosphorothioated backbone, 2,3-bis-(2-methoxy-4-nitro-5- sulfophenyl)-2H -tetra- zolium-5-carboxanilide, Tween 80 and Span 80

[42]

[47]

[

61

]

[72]

NP

NPs

controlled

prolonged

sitagliptin

bovine serum

albumin

CS, glacial acetic acid, tripolyphosphate

Poly(D,L-lactide-co-glycolide), Bisphenol-A-ethoxylate di-acrylate, ethylenediamine, tetrahydrofuran, poly(vinyl alcohol)

[43]

[48]

[

62

]

[73]

NP

delayed

nanogel

gradually

human serum albumin

surface protein A fusion antigens

CS low molecular weight, acetic acid, mucin, sialic acid

[

pullulan with 1.3% cholesterol and 23% amino residues

44]

[49]

[

63

]

[74]

in situ misemgel

controlled

nanogels

raloxifene

complete release in 6 h

hydrochloride

Ovalbumin

peppermint oil, n-propanolol, n-butanol, Tween® 80, PEG 200, PG, GG, TPGS, linoleic acid, Kolliphor®, RH 40

squalane oil, cyclohexane, surfactant sucrose laurate (L-195)

[45]

[50]

[

64

]

[75]

in situ gel loaded NPs

biphasic

voriconazole

GG, clove oil, nanotransferosomes, Tween 80, lecithin

nanodispersion

prolonged

Ovalbumin

Epsiliseen®-H (ϵ-polylysine), dextran sulfate sodium salt, hydrogen chloride, sodium hydroxide

[46]

[51]

[

65

]

[76]

nanoemulsion

biphasic

quetiapine

Capmul MCM, Emalex LWIS 10, PEG 400, Transcutol P, Tween 80, water, Labrafil M 1944 CC, isopropyl myristate, sesame oil, Lauroglycol 90, miglyol 840

[47]

[52]

NPs

sustained

dolutegravir

sodium

HP-β-CD, DPC, Tween 80, DMSO

[48]

[53]

NPs

slow

acetylcholinesterase reactivator

L-α-phosphatidylcholine, 75% soybean phosphatidylcholine, dihexadecylmethylhydroxyethylammonium bromide, Tween 80, Phospholipon 80, Lipoid S75, 1-(o-tolylazo)-2-naphthol, pyrene, pyridine-2-aldoxime methochloride (Pralidoxime)

[49]

[54]

* Drug release rate as stated by the author(s); CS: chitosan, DPC: diphenyl carbonate, GG: gellan gum, HPMC: hydroxypropylmethylcellulose, HP-β-CD: hydroxypropyl-β-cyclodextrin, Na-CMC: sodium carboxymethylcellulose, NPs: nanoparticles, PEG: polyethylene glycol, PG: propylene glycol, TPGS: d-α-tocopheryl polyethylene glycol 1000 succinate.

6. Excipients Used in Modified Drug Release Vaccines for Nasal Administration

The majority of current vaccinations are designed to be administered systemically by intravenous, intramuscular, subcutaneous, or intradermal routes. Parenterally given intranasal vaccination formulations increase cellular and humoral protection against infections. Because the mucosal and systemic immune systems work differently, the parenteral vaccine cannot make contact with a mucosal barrier to induce mucosal immunity. Vaccine delivery through the nasal route, on the other hand, induces systemic immunity, as well as a powerful mucosal immune response. As a result, nasal administration can be used to deliver proteins, and peptides, as well as medicines. Various carriers of different systems for nasal vaccine delivery include powders, gels, and solutions [50][59]. The excipients and methods used in the recent developments (2017–2022) in the modified release intranasal vaccines are reviewed and summarized, as shown in Table 3.
Table 3.
Vaccines for modified release intranasal immunization.

Vaccine

Release Rate *

API

Excipients

* Drug release rate as stated by the author(s); CS: chitosan, NPs: nanoparticles, SA: sodium alginate.

Video Production Service