The food industry is quite interested in the use of (techno)-functional bioactive compounds from by-products to develop ‘Clean label’ foods in a circular economy. The aim of this review is to evaluate knowledge, scientific evidence, and practical application on the use of green extraction technologies (ultrasound-, microwave-, and enzymatic-assisted) of bioactive compounds from pomegranate peel by-products, and their potential application via the supplementation / fortification of vegetal matrixes to improve their quality, functional properties, and safety. Most studies are mainly focused on ultrasound extraction, which has been widely developed compared to microwave or enzymatic extractions, which should be deeply studied including combinations. After extraction, pomegranate peel by-products (in powders, liquid extract, and/or encapsulated, among others) have been incorporated into several food matrixes, as a good tool to preserve ‘Clean label’ foods without altering their composition and improving their functional properties. Future studies must clearly evaluate the energy efficiency/consumption, the cost, and the environmental impact leading to sustainable extraction of the key bio-compounds. Moreover, predictive models are needed to optimize the phytochemical extraction to help taking decisions along the supply chain
In accordance with Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) definition, ‘food waste’ is the decrease in the quantity and/or quality of food obtaining from decisions and/or actions by retailers, food service providers and consumers, while ‘food loss’ refers to any food that is discarded along the previous food supply chain steps from harvest up to retail sale [1]. FAO indicates that around one third of the food production is globally lost or wasted at some step in the food chain. Depending on the state and the basket item, the losses level greatly varies.
In the case of fruit and vegetables (F&V) at the whole supply chain could reach up to ~50 % (Figure 1). FAO’s future challenges by 2050 is to reduce ~50 % of food waste, as one of the objectives for sustainable development (OSD). Circular economy has been considered as the principles for eco-innovation, being focused on a ‘zero waste’ society and economy, using wastes as raw materials.
Between 2016 and 2018, FAO Statistics Division developed a food loss estimation model called “The Food Loss and Waste database”, an online collection of data including food loss and food waste. Figure 1 shows the % loss of F&V (food loss + food waste) worldwide in each value chain step in the first 20 years of XXI century [2]. The boxes show where ~50 % of the collected data falls into, the mid-value of the percentage loss at every stage in the supply chain is shown by a line. In this sense, postharvest and retailing are the main steps in the food chain where the F&V losses represent the highest mean percentages. Mean percentage during processing is less than 10 %, but in some cases, it reaches ~40 %. Moreover, although the mean percentage during distribution represent less than 10 %, the range is from < 5 % to > 30 %. Therefore, several strategies of creating active packaging with encapsulated key compounds have been developed, to avoid high percentage of food waste/loss [3]. The range of each step is wide since the value depends on the type of F&V, the country, and the year.
Although, this review is focused on pomegranate by-products, percentage of food loss related to this fruit is not available in the mentioned official database. Nevertheless, knowing that the total production of pomegranate worldwide is three million tons, and its peel and seeds approximately represent the ~54 % of the fruit, these results in ~1.62 million tons of waste [4,5]. Therefore, it is a huge amount of waste produced, so it is crucial to find suitable methods to revalorize them by optimizing the bioactive compounds extraction of pomegranate residues and then, convert them into value-added products. Consequently, savings can also be made on other resources involved during production, harvesting, preservation and distribution, such as energy, water, and land, as well as contributing to the environment [5]
Parallelly, health, well-being, and sustainability are the current trend in the food market. Consumers and food producers are interested in ‘Clean label’ foods or ingredients [6,7]. It means that they are interested in foods or ingredients obtained by green-processing technologies (non-thermal, green-solvents), and bioactive compounds with health promoting properties (nutraceuticals), among others. The bioactive compounds obtained from F&V by-products present technological and functional features and can be incorporated within other food matrixes to enhance their nutritional, functional, and sensory quality [6,8]. Also, the use of bioactive compounds from F&V by-products has previously been classified as potential green-ingredients for the cosmetic and pharmaceutical industries, developing different products intended for specific populations such as sport-people [9].
The present review aims to evaluate scientific evidence and knowledge on the use of green technologies for the extraction of phenolic compounds from pomegranate by-products, and its further incorporation techniques and potential applications via the supplementation / fortification of F&V matrixes to improve their quality and safety in a circular economy. For this purpose, a literature review was conducted, focusing on ultrasound-, microwave-, and enzymatic-assisted technology to enhance phenolic compounds extraction from pomegranate peel by-products. Moreover, different incorporation techniques and applications have been reviewed. Results may provide the scientific community with the state of the art on pomegranate peel revalorization. The study may also help scientists, and food industry to develop solutions to better suit society demands.
Technology | Carriers | Target Compound/Activity | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|
Spray-drying | Maltrodextrin | F-TPC, UPLC-TPC, Pn, EA, P, GA | [21][78[22],79] |
Maltrodextrin + others: Tween 80 (99:1); Skimmed milk powder (50:50); Whey protein isolate (50:50); Gum arabic (50:50) | NA (Yield/Stability) | [23][24][28,80] | |
Skimmed milk power | NA (Yield/Stability) | [23][24][28,80] | |
Orange juice byproduct | F-TPC, DPPH | [25][26][81,82] | |
Maltodextrin/Pectin | TPC, Pn, EA | [27][83] |
Matrix | Pomegranate Peel Byproduct |
Extraction | Incorporation Method | Benefit | Ref. | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fresh whole F&V (pre- and postharvest) | Tomato | Drier (50–60 °C, 72 h) Fine powder (more information NA) cv information NA |
Ratio 3:10 EtOH 48 h + evaporator (65 °C) + re-dissolved in sterile distilled water (0.05%, 0.5%, 1% and 5% w/v) |
Preharvest. Tomato plants were sprayed in the leaves (bacteria inoculation) with the aqueous extract + 24 h drying |
Antibacterial activity at least 15 days Replacing, reducing, or even alternating treatments involving copper compounds |
[54][108] | ||||
Sage herb | Air dried (more information NA) Grinder (more information NA) cv information NA |
1:10 solid–liquid ratio in water or EtOH 80% 24 h + evaporator + water dilution | Preharvest. Added in the soil (2, 4, and 6 g per plot) |
Higher dry mass and essential oils Inhibition of free radical scavenging |
[55][109] | |||||
Olive | Oven drier (40 °C) Powder home grinder (more information NA) Wonderful cv |
120 g/L EtOH solvent (50 and 80%) + 1% Citric acid | Postharvest. Treatment of 1 × 1-mm injuries and inoculated (C. acutatum) by 10 µL of pomegranate peel extract (12, 1.2, or 0.12 g/L) |
Reduction of fungal and bacterial population | [56][110] | |||||
Potato tubers | Air drier (28 °C, 10–15 days) Fine powder (more information NA) Baladi cv |
1:10 solid–liquid (MetOH) 48 h 28 °C + evaporator + oven 50 °C 48 h | Postharvest. Wound (3 × 3 mm φ and deep) + inoculation (F. sambucinum) (24 h) + dipping (1.25, 2.5, 5, 10, and 20 mg/mL water) + air dried (2 h at 28 °C). |
Antifungal activity on the mycelial growth and spore germination | [57][111] | |||||
Strawberry | Drying and particle size information NA Dente di caballo cv |
US 40 °C 80% A 3 min (3 on, 8 off) Ratio 1:10 (H2O 25%, propanol 25%, ethanol 25% and methanol 25%) + evaporator + Freeze-drier + re-dissolved in water |
Postharvest. Immersion (30 s in a 2 L solution of pomegranate peel extract) + air-drying (1 h) |
Extension of shelf life Substitution of synthetic pesticides |
[58][112] | Whey protein | Pn, EA, P, GA | |||
Sweet cherry | Oven drier (40 °C) Particle size NA Mollar de Elche cv | [22][79] | ||||||||
EtOH solvent (50 and 80%) + 1% Citric acid +evaporator + Water dilution | Postharvest. | Dipping (2 min) in the pomegranate extract (12, 2.4 or 1.2 g/L) + air drying (2 h, 28 °C) + storage at 1 °C | Inhibition of all fungal spore germination | [59][113] | Arabic gum | Pn, EA | [28][84] | |||
Fresh whole F&V (pre- and postharvest) | Sweet cherry | Oven drier (40 °C) Fine powder < 470 µm cv information NA |
1:8 solid–liquid ratio (Water 28 °C 24 h) | Postharvest. Immersion in pomegranate peel extracts (3 min 20 °C) + room temperature drying |
Pomegranate peel extracts and calcium sulphate coatings, alone or in combination, decreased weight loss, decay, respiration rate, and increased acidity, firmness, ascorbic acid, DPPH, TPC, and TAC | [ | Chitosan | Pn, EA | [28][29][84,85] | |
Pectin | Pn, EA | [28][84] | ||||||||
60 | ] | [ | 114 | ] | ||||||
Apple | Oven drier (40 °C) Particle size NA Mollar de Elche cv |
EtOH solvent (50 and 80%) + 1% citric acid + evaporator + water dilution | Postharvest. Wounds treated with 10 μL of pomegranate peel extract (12, 1.2 or 0.12 g/L) + inoculation (10 μL P. expansum) |
Inhibition of fungal spore germination and decay of artificial inoculations | [59][113] | Modified starch | Pn, TPC, HTC, DPPH | [30 | ||
Mango | Freeze drying (−45 °C, 94 h) Particle size and cv information NA |
MetOH 45 °C 30 min + Bath US + evaporator + water dilution | Postharvest. Chitosan (2%) in 0.5% citric acid solution + Pullulan (2%) in water (50:50 ratios). During stiring: 1% glycerol + 5% of pomegranate peel extract (0.02 g/mL). Dipping for 2 min |
Increase of firmness, TPC and AOX. Prolonged the shelf life | [61][115] | ][86] | ||||
Apricot | Drier (60 °C, 48 h) Particle size < 0.251 mm cv information NA |
80% EtOH 25 °C + evaporator | Postharvest. Chitosan coating solution (1% chitosan in glacial acetic 1% + 0.8% glycerol + Tween 80 + 0.50, 0.75, and 1% pomegranate peel extract) |
Reduction of % decay and weight loss. Maintenance of DPPH radical scavenging activity, ascorbic acid content, titratable acidity and firmness. | [62][116] | Alginate | ||||
Figs | NA (Yield/Stability) | Air dried few days (more information NA) Pulverized (more information NA) cv information NA[29][85] |
||||||||
Alcoholic buffer (EtOH 50%) | Postharvest. | Alginic acid: agar (70:30) + 0.25 and 0.5% pomegranate peel extract Dipping in the coating solution + coating gelation |
Prolonged the shelf life | [63][117] | Freeze-drying | Soy phosphatidylcholine liposomes | Pn, EA, rutin, epifallocatechin, TPC | [31][87] | ||
Dates | Drier (48 °C, 52 h) Ground peels (more information NA)cv information NA |
EtOH 70% + evaporator + Water dilution | Postharvest. 1% Chitosan, 1% nanochitosan or 1% pomegranate peel extract in 1% glacial acetic |
Growth inhibition of any fungal spore after 48 h of coating. | [64 | Maltodextrin (5 and 10%) and b-cyclodextrin (5 and 10%). | F-TPC, FRAP | [32][38] | ||
Prunus armeniaca gum exudates | FRAP, DPPH | [33][88] | ||||||||
] | [ | 118 | ] | Chitosan | FRAP, DPPH | [33][88] | ||||
Maltrodextrin | TPC, TFC, Pn, EA, FRAP, DPPH | [34][89] | ||||||||
Maltodextrin and calcium alginate | ANCs, FRAP, DPPH | [35][ | ||||||||
Citrus | Hot air drier (50 °C, 48 h) Particle size 0.250 mm cv information NA |
2.5:10 Solid–liquid ratio (Ac, EtOH, MetOH, H2O, DMSO) + shaking (6 h) + re-extracted with water evaporation | Postharvest. Immersion of wounded lemons (2 × 1 mm long and wide tip) in pomegranate peel extract (pre-infection and post-infection with P. digitatum) + air drying |
Prevention and control of P. digitatum | [65][119] | |||||
Fresh whole F&V (pre- and postharvest) | Grapefruit | Oven drier (40 °C) Particle size information NA Mollar de Elche cv |
EtOH solvent (50 and 80%) + 1% citric acid evaporator + water dilution |
Postharvest. Wounds treated with 10 μL of pomegranate peel extract (12, 1.2 or 0.12 g/L) + inoculation 10 μL P. digitatum and P. italicum |
Inhibition of all fungal spore germination and decay of artificial inoculations | [66][120] | ||||
Lemon | Oven drier (40 °C) Particle size information NA Mollar de Elche cv |
EtOH solvent (50 and 80%) + 1% citric acid + evaporator + water dilution | Postharvest. Wounds treated with 10 μL of pomegranate peel extract (12, 1.2 or 0.12 g/L) + inoculation 10 μL P. digitatum and P. italicum |
Inhibition of all fungal spore germination and decay of artificial inoculations | [59][66][113,120] | |||||
Mandarin | Drier (70 °C, 48 h) Ground peels (more information NA) Shirine Shahvar cv |
0.25:10 solid–liquid ratio (60% EtOH + 0.1% citric acid) | Postharvest. Wounded (1 × 2 mm φ and depth) + dipping 1 min in pomegranate peel extract concentrations (25, 50, 75, 100%) + inoculation (P. italicum and P. digitatum) + drying |
Reduction of % infected wound and lesion φ (75% or/and 100% extract). Increase of TPC, TFC, and PAL activity (75% or/and 100% extract) | [67][121] | 90] | ||||
Orange | Drier (35 °C, 2 days) Particle size NA Gabsi cv |
1:10, 0.6:10, 0.3:10 solid–liquid ratio (MetOH or Water) + evaporated + drying (40 °C or freeze-drying) + re-dissolved in water | Postharvest. Chitosan coating solution (1% chitosan in glacial acetic 1% + 0.5% Locust bean gum + 20% glycerol + 7, 18, and 36% dry waster/MetOH pomegranate peel extract). Wounded oranges (4 times: 3 × 3 mm φ × deep) + Inoculation (20 μL of a P. digitatum) + drying + dipping in different coating solutions (2 min) |
Controlled growth of Penicillium digitatum Reduction of postharvest decay |
[68][122] | Maltodextrin and soy lecitin | NA (Yield/Stability) | [36][91 | ||
Orange | ] | |||||||||
Oven drier (40 °C) | Particle size NA Mollar de Elche cv |
EtOH solvent (50 and 80%) + 1% citric acid + evaporator + water dilution | Postharvest. Wounded oranges (3 times 2 × 2 mm φ and deep) + 20 μL pomegranate peel extract (12 g/L) + Inoculation (20 μL of a P. digitatum) + 1% citric acid + drying |
Enhanced defense pathways (antibiotic biosynthesis) | [69][123] | Double emulsion | Water1 in Oil in Water2: Water1 (ethanolic solutions) in Oil (castor, soybean, sunflower, medium chain triglyceride and orange) in Water2 (aqueous solution with Tween80 | |||
Fresh whole F&V (pre- and postharvest) | ) | NA (Yield/Stability) | Guava | Drier (60 °C, 72 h) Particle size 0.420 mm [37][92] |
||||||
Bhagwa cv | 1:10 solid–liquid ratio (80% EtOH) + evaporation | Postharvest. | Chitosan (1% chitosan in glacial acetic 1% + 0.75% glycerol) and alginate solution (2% alginate + 10% glycerol + 2% calcium chloride) with 1% pomegranate peel extract | Preserved quality for 20 d under refrigeration | [70][124] | Ion gelation | Chitosan gel (1%):gelatin 2:1 | F-TPC, DPPH | [ | |
Capsicum | Drier (60 °C, 72 h) Particle size 0.420 mm Bhagwa cv |
1:10 solid–liquid ratio (80% EtOH) + evaporation | 38][93] | |||||||
Postharvest. | Chitosan (1% chitosan in glacial acetic 1% + 0.75% glycerol) and alginate solution (2% alginate + 10% glycerol + 2% calcium chloride) with 1% pomegranate peel extract | Inhibition of microbial growth. Preserved sensory quality. | Extension of shelf life up to 25 d at 10 °C |
[71][125] | Spirulina | TPC, DPPH | [ | |||
Pear | Drier (60 °C, 72 h) Particle size 0.420 mm Bhagwa cv | 15][72] | ||||||||
1:10 solid–liquid ratio (80% EtOH) + evaporation | Postharvest. | Chitosan (1% chitosan in glacial acetic 1% + 0.75% glycerol) and alginate solution (2% alginate + 10% glycerol + 2% calcium chloride) with 2% pomegranate peel extract | Lowered the cell wall degrading enzymes activity (firmness preservation) | [72][126] | Microalgae | EA | [39][94] | |||
Chitosan + others: Dialdehyde guar gum Gelatin-based materials |
F-TPC, DPPH | [40][95] |
Fresh-cut/Minimally processed F&V | ||||||
Fruit salad: nectarine and | ||||||
pineapple in cubes | ||||||
covered with | ||||||
fructose syrup | ||||||
Oven drier (38 °C, 48 h) | ||||||
Particle size 500 mm | ||||||
Wonderful cv | ||||||
Powder | ||||||
2.5–5% ( | ||||||
w | ||||||
/ | ||||||
v | ) of pomegranate peel powder at the container bottom | Inhibition of mesophilic bacteria, total psychrotrophic microorganisms, yeasts, and lactic acid bacteria | No negative effect on sensory characteristics | [ | 73][127] | |
Fresh-cut pear, apple and melon (plugs) |
Oven drier (40 °C) Particle size NA Mollar de Elche cv |
EtOH solvent (50 and 80%) + 1% citric acid + evaporator + water dilution | Inoculated plugs were dipped (10 min, 150 rpm) + dried (25 °C 30 min) | Reduction of Listeria monocytogenes | [74][128] | |
Fresh-cut Golden apple wedges: thickness 30-mm and 30 g |
Drying and particle size information NA Dente di cavallo cv |
Pulsed UAE (10 min, <50 °C, 1:40, 26 kHz, 200 W, 40% A, 50% duty cycle) + encapsulation with pectin from citrus peel by spray drying | Enrichment with microencapsulates reconstituted in water 1:1 | Reduction of enzymatic browning. Color preservation | [75][129] | |
Beverages | Carrot juice | Oven drier (40 °C) Grounded in a colloid mill (more information NA) cv information NA |
High pressure-assisted extraction | 5 mg pomegranate peel extract per mL of carrot juice | Improvement of microbiological safety and AOX during storage. Color preservation | [76][77][130,131] |
Beverages | Apple juice | Oven drier (55 °C, 12 h) Particle size and cv information NA |
Maceration extraction (1:50, 80% EtOH 1 h shaking) | Different% of pomegranate peel extract (0–2%) | Enhancing sensory quality and AOX. Low toxicity with 1% of pomegranate peel extract | [78][132] |
Kiwi juice | Information NA | Commercial pomegranate extract (PureBulk, Roseburg) | Extract incorporation (180 μg/mL kiwi juice) + US bath (40 kHz, 180 W, 20 °C, 10–30 min) | US and pomegranate extract combined treatment: higher reductions on yeast and molds | [79][133] | |
Red wine | Green decoction: Boiled in water 60 min (1:40) Freeze-drying of the extract Wonderful cv |
Powder | Purification to obtain the tannins. 8 analyzed tannins (1 g L−1 wine solution) |
Increase of protein stability Increase of color stability Reduction of sulfites |
[80][134] | |
Symbiotic drink powder |
Hot oven (40 °C, 48 h) Particle size Kitchen-miller (more information NA) cv information NA |
Ethanolic extract (80%; 1:15) + evaporator + Freeze-drier | Formulation: beetroot peel extract powder (3%), pomegranate peel extract powder (1%), grape pomace extract powder (1.5%), quince seed gum (0.5%), stevia (4%), mint (0.1%) and water (89.9%). Pasteurization: 72 °C, 90 s | Maintenance of L. casei viability of the recommended level of 10−7 CFU/g | [81][135] |