Unawareness of Chronic Kidney Disease in Germany: Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 2 by Beatrix Zheng and Version 1 by Susanne Stolpe.

Chronic kidney disease (CKD) is associated with an increased risk for cardiovascular events, hospitalizations, end stage renal disease and mortality. Main risk factors for CKD are diabetes, hypertension, and older age. Although CKD prevalence is about 10%, awareness for CKD is generally low in patients and physicians, hindering early diagnosis and treatment. We analyzed baseline data of 3305 participants with CKD Stages 1–4 from German cohorts and registries collected in 2010. Prevalence of CKD unawareness and prevalence ratios (PR) (each with 95%-confidence intervals) were estimated in categories of age, sex, CKD stages, BMI, hypertension, diabetes and other relevant comorbidities. We used a log-binomial regression model to estimate the PR for CKD unawareness for females compared to males adjusting for CKD stage and CKD risk factors. CKD unawareness was high, reaching 71% (68–73%) in CKD 3a, 49% (45–54%) in CKD 3b and still 30% (24–36%) in CKD4. Prevalence of hypertension, diabetes or cardiovascular comorbidities was not associated with lower CKD unawareness. Independent of CKD stage and other risk factors unawareness was higher in female patients (PR = 1.06 (1.01; 1.10)). Even in patients with CKD related comorbidities, CKD unawareness was high. Female sex was strongly associated with CKD unawareness. Guideline oriented treatment of patients at higher risk for CKD could increase CKD awareness. Patient–physician communication about CKD might be amendable. 

  • chronic kidney disease
  • CKD unawareness
  • gender differences

1. Introduction

Chronic kidney disease (CKD) is a highly prevalent disease. Prevalence of renal insufficiency (i.e., CKD Stages 3–5) in Germany is about 10% in a population aged ≥40 years which is comparable to the prevalence of coronary heart disease, diabetes or depression [1,2,3,4][1][2][3][4]. However, CKD is widely unrecognized in its relevance for personal health consequences and its impact on societal health systems’ spending. CKD can lead to terminal renal failure (end stage renal disease, ESRD) which affects about 90,000 patients in Germany. Costs for renal replacement therapy as consequence of ESRD, such as dialysis and renal transplantation, are disproportionally high [1,5,6][1][5][6]. Moreover, CKD is associated with a higher risk for non-renal health outcomes such as cardiovascular diseases, hospitalizations, cognitive decline and premature mortality [5]. Kidney function is assessed by the estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) using equations that incorporate serum creatinine, sex, age and race such as the CKD-Epi, Equation [7]. According to the Kidney Disease Improving Global Outcomes (KDIGO) Guideline, CKD is staged (Stages I to V) using cut points of eGFR and albuminuria (Figure 1). Patients with CKD Stage 5 (=eGFR < 15 mL/min/1.73 m2, (ESRD)) require renal replacement therapy.
Figure 1. CKD staging according to decreasing renal function defined by albuminuria and estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR). ACR = albumin/creatinine ratio, CVD = cardiovascular disease, ESRD = end stage renal disease, KDIGO = Kidney Disease Improving Global Outcomes (=Guideline).
Timely start of treatment and monitoring of CKD risk factors such as hypertension can decelerate the decrease of renal function [8]. CKD remains asymptomatic throughout a long time leading to late diagnosis in advanced stages defined by severely reduced renal function. Regarding renal insufficiency in elderly patients, discussions in the medical community whether a decline of renal function in older age should be regarded as normal physiologic aging process or be labelled as ‘disease’ are still ongoing [9].
Contrasting to diseases similarly prevalent as coronary heart disease or diabetes, for CKD, a high public and patient unawareness has been reported: unawareness was about 80% in early stages, and about 30% in later stages in populations from USA, Australia or Taiwan [10], even in patients with markers for renal dysfunction [11]. In the German Health Interview and Examination Survey for Adults (DEGS), 72% of participants—drawn from the general population—with a decreased renal function (defined as eGFR < 60 mL/min/1.73 m2), did not know about their condition [12]. CKD unawareness was even high in German patients hospitalized due to cardiovascular diseases [13]. Public knowledge about CKD is scarce [14]. Screening for CKD among patients and populations at higher risk was shown to be cost-effective [15], but is lacking on routine basis —resulting in late diagnosis and delayed treatment. Although eGFR should be calculated and printed automatically on patients’ laboratory reports that include measurement of serum creatinine, this seems not to lead to a routine ascertainment of kidney function and diagnosis of CKD. Physician–patient communication about CKD and its relevance for health seems to be more difficult in CKD than in other chronic diseases with negative impact on patients’ involvement and compliance to treatment [16,17][16][17].
CKD unawareness can result from either not yet being diagnosed or not being told about by a physician or not fully grasp the meaning of CKD information.
We wanted to estimate CKD unawareness focusing on patients with CKD related risk factors, as these patients can be expected to be targeted in primary health care for monitoring renal function according to guidelines. Among these patients, we wanted to identify demographic and clinical factors that are associated with low CKD awareness.

2. Current Insights

In a population of patients with high prevalence of CKD risk factors, CKD unawareness was 80% in early CKD Stages 1 and 2 and still about 30% in patients with CKD Stage 4. Unawareness for CKD was seen even in the elderly or patients with hypertension or diabetes. In these patients, guidelines for treatment and drug prescribing recommend a routine monitoring of renal function. Therefore, the extent of CKD unawareness was unexpected in these subgroups and may reflect a low adherence or knowledge of guidelines. A gender gap in CKD awareness with a higher unawareness in women increased distinctly with increasing stages of CKD and was visible independently of other CKD risk factors.

2.1. Unawareness in Patients, Physicians and Public

Information on CKD awareness was derived from the participants’ answer to the question whether they had ever been told by their physician that they had a renal disease or kidney stones. Therefore, patients’ unawareness could either derive from a lack of understanding of the physicians’ information about their CKD or from their physicians’ unawareness of their CKD. Wagner et al. showed that hospital patients’ informational status regarding a prevalent CKD directly depended on physicians awareness [13].
In 2009, in a report on the prevalence of patients with chronic diseases in general practice, the authoring physicians did not select CKD as one of 20 relevant diseases and conditions [24][18], although CKD prevalence in this setting is estimated to be about 30% [25][19]. Guidelines on treatment of hypertension or diabetes are much more familiar in general practice than those dealing with CKD [26][20]. It has been shown that interventions to increase CKD knowledge and awareness in primary care physicians can lead to better CKD diagnoses and risk factor management [27][21].
In about 80% of the records of patients in general practice [28][22] and in hospitalized patients due to cardiovascular events [13], a prevalent CKD was not mentioned in their record, less so in patients with diabetes or obese patients. Even patients treated for CKD are often unaware. In patients from a nephrological outpatient clinic, unawareness of CKD Stage 1 or 2 was 40%, and in later stages about 12% [29][23]. In UK, 41% of patients with CKD Stage 3 that are documented in their GPs CKD registry were unaware of their disease [30][24].
The high CKD unawareness in patients at higher age (≥70 years) is disturbing. Age-related physiological changes in pharmacodynamics along with decreasing glomerular filtration require renal monitoring and adjustment of prescription and dosing of drugs. About 90% of the older patients in our study reported intake of antihypertensive medication. Therefore, they should regularly visit their GP. In our cohort, with increasing age, in CKD Stages 3b and 4 unawareness increased also. Physicians seem reluctant to disclose CKD related laboratory findings to their patients. As it is still discussed when to define CKD as a ‘disease’ in the elderly [9], physicians do not want to alarm their patients needlessly, when CKD is still not causing any trouble and worry about over-medicalization. However, an eGFR < 30 mL/min/1.73 m2 defining CKD Stage 4 should be generally regarded as pathologic. On the other hand, if physicians inform their patients about a renal dysfunction, patients may not grasp the meaning and impact it has on their health [31][25]. Cognitive decline which has found to be linked to CKD might negatively affect patients’ awareness [32][26]. However, in an analysis of primary care encounters, CKD was less often discussed than other conditions and information about CKD was given mostly about technical details as laboratory values [17[17][27],33], although better health information facilitates success in patients’ adherence to treatments [16,34][16][28].

2.2. CKD Unawareness and Additional CKD Related Risk Factors

In our cohort, in 97% of all patients, at least one condition was present which should prompt screening of renal function. However, even patients already treated or with diagnostic markers for CKD were often unaware. Albuminuria as marker for CKD seem to trigger renal screening, as unawareness was lower in these patients in our—as well as in other—cohorts [11].
Diabetes, hypertension or cardiovascular diseases were more prevalent in our cohort than in CKD patients in general [35][29]. Diabetic patients are at higher risk for diabetic nephropathy or other renal function disorders. Known diabetes as well as hypertension should trigger monitoring renal function. Nonetheless, unawareness was about 70% in diabetic or hypertensive patients with CKD Stage 3a and 50% in CKD Stage 3b. A German study found a similar CKD unawareness in patients with coronary heart disease [13]. US studies reported even higher CKD unawareness in patients with diabetes or hypertension [36][30]. In our data, still 36% of patients with diabetes and CKD Stage 4 were unaware of their CKD. A finding that is difficult to explain, as metformin, an anti-diabetic drug, is contraindicated in CKD Stage 4.

2.3. Unawareness and High Risk of Renal Failure

In our cohort, 21% of patients with a risk for renal failure within five years ≥15% according to the KFRE risk score were not informed about the critical state of their disease. These patients might lack necessary time for preparation for renal replacement options. In patients from NHANES with CKD Stages 3–4, unawareness was even higher among those with a KFRE risk of ≥15% (50%) [37][31].

2.4. Gender Gap in CKD Awareness

The gender gap in CKD awareness was unexpected, especially the strong increase with decreasing renal function. As unawareness for CKD in higher stages can be associated with higher probability of non-treatment or non-adherence to a treatment, women will have a higher risk for CKD-related adverse health outcomes such as cardiovascular diseases, hospitalizations, and premature mortality. In 187 participants with CKD from a German population, sex differences in CKD awareness were not visible [12]. A recent analysis of NHANES data found a higher CKD unawareness in women compared to men, but only in the Caucasian participants. Sex differences were smaller than in our cohort [38][32]. It is difficult to explain why women are more often unaware about a potentially critical CKD stage. Women were similarly affected by comorbidities which should require renal monitoring by a physician. Then, they would be informed about a CKD in the same manner as men. Women have been shown to be more interested in health and are more actively seeking health-related information than men [39][33]. Men, independent of educational attainment, are less engaged in healthy lifestyles than women [40][34], including exhibiting less proactive and preventive behavior [41][35]. Sex differences in treatment and disease outcome could be related to physicians’ bias and unconscious attitudes towards female and male patients [42][36].

References

  1. Brück, K.; Stel, V.S.; Gambaro, G.; Hallan, S.; Völzke, H.; Ärnlöv, J.; Kastarinen, M.; Guessous, I.; Vinhas, J.; Stengel, B.; et al. CKD Prevalence Varies across the European General Population. J. Am. Soc. Nephrol. 2015, 27, 2135–2147.
  2. Heidemann, C.; Scheidt-Nave, C. Prevalence, incidence and mortality of diabetes mellitus in adults in Germany. J. Health Monit. 2017, 2, 105–129.
  3. Bretschneider, J.; Kuhnert, R.; Hapke, U. Depressive symptoms in adults in German. J. Health Monit. 2017, 2, 81–88.
  4. Goesswald, A.; Schienkiewitz, A.; Nowossadeck, E.; Busch, M. Prevalence of myocardial infarction and coronary heart disease in adults aged 40–79 years in Germany. Results of the German health interview and examination survey for adults (DEGS1)Antje Goesswald. Eur. J. Public Health 2013, 23, 650–655.
  5. Baumeister, S.E.; Böger, C.A.; Krämer, B.K.; Döring, A.; Eheberg, D.; Fischer, B.; John, J.; Koenig, W.; Meisinger, C. Effect of Chronic Kidney Disease and Comorbid Conditions on Health Care Costs: A 10-Year Observational Study in a General Population. Am. J. Nephrol. 2010, 31, 222–229.
  6. Ng, J.K.; Li, P.K.-T. Chronic kidney disease epidemic: How do we deal with it? Nephrology 2018, 23, 116–120.
  7. Levey, A.S.; Tighiouart, H.; Simon, A.L.; Inker, L.A. Comparing Newer GFR Estimating Equations Using Creatinine and Cystatin C to the CKD-EPI Equations in Adults. Am. J. Kidney Dis. 2017, 70, 587–589.
  8. Whaley-Connell, A.; Nistala, R.; Chaudhary, K. The Importance of Early Identification of Chronic Kidney Disease. Mo. Med. 2011, 108, 25–28.
  9. Delanaye, P.; Jager, K.J.; Bökenkamp, A.; Christensson, A.; Dubourg, L.; Eriksen, B.O.; Gaillard, F.; Gambaro, G.; van der Giet, M.; Glassock, R.J.; et al. CKD: A Call for an Age-Adapted Definition. J. Am. Soc. Nephrol. 2019, 30, 1785–1805.
  10. Hsiao, L.-L. Raising awareness, screening and prevention of chronic kidney disease: It takes more than a village. Nephrology 2018, 23, 107–111.
  11. Tuot, D.S.; Plantinga, L.C.; Hsu, C.-Y.; Jordan, R.; Burrows, N.R.; Hedgeman, E.; Yee, J.; Saran, R.; Powe, N.R. Centers for Disease Control. Chronic Kidney Disease Surveillance Team Chronic Kidney Disease Awareness Among Individuals with Clinical Markers of Kidney Dysfunction. Clin. J. Am. Soc. Nephrol. 2011, 6, 1838–1844.
  12. Girndt, M.; Trocchi, P.; Scheidt-Nave, C.; Markau, S.; Stang, A. The Prevalence of Renal Failure. Results from the German Health Interview and Examination Survey for Adults, 2008–2011 (DEGS1). Dtsch. Ärzteblatt Int. 2016, 113, 85–91.
  13. Wagner, M.; Wanner, C.; Schich, M.; Kotseva, K.; Wood, D.; Hartmann, K.; Fette, G.; Rücker, V.; Oezkur, M.; Störk, S.; et al. Patient’s and physician’s awareness of kidney disease in coronary heart disease patients—A cross-sectional analysis of the German subset of the EUROASPIRE IV survey. BMC Nephrol. 2017, 18, 321.
  14. Welch, J.L.; Ellis, R.J.B.; Perkins, S.M.; Johnson, C.S.; Zimmerman, L.M.; Russell, C.L.; Richards, C.; Guise, D.M.; Decker, B.S. Knowledge and Awareness Among Patients with Chronic Kidney Disease Stage 3. Nephrol. Nurs. J. J. Am. Nephrol. Nurses Assoc. 2016, 43, 513–519.
  15. Komenda, P.; Rigatto, C.; Tangri, N. Screening Strategies for Unrecognized CKD. Clin. J. Am. Soc. Nephrol. 2016, 11, 925–927.
  16. Greene, J.; Hibbard, J.H. Why Does Patient Activation Matter? An Examination of the Relationships Between Patient Activation and Health-Related Outcomes. J. Gen. Intern. Med. 2012, 27, 520–526.
  17. Greer, R.C.; Cooper, L.A.; Crews, D.C.; Powe, N.R.; Boulware, L.E. Quality of Patient-Physician Discussions About CKD in Primary Care: A Cross-sectional Study. Am. J. Kidney Dis. 2011, 57, 583–591.
  18. Edigi, G.; Schelp, H. Prävalenz chronischer Krankheiten und Qualitätsindikatoren in einer Bremer Hausarztpraxis. Z. Allg. Med. 2009, 85, 187–195.
  19. Gergei, I.; Klotsche, J.; Woitas, R.P.; Pieper, L.; Wittchen, H.-U.; Krämer, B.K.; Wanner, C.; Mann, J.F.E.; Scharnagl, H.; März, W.; et al. Chronic kidney disease in primary care in Germany. J. Public Health 2017, 25, 223–230.
  20. Plantinga, L.C.; Tuot, D.S.; Powe, N.R. Awareness of Chronic Kidney Disease Among Patients and Providers. Adv. Chronic Kidney Dis. 2010, 17, 225–236.
  21. Harvey, G.; Oliver, K.; Humphreys, J.; Rothwell, K.; Hegarty, J. Improving the identification and management of chronic kidney disease in primary care: Lessons from a staged improvement collaborative. Int. J. Qual. Health Care 2015, 27, 10–16.
  22. Kitsos, A.; Peterson, G.M.; Jose, M.D.; Khanam, M.A.; Castelino, R.L.; Radford, J.C. Variation in Documenting Diagnosable Chronic Kidney Disease in General Medical Practice: Implications for Quality Improvement and Research. J. Prim. Care Community Health 2019, 10.
  23. Devraj, R.; Borrego, M.; Vilay, A.M.; Pailden, J.; Horowitz, B. Awareness, self-management behaviors, health literacy and kidney function relationships in specialty practice. World J. Nephrol. 2018, 7, 41–50.
  24. McIntyre, N.J.; Fluck, R.; McIntyre, C.; Taal, M. Treatment needs and diagnosis awareness in primary care patients with chronic kidney disease. Br. J. Gen. Pract. 2012, 62, e227–e232.
  25. Greer, R.C.; Liu, Y.; Cavanaugh, K.; Diamantidis, C.J.; Estrella, M.M.; Sperati, C.J.; Soman, S.; Abdel-Kader, K.; Agrawal, V.; Plantinga, L.C.; et al. Primary Care Physicians’ Perceived Barriers to Nephrology Referral and Co-management of Patients with CKD: A Qualitative Study. J. Gen. Intern. Med. 2019, 34, 1228–1235.
  26. Viggiano, D.; Wagner, C.A.; Martino, G.; Nedergaard, M.; Zoccali, C.; Unwin, R.; Capasso, G. Mechanisms of cognitive dysfunction in CKD. Nat. Rev. Nephrol. 2020, 16, 452–469.
  27. Greer, R.C.; Crews, D.C.; Boulware, E. Challenges perceived by primary care providers to educating patients about chronic kidney disease. J. Ren. Care 2012, 38, 174–181.
  28. Sunol, R.; Somekh, D. EMPAHTiE—Empowering Patients in the Management of Chronic Diseases; EMPATHiE Consortium: Brussels, Belgium, 2014.
  29. Collins, A.J.; Gilbertson, D.T.; Snyder, J.J.; Chen, S.-C.; Foley, R.N. Chronic kidney disease awareness, screening and prevention: Rationale for the design of a public education program. Nephrology 2010, 15, 37–42.
  30. Obadan, N.O.; Walker, R.; Egede, L.E. Independent correlates of chronic kidney disease awareness among adults with type 2 diabetes. J. Diabetes Complicat. 2017, 31, 988–991.
  31. Chu, C.D.; McCulloch, C.E.; Banerjee, T.; Pavkov, M.E.; Burrows, N.R.; Gillespie, B.W.; Saran, R.; Shlipak, M.G.; Powe, N.R.; Tuot, D.S.; et al. CKD Awareness Among US Adults by Future Risk of Kidney Failure. Am. J. Kidney Dis. 2020, 76, 174–183.
  32. Hödlmoser, S.; Winkelmayer, W.C.; Zee, J.; Pecoits-Filho, R.; Pisoni, R.L.; Port, F.K.; Robinson, B.M.; Ristl, R.; Krenn, S.; Kurnikowski, A.; et al. Sex differences in chronic kidney disease awareness among US adults, 1999 to 2018. PLoS ONE 2020, 15, e0243431.
  33. Ek, S. Gender differences in health information behaviour: A Finnish population-based survey. Health Promot. Int. 2015, 30, 736–745.
  34. Dawson, K.; Schneider, M.; Fletcher, P.C.; Bryden, P.J. Examining gender differences in the health behaviors of Canadian university students. J. R. Soc. Promot. Health 2007, 127, 38–44.
  35. Avdic, D.; Hägglund, P.; Lindahl, B.; Johansson, P. Sex differences in sickness absence and the morbidity-mortality paradox: A longitudinal study using Swedish administrative registers. BMJ Open 2019, 9, e024098.
  36. Chapman, E.N.; Kaatz, A.; Carnes, M. Physicians and Implicit Bias: How Doctors May Unwittingly Perpetuate Health Care Disparities. J. Gen. Intern. Med. 2013, 28, 1504–1510.
More