According to epidemiological data in the U.S and Europe, cancer incidence in childhood is at least 30-fold lower compared to that in adulthood, corresponding roughly to one new case per year over 6500 newborns, children, or adolescents. Despite its rarity, this implies that one child in approximately 300 will be diagnosed with cancer before their twentieth birthday. Pediatric cancer, although rare, requires the most optimized treatment approach to obtain high survival rates and minimize serious long-term side effects in early adulthood.
1st Author, [ref] |
Year | Study Design | Cancer Type | Population (Mean/Median Age) |
18F-FDG PET/CT Time-Points | 18F-FDG Parameters Correlated with Prognosis | Segmentation Methods (Thresholds) |
Prognostic Parameters Predicted |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Li Y-J., [49][90] | 2016 | Meta-analysis P:8/R:15 |
B & STS | 1261 * | Baseline, post-NAC |
SUVmax, MTV, TLG | NR | EFS, OS |
Im HJ., [50][91] | 2018 | P | OST | 34 (12.2) | Baseline, interim, post-NAC |
SUVpeak, MTV, TLG | Fixed-absolute and liver-based | EFS, OS Histologic response |
Annovazzi A., [53][92] | 2021 | R | ESFT | 28 (28.7) * | Baseline, post-NAC |
ΔTLG (cut-off: −60%) | Fixed-relative (40% SUVmax) |
Histologic response |
El-Hennawy G., [54][93] | 2020 | P | ESFT | 36 (9.6) | Baseline, post-NAC |
MTV2(L) (cut-off: 17 mL) TLG2(L) (cut-off: 60 g) ΔTLG(L) (cut-off: −90%) |
Fixed-absolute and liver-based | Histologic response |
Byun BH., [55][94] | 2014 | P | OST | 30 ** (NS) [17 ≤ 15 years 13 > 15 years] |
Baseline, interim, post-NAC |
MTV2.5 (interim) ≥ 47 mL TLG2.5 (interim) ≥ 190 g |
Fixed-absolute (SUVmax: 2.0 and 2.5) | Histologic response |
Bailly C., [57][96] | 2017 | R | OST, ESFT |
61 (13.9) | Baseline, post-NAC |
Elongation (shape textural feature) † |
Adaptive | EFS, OS for OST |
Song H., [67][104] | 2019 | R | OST | 35 (33) * | Baseline post-NAC |
MTV and radiomics (LA, DNU, GLRL_NU, GLSZ_NU) |
Manual (ITK-SNAP 3.8.0) |
EFS Histologic response |
Jeong SY., [58][97] | 2019 | R | OST | 70 * (NS) | Baseline, post-NAC |
MTV, TLG, and radiomics (LCM_Entropy) | MLA | Histologic response |
Kim J., [59][98] | 2021 | R | OST | 105 ** (NS) [80 ≤ 19 years 25 > 19 years] |
Baseline post-NAC |
MTV, TLG, and radiomics (GLCM_entropy, GLSZM_HGLZE GLRLM_SGHGE, NGLDM_SNE) | MLA DLA (2D-CNN) |
Histologic response |
(a) The method of MTV evaluation should “join” the clinical context, otherwise, the type of sarcoma and time of evaluation. OST patients, in general, have lesions with less soft-tissue component and consequently less post-treatment volume shrinkage than ESFT patients. Moreover, persistent bone
18F-FDG uptake could be related to the post-treatment bone-healing reaction [53]. Thus, MTV-fixed “relative” methods could preferably be avoided to limit post-treatment MTV overestimation in OST patients [53].
(b) An early prediction of histopathological response by MTV/TLG and textural features could be most useful after approval of new targeted therapies, which aim to change the standard of care and outcome for pediatric sarcomas. In the current published guide for the practical evaluation of PET response criteria in solid tumors (PERCIST) [74], the concomitant estimation of MTV/TLG parameters (usually by liver-based threshold segmentation methods) has been proposed for better consensus in the assignment of stable, partial, or progressive response to induction treatment. However, reproducibility of MTV/TLG evaluation is a prerequisite for treatment response prediction, still interfering with the MTV/TLG prognostic value in clinical practice.
(c) It should be clear that given the histologic type, pediatric sarcomas are different compared to those of adults. The tumor microenvironment is much more important and a possible target for immunotherapy agents, as implicated in the tumor response to treatment. On the contrary, mutational load and relative neoantigens are less expressed by tumor cells of pediatric sarcomas compared to adult sarcomas. Thus, targeted agents, as those implicated in cell differentiation, are probably more effective in pediatric sarcomas, according to experimental data for the “embryonal” RMS histologic subtype, the most common soft-tissue pediatric sarcoma [42][75][76][77]. Overall, tumor heterogeneity
F-FDG uptake could be related to the post-treatment bone-healing reaction [92]. Thus, MTV-fixed “relative” methods could preferably be avoided to limit post-treatment MTV overestimation in OST patients [92].18F-FDG imaging data reflects the histologic subtype, tumor microenvironment, and tumor molecular and genomic characteristics. Integrating all this information could lead to a more accurate interpretation of PET-based risk stratification and treatment monitoring of the whole tumor lesion of pediatric sarcomas. Interestingly, the first data in “radiogenomics” of adulthood carcinomas revealed an accurate tumor phenotyping and decoding of breast cancer lesions by PET/MR textural features [78][79].
F-FDG imaging data reflects the histologic subtype, tumor microenvironment, and tumor molecular and genomic characteristics. Integrating all this information could lead to a more accurate interpretation of PET-based risk stratification and treatment monitoring of the whole tumor lesion of pediatric sarcomas. Interestingly, the first data in “radiogenomics” of adulthood carcinomas revealed an accurate tumor phenotyping and decoding of breast cancer lesions by PET/MR textural features [109,110].1st Author, [Reference] |
Year | Study Design | Type of Lymphomas | Population (Mean/ Median Age) |
18F-FDG PET/CT Time-Points |
18F-FDG Parameters Correlated with Prognosis | Segmentation Methods (Thresholds) |
Prognostic Parameters Predicted |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Guo B., [105][133] | 2019 | Meta-analysis P:3/R:24 |
HL:3 DLBCL:16 Other NHL:8 |
2729 * | Baseline | MTV, TLG | Fixed-absolute, liver-based, fixed-relative |
PFS, OS |
Frood R., [106][134] | 2021 | Meta-analysis R:41 |
HL:10 DLBCL:31 |
>4000 * | Baseline | SUVmax, MTV, TLG MH ** (radiomics) |
fixed-absolute, liver-based, fixed-relative |
PFS, OS |
Ceriani L., [107][135] | 2020 | P | DLBCL | 141 * (59) | Baseline | MTV, MH ** (radiomics) MTVand MH ** |
Fixed-absolute (SUVmax: 2.5) |
PFS, OS |
Vercellino L., [108][136] | 2020 | P | DLBCL | 298 * (68) | Baseline | MTV (cut-off: 220 mL), MTV and ECOG PS |
Fixed-relative (41% of SUVmax) |
PFS, OS |
Mikhaeel NG., [111][139] | 2016 | P | DLBCL | 147 * (57) | Baseline Interim |
MTV (cut-off: 396 mL), TLG MTV and iPET |
Fixed-absolute (SUVmax: 2.5) | PFS, OS |
Schmitz C., [112][140] | 2020 | P | DLBCL | 510 * (62) | Baseline, Interim |
MTV (cut-off: 328 mL), ΔSUVmax (cut-off: 66%) MTV and iPET |
Fixed-relative (41% of SUVmax) |
PFS, OS |
Albano D., [115][143] |
2019 | R | Burkitt | 65 * (53) | Baseline End-treatment |
MTV (cut-off: 230 mL) TLG |
Fixed-relative (41% of SUVmax) |
PFS, OS |
Cottereau AS., [113][141] | 2020 | P | HL (early stage) |
258 * (31) | Baseline Interim |
MTV (cut-off: 147 mL) MTV and iPET |
Fixed-relative (41% of SUVmax) |
PFS, OS |
Bouallègue FB., [114][142] | 2017 | R | Bulky HL and NHL |
57 * (52) | Baseline | MTV (cut-off: 600 mL) Shape/texture parameters (radiomics) |
Fixed-Relative (30% of SUVmax) |
PFS, OS |
Zhou Y., [118][146] | 2020 | R | HL and NHL | 47 (14.8) | Baseline | TLG | Fixed-absolute (SUVmax: 2.5) |
PFS |
Kim J., [116][144] | 2019 | P | B-NHL | 46 (7.5) | Baseline | MTV, TLG | Fixed-Relative (41% of SUVmax) |
PFS, OS |
Xiao Z., [119][147] | 2021 | R | Burkitt | 68 (7) | Baseline | MTV (cut-off: 550 mL) TLG (cut-off: 2881 g) |
Fixed-relative (41% of SUVmax) |
PFS, OS |
Yang J., [120][148] | 2021 | R | LBL | 30 (6.5) | Baseline | MTV (cut-off: 243 mL) | Fixed-relative (41% of SUVmax) |
PFS, OS |
Mathew B., [121][149] | 2020 | R | ALCL | 50 (8.5) | Baseline, interim |
MTV(cut-off: 180 mL) MTV and iPET |
Fixed-relative (40% of SUVmax) |
PFS, OS |
Milgrom S., [122][150] | 2021 | P | Intermediate-risk HL | 86 (14.5) | Baseline | MTV | Fixed-absolute (SUV blood pool × 2) |
PFS |
Rogasch J., [101][129] | 2018 | R | HL | 50 (14.8) | Baseline | MTV, TLG asphericity (radiomics) |
Fixed-relative (41% of SUVmax) |
PFS, OS iPET |
Rodriguez-Taroco MG., [124][152] | 2021 | P | HL | 21 (12) | Baseline | GLCM (Entropy, energy) NGTDM (coarseness, busyness) |
Fixed-relative (41% of SUVmax) |
iPET |