4. MOFs in Optical Detection of Hg2+
Similar to nanomaterials-based sensors
[70], MOFs in the form of micro/nano-structures can be used in effective detection of Hg
2+. In this light, the zirconium (Zr) metal-incorporated MOFs were reported for luminescent and colorimetric quantification of Hg
2+ ions
[71,72,73,74,75,76,77][71][72][73][74][75][76][77]. Yang and co-workers developed a porous phorpyrinic luminescent metal–organic framework (LMOF;
PCN-224) with meso-tetra(4-carboxyphenyl) porphyrin (TCPP) ligands and Zr metal nodes via modified solvothermal method and applied in Hg
2+ sensors
[71]. During detection of Hg
2+, the probe displayed a bright red to dark red fluorescent quenching and a purple to light green colorimetric response within 2 min. The sensor response of
PCN-224 was not affected by the presence of any competing ions and was reversible in the presence of KI solution (up to seven cycles) as depicted in
Figure 2. The
PCN-224 revealed a linear response to Hg
2+ from 0.1 to 10 micromole (µM) with a detection limit (LOD) of 6 nanomole (nM). Moreover, probe
PCN-224 was also more effective towards the detection of Hg
2+ in real samples, such as tab and river water.
Figure 2. Illustration of the sensor construction protocol. The inherent TCPP linker was designed as the recognition site as well as the signal reporter for Hg
2+ sensing at the same time. Upon the addition of solution into the
PCN-224-Hg
2+ system, analytes were disassociated and fluorescence of
PCN-224 was recovered while the visual colour also turned from light green to purple (Reproduced with the permission from Ref
[71]).
The
UIO-66 (archetypal metal–organic framework (MOF) was reported for effective detection of Hg
2+. It contains the metal nodes that comprise a zirconium oxide complex bridged by terepthalic acid (1,4-benzenedicarboxylic acid) ligands). Hg
2+ detection in aqueous media can be further improved by tuning the structural features of
UIO-66 via modifying the terephthalic acid bridging unit or by post-doping process (PSM)
[72,73,74][72][73][74]. Zhang et al. developed the fluorescent MOF (
UIO-66-PSM) via coupling
UIO-66-N3 with phenylacetylene to use in sensing of Hg
2+ in aqueous media
[72]. Terephthalic acid with azide group was used to synthesize the
UIO-66-N3, which showed reactivity to phenylacetylene. The Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) surface area of
UIO-66-PSM was estimated as 606 m
2 g
−1 to N
2 gas at 77K. In this work,
UIO-66-PSM displayed great selectivity to Hg
2+ via fluorescence quenching with a linear behavior from 0 to 78.1 µM and an estimated LOD of 5.88 µM. Moreover, Hg
2+ detection by the
UIO-66-PSM was demonstrated in tap and lake water interrogations. However, the adsorption capability of
UIO-66-PSM to Hg
2+ in the presence of other ions still needs to be clarified. In a similar fashion, Samanta and co-workers described synthesis of the
UIO-66@Butyne by reacting ZrCl
4 with 2,5-bis(but-3-yn-1-yloxy) terephthalic acid and applied it in quantifying Hg
2+ in aqueous medium
[73]. The
UIO-66@Butyne displayed a fluorescence quenching response to Hg
2+ via the reaction-based chemodosimeter mechanism. In which, the triple bonded acetylene unit present over the surface reacted with Hg
2+ and led to green fluorescence quenching with a LOD of 10.9 nM. It also showed higher selectivity to Hg
2+ than that of other ions. The BET surface area of
UIO-66@Butyne was found to be 74 m
2 g
−1 for Hg
2+ at 77K. Regarding to structural modification, Xiaoxiong et al. proposed post doping of Eu
3+ over the surface of
UIO-66 type MOF (
Eu3+@UIO-66 (DPA) (synthesized by reacting ZrCl
4 and isophthalic acid with 2,6-pyridinedicarboxylic acid (DPA)) to apply in sensor studies
[74]. Due to the doping of Eu
3+, the MOF displayed strong red fluorescence via coordination of Eu
3+ with pyridine “nitrogen” and acid group. Upon the addition of metal ions to the above MOF system, only Fe
3+ and Hg
2+ ions showed fluorescence quenching at 615 nm (in water) via Eu
3+ atom displacement. However, adding hydrogen peroxide (H
2O
2; acted as a masking agent for Fe
3+) eliminated the interfering effect of Fe
3+ over Hg
2+ selectivity and delivered a linear response between 10 nM to 2.5 µM with a LOD of 8.26 nM (lower than the allowed limit). In terms of the strategy and LOD, this work is an impressive one, but demonstrations in real time applications are missing in this report.
Wang and co-workers constructed a novel Zr-based MOF (
RuUIO-67) integrated with ruthenium (Ru) complex for colorimetric sensing of Hg
2+, which was reversible with KI solution
[75]. The
UIO-67 is comprised of Zr
6O
4(OH)
4 nodes strutted by linear 4,4′-biphenyldicarboxylic acid (H
2bpdc) bridging ligands. It is further doped with ruthenium complex Ru(H
2bpydc)(bpy)(NCS)
2 (achieved by reacting [RuCl
2(p-cymene)]
2, 2,2′-bipyridine (bpy), 2,2′-bipyridine-5,5′-dicarboxy (H
2bpydc) with ammonium thiocyanate (NH
4NCS)) to yield the
RuUIO-67 MOF. Upon the addition of Hg
2+ (in HEPES buffer, pH 7.4) to
RuUIO-67 in methanol-water (8:2), the initial absorption band at 540 nm gradually disappeared and a new band at 435 nm was visualized due to the strong binding of sulphur “S” atom present in the NCS group. The MOF showed a linear response between 0–13 µM with a LOD of 0.5 µM (0.1 ppm) and a naked eye LOD of 7.2 µM. Moreover, reversibility up to six cycles was achieved when I
- (KI solution) was added to the sensory system. However, it still needs to focus on competing interrogations. Li et al. described the modified
UIO-68 (Zr
6O
4(OH)
4 clusters linked with 4,4′-terphenyldicarboxylate (TPDC)) MOFs
UIO-68-NCS,
UIO-68-R6G, and
UIO-68-R6G′ via post-synthetic modification strategy towards colorimetric and fluorescent detection of Hg
2+ [76]. Reaction of the
UIO-68-NH2 with thio-phosgene and triethylamine led to formation of the
UIO-68-NCS, which was further reacted with N-(rhodamine-6G) lactam-ethylenediamine (R6G-EDA) and Hg(NO
3)
2 hydrate to yield the
UIO-68-R6G and
UIO-68-R6G′, respectively. In the presence of Hg
2+,
UIO-68-R6G displayed in red and enhanced “turn-on” red emission with corresponding changes in particle sizes as seen in
Figure 3.
Figure 3. (
a) SEM images of
UIO-68-NH2,
UIO-68-NCS,
UIO-68-R6G, and
UIO-68-R6G′ and their as-synthesized samples. (
b) Emission spectra of
UIO-68-R6G (0.1 mg mL
−1) upon the addition of Hg
2+ at different concentrations in the Tris-HCl buffer solution.
Ksv = 4.1 × 10
9 L mol
−1. The emission maximum was observed at 566 nm (
λex = 488 nm). Linearity relationship between Hg
2+ with different concentrations and relative emission intensities, and the time-dependent emission of
UIO-68-R6G with the sequential addition of Hg
2+ are shown in the insets. (
c) Emission response of
UIO-68-R6G toward various metal ions (10
−4 M) in an aqueous solution (0.9 mL) of
UIO-68-R6G (0.1 mg mL
−1): (1) blank, (2) Ag
+, (3) Ca
2+, (4) Co
2+, (5) Cr
3+, (6) Cu
2+, (7) Fe
2+, (8) Hg
2+, (9) K
+, (10) Mg
2+, (11) Na
+, (12) Ni
2+, (13) Pb
2+, and (14) Zn
2+. The corresponding sample photographs are inserted (Reproduced with the permission from Ref
[76]).
Based on the N
2 uptake at 77K, the BET surface area of
UIO-68-NH2,
UIO-68-NCS,
UIO-68-R6G, and
UIO-68-R6G′ were established as 674 cm
3 g
−1, 620 cm
3 g
−1, 405 cm
3 g
−1, and 326.83 cm
3 g
−1, correspondingly. The decrease in BET surface area was attributed to the incorporation of larger rhodamine-thiocarbamide unit, which reduced the porosity. The UIO-68-R6G in Tris-HCl buffer solution displayed a linear response to Hg
2+ from 10
−8 to 10
−1 M with a LOD of 0.1 nM and was demonstrated with applicability in in-vitro/in- vivo bio-imaging studies. Thereafter, Kim and co-workers presented the MOF-
SALI-MAA-3eq via incorporation of three equivalents of mercaptoacetic acid into
NU-1000 (comprised of Zr
6(μ
3-O)
4(μ
3-OH)
4(H
2O)
4(OH)
4 nodes and tetratopic 1,3,6,8-(
p-benzoate)pyrene linkers) towards the determination of Hg
2+ [77]. Based on the N
2 adsorption-desorption isotherms at 77K, the BET surface area of
NU-1000 and
SALI-MAA-3eq were found as 2253 m
2 g
−1 and 1906 m
2 g
−1, correspondingly. The decrease in surface area was related to the incorporation of mercaptoacetic acid. The
SALI-MAA-3eq in water showed a linear response from 0.1 to 10 mM, however, the LOD was not provided. This work requires further investigations in competing and applicability studies.
Subsequently, by coordinating the 5-boronobezene-1, 3-dicarboxylic acid with Eu
3+ ions, the boric acid (BA)-functionalized lanthanide metal-organic framework (
BA-Eu-MOF) was reported in detection of Hg
2+ and CH
3Hg
+ species in aqueous medium
[78]. The
BA-Eu-MOF was in the form of meso-porous nanoparticles with a uniform size distribution of ~400 nm. It also showed characteristics of red emission, good dispersive ability, and water solubility. Initially, the “antenna” effect was passivated by boric acid (BA) and the
BA-Eu-MOF showed weak red emission. During detection of Hg
2+ and CH
3Hg
+ species via chemodosimeter reaction between BA and the analytes, the “antenna” effect was recovered and led to strong red fluorescence under UV-lamp (λ
ex = 365 nm). The BET surface area of
BA-Eu-MOF was established as 39.7 m
2 g
−1 to N
2 gas at 77K. Upon the addition of the Hg
2+ and CH
3Hg
+, photoluminescence (PL) response at 620 nm was linearly enhanced between 1–60 µM and 1–80 µM with a LODs of 220 nM and 440 nM. Moreover,
BA-Eu-MOF showed higher selectivity over other competing mono- and di-valent cations in real time river water applications.
MOFs composed of other lanthanide metal nodes have also been engaged in the Hg
2+ discrimination. By reacting the organic ligand “4,4′,4′′-s-triazine-1,3,5-triyltri-p-amino-benzoic acid (H
3TATAB)” with lanthanide metals (Ln = Eu, Tb, Sm, Dy and Gd), the
Ln(TATAB)·(DMF)4(H2O)(MeOH)0.5 MOFs were produced in quantitative yields and were interrogated towards metal ions detection
[79]. Wherein, only the
TbTATAB in water showed selective sensitivity to Hg
2+ but not the other lanthanide ions (Eu, Sm, Dy and Gd) containing MOFs. During Hg
2+ detection, luminescence of
TbTATAB at 494, 544, 587, and 622 nm (quantum yield = 77.48%) was quenched linearly from 0 to 50 µM with a LOD of 4.4 nM. This work also demonstrated Hg
2+ detection in real water samples (river water, drinking water, and tap water), but information on the nanostructure and BET surface area were missing. Recently, Li et al. developed two MOFs, namely
{[Tb2(bpda)3(H2O)3]·H2O}n and
{[Dy2(bpda)3(H2O)3]·H2O}n, by reacting 2,2′-bipyridine-4,4′-dicarboxylic acid (H
2bpda) with LnCl
3.6H
2O (Ln = Tb and Dy) and engaged them in sensory investigations
[80]. The
{[Dy2(bpda)3(H2O)3]·H2O showed fluorescent quenching with Hg
2+ at 489, 543, 582, and 620 nm (λ
ex = 310 nm) with a K
SV value of 20,406 M
−1 and a LOD of 7.2 nM. This work requires additional investigations on the BET surface area and interference studies.
Researches in Hg
2+ sensing using zinc containing MOFs were also described as follows. Morsali′s research group proposed a double solvent sensing method (DSSM) to detect Hg
2+ with great accuracy by using a zinc-based MOF [Zn(OBA)-(DPT)
0.5]·DMF, namely
TMU-34(-2H), where OBA, DPT, and DMF represent 4,4′-oxybis(benzoic acid), 3,6-di(pyridin-4-yl)-1,2,4,5-tetrazine, and N, N-dimethylformamide, respectively
[81]. The BET specific surface area of
TMU-34(-2H) to N
2 gas at 77K was 667 m
2 g
−1 and was able to adsorb 201 cm
3 g
−1 of N
2 gas. In the presence of Hg
2+, the
TMU-34(-2H) displayed 1D-transduction signals of 243% PL enhancement in water at 648 nm (λ
ex = 504 nm) and 90% PL quenching in acetonitrile at 618 nm (λ
ex = 458 nm) with estimated LODs as 1.8 µM and 6.9 µM, correspondingly, within 15 seconds. However, both solvents suffered interfering effects from other ions. Therefore, DSSM tactic was proposed to improve the sensitivity to Hg
2+ by combining water and acetonitrile. Wherein, the sensing factor of Hg
2+ was found as 41 by plotting 2D sensing curve, which was higher than that of all other metal ions with sensing factors between 0–2. Thus, the interfering effects was eliminated. However, its applicability is still in question due to the lack of mechanistic aspects. Thereafter an anionic MOF, namely
Zn-TPTC (TPTC represents [2,2′:6′,2′′-Terpyridine]-4,4′,4′′-tricarboxylic acid), was presented for luminescent detection of Hg
2+ [82]. Upon addition of Hg
2+, the
Zn-TPTC displayed linear PL quenching at 492 nm in a concentration range of 1 to 100 µM and an estimated LOD of 3.7 nM. The ‘N′ atoms of the MOF may interact with Hg
2+ because of the greater affinity. There is no information regarding the BET surface area as well as the competing and application studies.
Subsequently, Pankajakshan et al. described Hg
2+ sensing ability of
{[Zn(4,4′-AP) (5-AIA)]. (DMF)0.5}n, (where 4,4′ AP = 4,4′-azopyridine, 5-AIA and DMF represent deprotonated 5-amino isophthalic acid and N,N′-dimethylformamide), via PL quenching at 405 nm in aqueous solution
[83]. The MOF probe possessed a QY value of 11% and BET surface area of 173 m
2 g
−1. It was stable in pH range 4 to 11 and exhibited a linear PL quenching response to Hg
2+ in a concentration range of 9.99 µM to 20 mM. Moreover, the MOF displayed a high selectivity to Hg
2+ over a wide range of competing mono-, di-, and tri-valent cationic species with a LOD down to 10
−11 M and an estimated K
SV value of 1.011 ×10
9 M
−1 s
−1. In fact, the sensitivity was attributed to a specific interaction between Hg
2+ and the free standing -N=N- of 4,4′-azopyridine. This work undoubtedly can be considered exceptional because of its performance in the real time Hg
2+ detection (in seawater, river water, tap water, drinking water, and single crystals of MOF on an aluminum foil). Thereafter Khatun and co-workers developed the luminescent pillared paddle wheel MOF-
Zn2(NDC)2(DPTTZ) with naphthalene dicarboxylate (NDC) antenna and N,N′-di(4-pyridyl)thiazolo-[5,4-d]thiazole (DPTTZ) pillars, which detected Hg
2+ via red-shifts in PL emission
[84]. In addition, MOF-
Zn2(1,4-BDC)2(DPTTZ)2 was also synthesized for comparison, where the 1,4-BDC represents 1,4-benzenedicarboxylic acid. The BET surface area and pore volumes of MOFs-
Zn2(NDC)2(DPTTZ) and
Zn2(1,4-BDC)2(DPTTZ)2 to CO
2 were estimated as 106.8 m
2 g
−1, 113.4 m
2 g
−1 and 6.6 × 10
−2 cm
3 g
−1, 7.8 × 10
−2 cm
3 g
−1, respectively. The
Zn2(NDC)2(DPTTZ) in DMF showed an exceptional selectivity only to Hg
2+ among all ions via bathochromic PL shift from 410 nm to 450 nm. Although lacking experimental evidences, it was speculated that the PL change could be attributed to the interaction between Hg
2+ and DPTTZ group. This work requires further attention regarding the LOD, competing studies, and real time applications. Recently, Zn-based MOF-
ZnAPA with 5-aminoisophthalic acid (H
2APA) organic linkers was demonstrated for Hg
2+ detection by means of fluorescence quenching in water
[85]. Wherein, PL emission of MOF at 405 nm was linearly quenched during exposure to Hg
2+ in a concentration range of 0–100 µM with a LOD of 0.12 µM. This might be due to the binding affinity of Hg
2+ to ‘N′ atom of amino group. This work showed a great selectivity over many other competing mono- and di-valent cationic species; however, it still needs to put more focus on the BET surface area and real applications.
The Cd-based MOFs were also engaged in discrimination of Hg
2+, in parallel to Zn-based MOFs. For example, Wu and co-workers constructed a Cd comprising 3D MOF-{[Cd
1.5(C
18H
10O
10)]·(H
3O)(H
2O)
3}
n-
Cd-EDDA with dual emission and utilized it in ratiometric detection of Hg
2+ in pure water
[86]. By hydrothermally reacting 5,5′-[ethane-1,2-diylbis(oxy)]diisophthalic acid (H
4EDDA) with Cd(ClO
4)
2·6H
2O, the
Cd-EDDA was produced with 80% yield. Upon addition of Hg
2+ to the
Cd-EDDA, intensity of PL emission at 350 nm decreased significantly (K
SV = 4.3 ×10
3 M
−1) accompanied with a new PL peak at 410 nm with a linear response (within 15s) between 4–25 µM and a calculated LOD of 2 nM, which was lower than the permitted level. Be noted that the
Cd-EDDA displayed great selectivity over a wide range of metal ions by means of crystallinity destruction and was not reversible with Na
2S. Thereby the probe behaves like a chemodosimeter. Information regarding the BET surface area and real time applicability requires further investigations. Subsequently, a MOF, namely
[(Me2NH2)Cd3(OH)(H2O)3(TATAB)2](DMA)6], was formed as yellow crystals through solvothermally reacting Cd(NO
3)
2·6H
2O and 4,4′,4″-s-triazin-1,3,5-triyltri-p-aminobenzoic acid (H
3TATAB) in DMA (N,N-dimethylacetamide), methanol, and HCl at 95 °C for 3 days and was consumed towards luminescent Hg
2+ detection in water
[87]. Due to the binding between ‘N′ atoms of amino and triazine groups, PL emission at 365 nm was quenched in the presence of Hg
2+. However, the selectivity was significantly affected by Fe
3+. Moreover, there was no details regarding the BET surface area and applicability. Recently, interaction of Cd(ClO
4)
2.6H
2O with 2-aminoterephthalic acid (NH
2-H
2BDC) by microwave synthetic was used as a tactic to derive the Cd
2+-comprising MOF-
NH2-Cd-BDC, which was applied in sensing of Hg
2+ via PL quenching at 427 nm
[88]. The -NH
2 group of
NH2-Cd-BDC reacted with Hg
2+ and led to linearly quenched emission in a concentration range from 1 to 20 µM and a K
SV value of 28.0 × 10
3 M
−1 and a LOD of 0.58 µM. Though the work seems to be comparatively good with respect to earlier reports, it still lacks information on the BET surface area, real time applicability, and competing studies.
The ferrous (Fe
2+) comprising MOF nanoparticles, namely
Fe(II)-MOF-NPs, were developed via solvothermal reaction of FeSO
4.7H
2O with nano linkers (synthesized via refluxing 1, 2-phenylenediamine and 5-aminoisophthalic acid) and were engaged in colorimetric and PL detection of Hg
2+ [89]. The nanoparticles have a size in the range between 100 to 250 nm and possess magnetic properties as well. During addition of Hg
2+, PL emission at 416 nm displayed a ‘turn-on′ response and was red-shifted to 422 nm. The absorption peak at 427 nm was also enhanced and red-shifted to 456 nm accompanied with changes in colour from yellow to colorless. Both absorption and PL showed a linear response in a concentration range from 1 nM to 1 µM and LODs of 1.17 and 1.14 nM and limit of quantifications (LOQs) of 1.59 and 1.48 nM, respectively. Moreover, the
Fe(II)-MOF-NPs in DMSO were also effective in discrimination of Hg
2+ in competing and real environment (tap, mineral, river, sea, and waste water). Based on above results, the
Fe(II)-MOF-NPs can be an excellent candidate for the discrimination of Hg
2+, but mechanistic investigations and BET adsorption studies must be conducted to move towards Hg
2+ removal studies. Towards sensing of Hg
2+, Li and co-workers presented the hydrostable bromine-functionalized Mn-based MOF-
{[Mn2(Bript)2(4,4′-bpy).5(DMF)]·(H2O)}n, where H
2Bript, 4,4′-bpy, and DMF represent 4-Bromoisophthalic acid, 4,4′-bipyridine, and dimethylformamide, respectively
[90]. The BET surface area of the MOF was established as 210 m
2 g
−1 and was further reduced to 33 m
2 g
−1 upon loading of Hg
2+. Due to the binding affinity between Br atom and Hg
2+, PL emission at 468 nm was linearly quenched (K
Sv = 1390.5 M
−1) from 0 to 0.03 M with an estimated LOD of 48 µM. The MOF showed high selectivity toward Hg
2+ (in water) among variety of competing species. However, studies on the real time applicability and LODs need more focus before proceeding further. To this track, Song et al. reported highly selective sensing of Hg
2+ using Ag coordinated MOF
[91]. Wherein, they developed three Ag
+/Cu
2+ comprising MOFs, namely
[Ag(2,4′-Hpdc)(4,4′-bpy)]n,
[Ag(2,2′-Hpdc)(4,4′-bpy)0.5]n, and
[Cu(2,2′-Hpdc)2(1,4-bib)]n, via hydrothermal method, where 2,4′-Hpdc, 2,2′-Hpdc, 4,4′-bpy, and 1,4-bib represent 2,4′-biphenyldicarboxylic acid, 2,2′-biphenyldicarboxylic acid, 4,4′-bipyridine, and 1,4-bis(1-imidazolyl) benzene, respectively. Among them, only the
[Ag(2,4′-Hpdc)(4,4′-bpy)]n in water showed selectivity to Hg
2+ via ‘turn-on′ response with PL emission at 401 nm. Note that the Fe
3+ showed PL quenching in the selectivity studies as seen in
Figure 4. Due to the binding affinity between 2,4′-Hpdc to Hg
2+, PL emission of the MOF (in water) was enhanced linearly between Hg
2+ concentrations from 0 to 100 µM with a LOD of 9.63 nM. However, it still requires optimization for BET surface area, competing analysis, and real sample applications.
Figure 4. (
a) Suspension-state PL spectra (inset: the images under UV-light irradiation at 365 nm) and (
b) the relative intensities of
[Ag(2,4′-Hpdc)(4,4′-bpy)]n at 401 nm dispersed in aqueous solutions containing different metal ions (50 μM) when excited at 300 nm (reproduced with the permission from Ref
[91]).
Many MOFs were also involved in detection of multiple analytes other than Hg
2+ as detailed in the following. For example, 4,4′-(benzothiadiazole-4,7-diyl)dibenzoic acid ligand comprising MOFs, such as
[Mn4(C20H10N2O4S)2-(HCOO)4(DEF)2] and
[Pb(C20H10N2O4S)(DMF)] (where DEF and DMF represent N,N′-diethylformamide and N,N′-dimethylformamide; solvothermally synthesized), were described for the sensing of Hg
2+and Tl
3+ metal cations and chromate, dichromate, and permanganate anions
[92]. Detection of the metal ions was attributed to the interaction of ‘S′ atom with metal cations. Moreover, PL emission at 500 nm was quenched rapidly with LODs down to parts per billion/parts per million (ppb/ppm) in the presence of these analytes. Be noted that both MOFs can be used to detect Hg
2+ in samples free of Tl
3+. Thus, these MOFs can be accounted as Hg
2+ sensors. However, they are non-selective. Thereafter a ratiometric Hg
2+ sensor was proposed by using MOF-
[Zn(tpbpc)2]·solvent prepared via solvothermal tactic, where Htpbpc (4′-[4,2′;6′,4′′]-terpyridin-4′-yl-biphenyl-4-carboxylic acid and DMF solvent were used as an organic linker with Zn metal nodes
[93]. This Zn-MOF was also demonstrated for detection of CrO
42− and Cr
2O
72− species in water via PL quenching at 414 nm. Above sensory results may arise from interactions between pyridine ‘N” atoms and Hg
2+ or by inhibition of energy transfer processes by CrO
42− and Cr
2O
72− ions. During addition of Hg
2+ ions from 0 to 1200 µM, PL emission peak at 414 nm was quenched linearly with a LOD of 0.32 µM, accompanied with appearance of a new peak at 500 nm (green emission under UV lamp λ
ex = 365 nm). However, during competing studies, the selectivity may be affected in the presence of Cr(VI) ions (CrO
42− and Cr
2O
72). Thus, more interrogations are required due to lack of information on the selectivity, BET surface area and practical applications.
Ma′s research group developed the stable dye-incorporated MOF-
[(CH3)2NH2][In(TNB)4/3].(2DMF)(3H2O) via a solvothermal method, where H
3TNB (4,4′,4′′-nitrilotribenzoicacid) was used as an organic linker and then incorporated with a dye 4-[p-(dimethylamino)styryl]-1-ethylpyridinium (DSM) to provide the
MOF-DSM system
[94]. The
MOF-DSM system displayed sensing ability towards Hg
2+, Cr
2O
72-, and a wide variety of nitro-compounds. The BET surface area of MOF and
MOF-DSM systems were estimated as 491 m
2 g
−1 and 236 m
2 g
−1, respectively. During discrimination of Hg
2+, PL emission peaks of
MOF-DSM (in water) at 478 and 630 nm were linearly quenched between 1–10 µM with an estimated LOD of 1.75 ppb and a K
SV value of 1.48 × 10
5 M
−1. The energy transfer efficiency of the π-π
* transitions diminished due to the binding affinity between Hg
2+ and ‘N′ atoms of DSM. The MOF-DSM was found to be more effective in aqueous detection of Cr
2O
72- and vapour/aqueous detection of nitro-compounds. Subsequently, Li et al. derived the Co-based MOF-
[Co (NPDC)(bpee)]·DMF·2H2O (where NPDC and bpee represent 2-nitro phenylenedicarboxylate and 1,2-bis(4-bipyridyl) ethylene) by means of the solvothermal tactic and established sensing ability towards Hg
2+ and MnO
4- [95]. This MOF in water displayed PL quenching in the presence of MnO
4- and PL enhancement at 471 nm for Hg
2+ ions. The linear response for Hg
2+ ions by this MOF was found to be 1–120 µM with a LOD of 4.1 µM. However, this work still contains mechanistic flaws with non-optimal LODs and lacks information in applicability as well. To this track, Yang and co-workers synthesized two Cd-based MOFs, namely
Cd(L)(atpa)]n and
[Cd(L)(tbta)(H2O)]n (where H
2atpa, H
2tbta, and L represent 2-aminoterephthalic acid, tetrabromoterephthalic acid, and 1,4-bis(benz-imidazol-1-yl)-2-butene, respectively) via a hydrothermal method and utilized them as dual luminescent sensors (Cu
2+ and Cr
2O
72- by
[Cd(L)(atpa)]n, and Hg
2+ and Cr
2O
72- by
[Cd(L)(tbta)(H2O)]n in water
[96]. PL intensity of
[Cd(L)(tbta)(H2O)]n at 294 nm was linearly quenched during addition of Hg
2+ from 0 to 0.25 mM with a LOD of 0.043 µM and a K
SV value of 1.72 × 10
5 M
−1. Moreover, fluorescence of
[Cd(L)(tbta)(H2O)]n in water at 294 nm was also quenched in the presence of Cr
2O
72-. This work did not provide any details on the BET surface area, discriminative information between Hg
2+ and Cr
2O
72- (Cr
6+), and practicality.
Subsequently, 2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylic acid (NP) and 1,5 dihydroxy-2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylic (DNP) were conjugated with lanthanide cations (La
3+ and Ce
3+) to produce luminescent MOFs, namely
AUBM-2 (Ce) and
AUBM-2(La) with NP ligand and
AUBM-3(Ce) and
AUBM-3(La) with DNP ligand. They were engaged in sensory studies
[97]. Wherein, upon excitation at 300 and 370 nm, the
AUBM-2 (Ce) and
AUBM-3(Ce) displayed sensory responses to Hg
2+, Cr
3+, Pb
2+, Cd
2+, and As
3+ by means of fluorescent enhancement or quenching responses. This study requires further optimization for Hg
2+ analyte detection. Next, Ren et al. proposed utilization of MOF nanosheet
amino-MIL-53(Al) (hydrothermally synthesized by reacting AlCl
3.6H
2O with 2-amino-terephthalic acid) towards luminescent detection of Hg
2+ and glutathione (GSH)
[98]. Emission of
amino-MIL-53(Al) nanosheets at 435 nm (in water) was linearly quenched by Hg
2+ with concentrations between 1.96 nM to 38.27 µM and a detection limit of 0.23 nM. Furthermore, luminescent quenching was partially restored by addition of GSH (linear range: 210 nM to 15.25 µM and LOD = 8.11 nM). However, this work still lacks of information about the BET surface area. Solvothermally synthesized Cd-based MOFs
[(Cd(II)BPDC)0.5(L1)(NO3)]·3.4DMF (where BPDC, L1, and DMF represent 4,4′-biphenyldicarboxylic acid, 1-(3,5-di(1H-imidazol-1-yl)phenyl)-1H-imidazole), and Dimethylformamide, respectively) and
[(Cd2(4-tp-3-lad)(1,4- BDC)2}·2MeCN)n (where 4-tp-3-lad, 4-BDC, and MeCN represent 2,3,5,6-tetra(pyridin-4-yl)-bicyclo [2.2.0]hexane, 1, deprotonated 1,4-benzenedicarboxylic acid, and acetonitrile, respectively) were also proposed towards the detection of Hg
2+ and nitro-explosives via fluorescence quenching
[99,100][99][100]. However, due to insufficient information regarding the BET surface area, competing studies, and practicality, these reports are not impressive. Later, Su et al. reported sensing ability of Co-based MOF-
{[Co2(L)(hfpd)(H2O)]·1.75H2O}n (where H
4hfpd and L represent 4,4′-(hexa-fluoroisopropylidene)diphthalic acid and 4,4′-bis(imidazol-1-yl)-biphenyl) to Hg
2+ and acetylacetone via luminescent quenching responses
[101]. This hydrothermally synthesized MOF showed luminescence quenching in the presence of 0–200 µM Hg
2+ with a K
SV of 6497 M
−1 and a LOD of 4 µM. However, this work requires further interrogations on the BET surface area, nano/micro-structure, competing studies, and practicality.
5. Metal Coordinated Polymers as Luminescent Hg2+ Sensors
In addition to MOFs, metal containing coordination polymers were proposed towards luminescent sensing of Hg
2+ [100]. For instance, Sun′s research group developed Zn- and Cd-based coordination polymers-
[Zn(TPDC-2CH3)(H2O)2].H2O and
[Cd(TPDC-2CH3)(H2O)4].H2O via solvothermally reacting 2′,5′-dimethyl-[1,1′:4′,1′′-terphenyl]-4,4′′-dicarboxylic acid (H
2TPDC-2CH
3) with Zn
2+ and Cd
2+ ions, separately, and engaged them in sensory interrogations towards metal ions
[102]. Emission of the
[Zn(TPDC-2CH3)(H2O)2].H2O metal polymer at 380 nm (in water) was linearly quenched between 1–10 femtomole (fM) with a LOD of 3.6 fM. The solid chelation-enhanced fluorescence quenching (CHEQ) effect can be attributed to coordination between carboxyl group and Hg
2+. However, this report did not provide any information regarding the BET surface area and practicality. Next, the
Eu/IPA CPNPs (by solvothermal tactic) were prepared by reacting Eu
3+ comprising coordination polymer nanoparticles (CPNPs) with isophthalic acid (IPA) bridging ligands and were employed in Hg
2+ detection
[103]. Initially, absorbance band of
Eu/IPA CPNPs in Tris–HCl buffer (25 mM, pH 7.0) was overlapped with imidazole-4,5-dicarboxylic acid (Im), thus emission intensity at 615 nm was quenched due to the inner filter effect (IFE). During addition of Hg
2+, the IFE was supressed and recovery of emission at 615 nm was observed. The linear correlation of Hg
2+ ranged between 2 nM to 2µM with a LOD of 2 nM. Effectiveness of the probe was further demonstrated with applicability in biological fluid samples. Nevertheless, information regarding BET surface area must be evaluated for its exceptional applicability.
Towards the development of metal coordination polymers for Hg
2+ sensors, Li et al. described the solvothermally synthesized Zn-based 3D coordination polymer-
{[Zn2(1,4-bpyvna)(1,3,5-BTC)(OH)]·H2O}n (where 1,4-bpyvna and 1,3,5-H
3BTC represent 1,4-bis(2-(pyridin-4-yl)vinyl)naphthalene and 1,3,5-benzene-tricarboxylic acid, respectively) as a Hg
2+ sensor
[104]. Due to the interactive effect of 1,4-bpyvna with Hg
2+, the
{[Zn2(1,4-bpyvna)(1,3,5-BTC)(OH)]·H2O}n in DMF displayed fluorescence quenching at 444 and 472 nm as seen in
Figure 5.
Figure 5. (
a) Emission spectra of
{[Zn2(1,4-bpyvna)(1,3,5-BTC)(OH)]·H2O}n in DMF in the absence/presence of Mn+ ions. (
b) The colours of the suspensions of
{[Zn2(1,4-bpyvna)(1,3,5-BTC)(OH)]·H2O}n with different metal ions under UV light. (
c) Emission spectra of
{[Zn2(1,4-bpyvna)(1,3,5-BTC)(OH)]·H2O}n in the presence of increasing Hg
2+ concentrations (0–0.08 ppm) in DMF. Inset: linear relation between the quenching efficiency and the concentration of Hg
2+ in the range of 0–0.018 ppm. (
d) Fluorescence intensities of
{[Zn2(1,4-bpyvna)(1,3,5-BTC)(OH)]·H2O}n immersed in the DMF solution of metal ion (blue colour) or mixed Hg2+ and metal ions (red colour) under an excitation of 389 nm (Reproduced with the permission from Ref
[104]).
A linear response of the polymer was found from 0 to 0.018 ppm with a LOD of 0.057 ppm. A fluorescent colour change from blue to yellow was also observed. However, further interrogations for the BET surface area and real time applications are still required. Subsequently, Zhang and co-workers presented Hg
2+ sensing ability of hydrothermally synthesized fluorescent coordination polymer, namely
[Zn(H3TTA)(H2O)2]·2H2O (where H
3TTA represents [2,2′:6′,2″-terpyridine]-4,4′,4″-tricarboxylic acid)), in aqueous solution
[105]. Emission band at 500 nm was quenched in the presence of Hg
2+ with a K
SV value of 4695 M
−1. This work is incomplete due to lack of information in the BET surface area, LODs, and practicality. Utilization of Zn- and Cd-based luminescent coordination polymers towards the quantitation of Hg
2+ and Cr
2O
72- has been reported by many research groups
[106,107,108][106][107][108]. Since Cr
2O
72- is a well-known source of Cr
6+ ions, discrimination between them are not available in those reports. Therefore, those works cannot be considered as exceptional Hg
2+ sensor studies. Similarly, Lin et al. demonstrated Pb
2+ and Hg
2+ sensing ability of Eu
3+ containing coordination polymer, namely {
[Ln2(PBA)3(H2O)3]·DMF·3H2O}n, in DMF and aqueous media, where PBA, DMF, and H
2O represent deprotonated 5-(4-pyridin-3-yl-benzoylamino)-isophthalic acid, Dimethylformamide, and water molecules, respectively
[109]. Wherein, the polymer can be used to detect Hg
2+ in samples free of Pb
2+. Thus, these MOFs can be accounted as Hg
2+ sensors. However, they are non-selective.
In addition to metal coordination polymer-based Hg
2+ sensor, Rachuri and co-workers reported a luminescent coordination polymer, namely
[Zn(μ2-1H-ade)(μ2-SO4)] (by solvothermal reaction of adinine (HAde) and Zn(SO
4)·7H
2O), as discussed in the following
[110]. In the report, fluorescence intensity of the
[Zn(μ2-1H-ade)(μ2-SO4)] at 395 nm (in water) was linearly quenched between 0–1 mM of Hg
2+ with a LOD of 70 nM and a K
SV value of 7.7 × 10
3 M
−1. Moreover, this polymer also has an additional advantage that it showed selective sensing of the 2,4,6-trinitrophenol (TNP) in aqueous medium. The underlying mechanism of detection of Hg
2+ was attributed to the interaction with basic sites (N atoms) of the adenine and TNP through the resonance energy transfer (RET). It should be noted that this work also described the Hg
2+ detection in paper strips, therefore, it can be extended for effective Hg
2+ removal in real samples with directed BET surface area analysis. Thereafter, Zhu et al. demonstrated Hg
2+ sensing utility of two luminescent coordination polymers, namely
[Cd(L)(NTA)]n and
[Ni(L)(NPTA)⋅H2O]n (obtained by solvothermal method, where L, H
2NTA, and H
2NPTA represent 1,6-bis(benzimidazol-1-yl)hexane, 2-nitroterephthalic acid, and 3-nitrophthalic acid, respectively)
[111]. Emission peaks at 292 nm and 295 nm of the polymers
[Cd(L)(NTA)]n and
[Ni(L)(NPTA)⋅H2O]n (in water), respectively, were linearly quenched by Hg
2+ in a concentration range between 1–200 µM with corresponding LODs of 3.05 μM and 2.29 μM and K
Sv values of 3565 M
–1 for 1 and 7432 M
–1. In addition, both polymers displayed selectivity only to acetylacetone among all solvents. However, this work requires information on the BET surface area, competing studies, mechanistic investigations, and practicality.
6. MOFs Holding Composites for Optical Recognition of Hg2+
To enhance sensing ability of MOFs to Hg
2+, researchers also proposed to synthesize MOFs comprising composites as detailed in the following. A metal−polydopamine framework (
MPDA—a dopamine loaded Co-based MOF developed by sonochemical reaction of Co(NO
3)
2 and 2-methylimidazole to afford
ZIF-67 primarily) was reported as a fluorescent quencher towards the detection of Hg
2+ and Ag
+ via exonuclease III signal amplification activity with pico-molar level LODs (1.3 pM and 34 pM, respectively)
[112]. Upon addition of Hg
2+ to
MPDA-T-rich ssDNA (T-rich ssDNA represents thymine rich single stranded Deoxyribonucleic acid) system, ‘turn-on′ PL emission enhancement at 520 nm was observed with a linear response from 0 to 2 nM and a LOD of 1.3 pM. The quenched luminescence of
MPDA conjugated with T-rich ssDNA was recovered through T-Hg
2+-T complexation during addition of Hg
2+. This work was also well demonstrated in tap and river water applications. To this way, Huang and co-workers reported Cu-based MOFs as a hybrid sensory system with C-rich or T-rich DNA probes to detect the Ag
+, Hg
2+, and thiol comprising species at nanomolar-level via T-Hg
2+-T complexation
[113,114][113][114]. Wherein, Huang et al. developed a MOF, namely
[Cu4(Dcbb)4(Dps)2(H2O)2]n (by reacting H
2DcbbBr = 1-(3,5-dicarboxybenzyl)-4,4′-bipyridinium bromide and Dps (4,4′-dipyridyl sulfide) with Cu(NO
3)
2·3H
2O), to detect Ag
+, Hg
2+, and biothiols with nM LODs
[113]. Similarly, the MOF, namely
[Cu(Cdcbp)(H2O)2·2H2O]n (synthesized by reacting H
3CdcbpBr (3-carboxyl-(3,5-dicarboxybenzyl)-pyridinium bromide) with CuSO
4·5H
2O) was engaged in detection of Hg
2+ and biothiols with nM LODs
[114]. In both cases, the MOF tended to form a hybrid system initially with fluorescent dye loaded thymine rich (T-rich) DNA (labelled as P-DNA) which led to fluorescent quenching. It was then recovered upon addition of metal ions, Hg
2+ in particular, via T-Hg
2+-T complexation. The above hybrid MOFs-DNA system-based detection of Hg
2+ and biothiols and the corresponding mechanism are illustrated in
Figure 6. Following the same strategy, Zr- and Ce-based MOFs (
UIO-66-
NH2 and
Ce/TBC) were also demonstrated to discriminate Hg
2+ with nanomolar LODs
[115,116][115][116]. Wherein the
Ce/TBC (also noted as mixed-valence state cerium-based metal-organic framework (
MVC-MOF) combined with thymine-rich ssDNA was engaged in colorimetric peroxidase like sensors to detect Hg
2+ using oxidase substrate 3,3′,5,5′-tetramethylbenzidine
[116]. Results of Hg
2+ detection showed a linear response in a concentration range of 0.05 to 6 μM with a LOD of 10.5 nM and were further supported by environmental water analysis. In fact, many MOF-DNA hybrid systems were reported for detection of metal ions, aminoacids, and nucleic acids
[117,118][117][118], which make the strategy as precise one.
Figure 6. The proposed Hg
2+ and biothiols detection mechanism based on the P-DNA@1 hybrid (Reproduced with the permission from Ref
[114]).
Recently, gold nanoclusters composited MOFs, namely
AuNCs/MIL-68(In)-NH2/Cys and
AuNCs@UIO-66, were demonstrated in discrimination of Hg
2+ [119,120][119][120]. To develop the
AuNCs/MIL-68(In)-NH2/Cys,
MIL-68(In)-NH2 was first solvothermally synthesized by reacting In(NO
3)
3·xH
2O with 2-Aminoterephthalic acid (H
2ATA) followed by evenly dispersing the AuNCs on its surface. The AuNCs exhibited emission bands at 438 nm and 668 nm (λ
ex = 370 nm). By adding cysteine into above mixture, the
AuNCs/MIL-68(In)-NH2/Cys was produced with enhanced emission
[119]. Upon addition of Hg
2+ to the
AuNCs/MIL-68(In)-NH2/Cys at pH 7.4 (phosphate buffer), emission at 638 nm was quenched without affecting the peak at 438 nm. Due to the binding affinity of Hg
2+ with thiol (-SH) of cysteine, PL quenching exhibited two linear responses (with a concentration range from 20 pM to 0.2 μM and from 0.2 μM to 60 μM) with a LOD of 6.7 pM, which was further supported by real water analysis and microfluidic paper device. Subsequently, the
UIO-66 was obtained by solvothermally reacting zirconium chloride with 1,4-benzenedicarboxylic acid (H
2BDC). The synthesized
UIO-66 was then conjugated with AuNCs to afford
AuNCs@UIO-66 with 11% quantum yield
[120]. PL emission of the
AuNCs@UIO-66 at pH 7.2 was observed at 650 nm and was quenched linearly by Hg
2+ with concentrations from 800 nM to 10 μM and a LOD of 77 pM. The emission quenching was attributed to the Au-Hg amalgamation via interactive amino groups of bovine serum albumin (BSA) present over AuNCs surface. The applicability of the sensory study was also successfully demonstrated in tap and river water which can be accounted as a good candidate for Hg
2+ discrimination.
To this track, Marieeswaran and co-workers presented Hg
2+ sensing ability of the MOF containing composite consisted of magnetic nanoscale metal–organic framework (
MNMOF) conjugated with fluorescein amidite (FAM)-labeled ssDNA
[121]. The
MNMOF was developed by one-pot reaction between Fe
3O
4 nano-spheres (synthesized hydrothermally), FeCl
3.6H
2O, and 2-aminoterephthalic acid. Emission intensity at 495 nm (in Tris-HCl buffer) was quenched up to 62% with adsorption of FAM-labeled ssDNA on the
MNMOF. Addition of Hg
2+ further lowered the emission quenching at 495 nm down to 52% via T-Hg
2+-T complexation. The linear regression of Hg
2+ detection was between 2–20 nM with a LOD of 8 nM. This work was also demonstrated in environmental water samples. However, the BET surface area information and competing studies still need to be updated. In addition to the
MOF-DNA hybrid system, Hu and co-workers revealed the utilization of the
{[Cu(Dcbb)(Bpe)]·Cl}n (where H
2DcbbBr and Bpe represent 1-(3,5-dicarboxybenzyl)-4,4′-bipyridinium bromide and trans-1,2-bis(4-pyridyl)ethylene, respectively) towards sequential quantitation of Hg
2+ and I
- via the T−Hg
2+−T motif and “off-on-off” fluorescence response
[122]. Detection of Hg
2+ and I
- was verified by circular dichroism (CD) and the underlying mechanism was clarified by fluorescence anisotropy, binding constant, and simulation studies. LODs for Hg
2+ and I
- sensors were estimated as 3.2 and 3.3 nM, respectively. Though the sensor showed high selectivity, it can be considered a supplementary work due to the similar T−Hg
2+−T motif approach.
The
AuNP@MOF composite nanoparticles were used in colorimetric Hg
2+ assay via gold amalgam-triggered reductase mimetic activity in aqueous medium
[123]. The
AuNP@MOF composite was developed by immobilizing Au NPs over the porous surface of iron-5,10,15,20-tetrakis (4-carboxyl)-21H,23H-porphyrin-based MOF- (
Fe-TCPP-MOF) and was utilized in colorimetric sensing of Hg
2+. Wherein, Hg
2+ triggered the Au-mediated catalytic reduction of methylene blue and turned the blue colour to colourless, which was accompanied with quenching in absorbance peak of methylene blue at 665 nm as shown in
Figure 7. Moreover, the absorbance at 665 nm was linearly quenched within 2s by Hg
2+ with concentrations from 200–400 pM and a LOD of 103 pM. Apart from lack of the BET surface area information, the competing studies, tap and river water investigations attested the utility of the
AuNP@MOF in Hg
2+ detection.
Figure 7. Selectivity of the sensing method by
AuNP@MOF to other metal ions. Concentrations of Hg
2+ and other metal ions (Na
+, K
+, Ag
+, Ca
2+, Mg
2+, Cu
2+, Al
3+, Fe
3+, Fe
2+, Cd
2+, Mn
2+, Cr
3+, Ba
2+, Zn
2+, Pb
2+ and Ni
2+) were 1 nM and 10 nM, respectively. (
A) The UV spectra of the sensing system in response to various metal ions; (
B) The UV absorbance of the sensing system at 665 nm towards various metal ions; (
C) photographs of the sensing system responding to various metal ions (Reproduced with the permission from Ref
[123]).
In this light, Zhang et al. deposited Au nanoparticles on titanium-based MOF
(NH2-MIL-125(Ti)) by solvothermal reaction between 2-aminoterephthalate and tetrabutyl titanate) to afford
Au@NH2-MIL-125(Ti) for colorimetric detection of H
2O
2, cysteine, and Hg
2+ via peroxidase-like activity using 3,3′,5,5′-tetramethylbenzidine (TMB-catalyst)
[124]. The
Au@NH2-MIL-125(Ti) and TMB showed a blue colour and a “turn-on” absorbance response at 652 nm in the presence of H
2O
2 via peroxidase like mimic. Upon addition of cysteine to above sensory system, absorbance at 652 nm was quenched accompanied with disappearance of the blue colour. However, the blue colour and absorbance peak were recovered by adding Hg
2+. The Hg
2+ detection showed a linear response in concentrations from 1 to 5 µM with a LOD of 100 nM and was authenticated by real sample analysis. A masking tactic with EDTA was proposed in this report to avoid the interference effect from other metal ions, however, this work required more complicated detection procedures.
A “
CDs/AuNCs@ZIF-8” composite consisted of zeolitic imidazolate framework-8 (
ZIF-8) encapsulated with carbon dots (CDs) and gold nanoclusters was produced and utilized in detection of Hg
2+ [125]. The
CDs/AuNCs@ZIF-8 in aqueous medium displayed emission bands at 440 and 640 nm (λ
ex = 360 nm) due to the encapsulated CDs and AuNCs. In the presence of Hg
2+, PL peak at 640 nm was quenched but emission band at 440 nm was not affected. Therefore, it was noted as a ratiometric sensor. Due to the Au-Hg amalgamation, the probe showed linear ratiometric response (I
640/I
440) between 3–30 nM with a LOD of 1 nM accompanied with visualization of red blue emission colour changes under UV-irradiation. This work was also demonstrated in tap and river water samples. Following the ratiometric sensing approach, Yang et al. constructed a ratiometric sensor
MOF/CdTe QDs via physically mixing
CdTe QDs (λ
em = 605 nm) with MOF (
Fe-MIL-88NH2, λ
em = 425 nm) towards Hg
2+ and Cu
2+ discrimination
[126]. During detection of metal analytes, ratiometric responses at I
425/I
605 due to the strong binding interaction between CdTe QDs and metal ions were evaluated by monitoring the colour changes (from pink to blue). Although this work was well supported by paper-based analysis, lake water, fruit juice, and red wine samples, but it lacks information in competing studies.
7. MOFs in Electrochemical Recognition of Hg2+
Similar to many inorganic electrochemical sensors
[127], MOFs were also engaged in electrochemical-based detection of Hg
2+ as described subsequently. For example, Zhang et al. demonstrated electrochemical sensing of Hg
2+ in the presence of glucose by using the Cu
2+ anchored MOFs as enzyme free catalyst
[128]. MOFs were firstly synthesized By solvothermally reacting amino terephthalic acid (NH
2-BDC) with Cu(NO
3)
2. The as-synthesized MOFs were then combined with Au NPs and sDNA to obtain the
sDNA/MOF-Au probe. The
cDNA/GO@Au/GCE electrode was immersed in the mixed solution of
sDNA/MOF-Au and Hg
2+ at certain concentration for Hg
2+ sensing. The
sDNA/MOF-Au probe detected Hg
2+ via T-Hg
2+-T coordination and induced a oxidase-like catalytic response. This work showed a linear response to Hg
2+ in concentrations from 0.10 aM to 100 nM (aM = attomole = 10
−18 M) with a LOD of 0.001 aM. Moreover, this work was also demonstrated in dairy product samples, which was impressive. However, careful optimization is required to attain the reproducible results. Recently, the
ZIF-8 was synthesized via hydrothermal reaction of Zn(NO
3)
2⋅4H
2O and 2-methylimidazole and employed in electrochemical discrimination of Hg
2+ by coupling with Ag and Au nanoparticles
[129]. This work also involved the electrochemical aptasensor based on the Au electrode (AE). Signals were obtained from the “
APT/Ag@Au/ZIF-8/AE” aptasensor by means of differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) and electro-chemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). Due to the T-Hg-T complexation from T rich aptamer, Hg
2+ detection became feasible. Linear responses were observed from detection of Hg
2+ in concentrations from 1.0 × 10
−16 to 1.0 × 10
−12 M and from 5.0 × 10
−15 to 1.0 × 10
−12 M with LODs of 1.8 ± 0.04 × 10
−17 M and 1.3 ± 0.01 ×10
−16 M by DPV and EIS, respectively. This work was well supported by real water samples, thereby can be considered a report in T-Hg
2+-T motif featured electrochemical sensors.
Similar results were reported from many MOFs-based electrochemical sensors with fM LODs
[130,131,132][130][131][132]. Wherein, the Cu-based MOFs (
Cu-MOFs), thioether side groups attached Zr-based MOFs (
S-Zr-MOFs), and 2D-Co-based MOFs (
PPF-3 nanosheets) were engaged in the fabrication of
Cu-MOFs/Au,
S-Zr-MOF/SPE (SPE represents screen printed electrode), and anchor−Au NPs@
PPF-3 attached DNB/depAu/GCE (Au NPs, anchor, anchor, DNB, and depAu/GCE represent gold nanoparticles, dibenzocyclooctyne (DBCO), 3D DNA “nanosafe-box”, and gold nanoparticle-coated glassy carbon electrode, represtively) electrodes towards the specific detection of Hg
2+ ions. The GCE/AuNPs/DNA
2 sensor was incubated in a mixture of
Cu-MOFs/DNA
1 probes (T-rich DNA used in study) and Hg
2+. It demonstrated a linear DPV response from 10 fM to 100 nM with a LOD of 4.8 fM and also real time applications
[130]. Similarly, the
S-Zr-MOF/SPE showed a linear differential pulse anodic stripping voltammetry (DPASV) response for Hg
2+ between 0.03 nM to 3 µM with a LOD of 7.3 fM via multiple Hg-S interaction (by thio-ether side chains) and T-Hg
2+-T formation
[131]. By dropping the anchor−AuNPs@
PPF-3 [the
PPF-3 was synthesized by solvothermally reacting Co(NO
3)
2·6H
2O, 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(4-carboxyl-phenyl)-porphyrin (TCPP), and 4′-bipyridine (BPY)] over the surface of DNB/depAu/GCE, the proposed electrode fabrication was completed. The electrode was subjected to Hg
2+ detection to reveal a linear DPV response between 0.1 pM to 10 nM with a LOD of 33 fM
[132]. Next, the
Cu-MOF-mediated Hg
2+ detection by means of differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) and cyclic voltammetry (CV) tactics in 0.1 M phosphate buffer (PB) at pH 9 was reported by Singh and co-workers
[133]. In the report, CuNO
3·3H
2O and 2-aminoterephthalic acid were solvothermally reacted to afford porous
Cu-MOF nanoparticles, which could absorb large amount of Hg
2+. Through coupling with the GCE, the Cu-MOF detected Hg
2+ linearly in concentrations from 0.1 to 50 nM with a LOD of 0.0633 nM. Reliability of this work was well demonstrated by the real tuna-fish and tap water samples investigations.
Thereafter Kokkinos and co-workers proposed utilization of the
Ca-MOF modified working electrodes towards 3D-printed lab-in-a-syringe voltammetric cell mediated electrochemical detection of Hg
2+ [134]. The
Ca-MOF, namely
[Ca(H4L)(DMA)2]·2DMA, where H
6L and DMA represent N,N′-bis(2,4-dicarboxyphenyl)-oxalamide and N,N-dimethylacetamide), showed exceptional selectivity to Hg
2+. Moreover, the voltammetric lab-in-a-syringe device consisted of a vessel assimilating two thermoplastic conductive electrodes (act as counter and pseudo-reference electrodes) was fabricated by a single-step process. A small detachable 3D-printed syringe loaded with a graphite paste/
Ca-MOF mixture was used as a working electrode. The Ca-MOF participated in the ion exchange to form “
Hg@CaMOF”. The device showed a linear response to Hg
2+ with concentrations between 2–40 μg L
−1 and a LOD of 0.6 μg L
−1. Practicality of this work was also demonstrated in the fish oil and bottle water samples.
In contrast to direct electrochemical sensors, Zhang et al. proposed the MOF-involved light driven electrochemical (photoelectrochemical; PEC) sensor for Hg
2+ discrimination as described next
[135]. Firstly, Co(NO
3)
2·6H
2O and 2-methylimidazole were solvothermally reacted to afford the ZIF-67. The
ZIF-67 was then reacted with Cd(NO
3)
2·4H
2O and thioacetamide (TAA) to yield the
CoSx@CdS nanocomposites (CdS nanoparticles were grown over the surface of cobalt sulfide (CoSx) by using ZIF-67 polyhedrons as the sacrificial templates and cobalt precursors). The synthesized composite was drop casted on the ITO electrodes to engage in the photoelectrochemical sensing of Hg
2+ as illustrated in
Figure 8.
Figure 8. Synthetic process of hollow
CoSx polyhedrons and
CoSx@CdS composites and the mechanism of photocurrent responses of
CoSx@CdS composites, showing the band structures of
CoSx@CdS/HgS composites and charge separation under the visible-light illumination (Reproduced with the permission from Ref
[135]).
In the presence of Hg2+ ions in PBS (pH 7.4) containing 0.15 M triethanolamine (TEA) (see Figure 8), carrier transport and photocurrent of the device were improved and enhanced under illumination due to the combined CoSx and CdS components. In fact, the ion-exchange reaction took place to trigger in-situ generation of CoSx@CdS/HgS (new Z-scheme heterojunction photocatalyst) during the detection process. This sensor showed a linear response to Hg2+ with concentrations between 0.010–1000 nM and a LOD of 2 pM. It was also validated by tap and lake water analysis.
8. MOFs in Removal of Hg2+
Other than optical and electrochemical recognition of metal analytes, MOFs were also engaged in the selective removal heavy metal ions
[136]. In this section, removal/extraction of Hg
2+ in particular was described in detail. Many Zr-based MOFs displayed great adsorption capacity to Hg
2+ due to their porous nature. For example, Kahkha and co-workers described the consumption of mesoporous porphyrinic containing Zr-MOF-
PCN-222/MOF-545 for effective pipette-tip solid-phase extraction of Hg
2+ [137]. The MOF was solvothermally synthesized by reacting meso-tetrakis(4-carboxyphenyl)porphyrin (H
2TCPP) and ZrOCl
2·8H
2O. The as-synthesized MOF was then inserted into a Bio Plas pipette-tip attached to a 2000-μL micro pipette for Hg
2+ adsorption. It was shown that 2 mg of MOF- sorbent was enough to accomplish extraction and desorption of Hg
2+ up to 15 cycles at pH 5 by using 10% HCl as eluting solvent (fixed at 15 µL volume). A LOD of this method was estimated as 20 ng L
−1 with an adsorption capacity (contrast to other ions), enrichment factor, and total extraction time of 35.5 mg g
−1, 120-fold, and 7 min, respectively. This work was demonstrated for Hg
2+ determination in the fish samples, however, information regarding the BET surface area and Langmuir/Freundlich isotherms requires further interrogations. Hasankola et al. engaged the MOF-
PCN-221 (synthesized by solvothermal reaction), which comprised of 5,10,15,20-tetrakis(4-carboxyphenyl) porphyrin (H
2TCPP) organic linker and ‘Zr′ metal node, towards selective removal of Hg
2+ [138]. Wherein the time required for Hg
2+ adsorption was 30 min at an optimal pH of 7.1 and an adsorption capacity of
PCN-221 was established as 233 mg g
−1. Be noted that the adsorption process of Hg
2+ by
PCN-221 can be properly interpreted with the pseudo-second-order kinetic model (with R
2 = 0.99) and followed the Langmuir model adsorption isotherms for Hg
2+. Investigations on the Hg
2+ adsorption mechanism indicated that Hg
2+ could not be replace with Zr ions. For the desorption process, 0.01 M HNO
3 was used. This work requires more investigations for the BET surface area, practicality, and structural features.
Li et al. described the utilization of porous and highly defective Zr-based MOF-UIO-66-Zr
6(OH)
4O
4(BDC)
6 (where BDC represents benzene-1,4-dicarboxylate), namely
UIO-66-50Benz (Benz represents benzene-1,4-dicarboxylate), for Hg
2+ removal
[139]. By means of topotactic transformations of MOFs and ligand extraction process,
ZrOx (obtained by immersion of
UIO-66-50Benz in 10 mol L
−1 NaOH),
ZrOxyPhos (obtained by immersion of
UIO-66-50Benz in 210 mM Na
3PO
4), and
ZrSulf (obtained by immersion of
UIO-66-50Benz in 250 mg of Na
2S solution in 10 mL) were developed and engaged in Hg
2+ removal as seen in
Figure 9.
Figure 9. Schematic of the utilization of highly defective Zr-based porous MOFs-
ZrOx,
ZrOxyPhos, and
ZrSulf towards Hg
2+ removal and excellent Hg
2+ removal performance by
ZrSulf compared to other metal ions and at different pH ranges; coordinated solvents NaOH, Na
3PO
4, and Na
2S were used to afford
ZrOx,
ZrOxyPhos, and
ZrSulf, respectively. (Reproduced with the permission from Ref
[139]).
The BET surface area of ZrOx, ZrOxyPhos, and ZrSulf were estimated as 430, 290, and 560 m2 g−1, correspondingly, which also confirmed the high effectiveness of ZrSulf. Among these materials, ZrSulf possessed the fastest adsorption kinetics (1.1 × 10−2 g (mg min)−1 and the highest adsorption capacity of 824 mg g−1. The distribution coefficient (Kd) of ZrSulf to Hg2+ was estimated as 4.98 × 105 mL g−1 at pH 6.8 Moreover, it was reusable for more than five cycles after washing with HCl and thio-urea. The high selectivity of Hg2+ was attributed to the covalent bond formation with sulfur-based functionality. From kinetic studies, it was established that the adsorption followed the pseudo-second order model and, at the same time, controlled by the film diffusion and pore diffusion. This material can be considered as a good candidate for Hg2+ removal in terms of its adsorption capacity and practicality.
Subsequently, Leus and co-workers solvothermally synthesized the thiolated Zr-based MOF-
UIO-66-(SH)2 (by reacting ZrOCl
2.8H
2O and 2,5-dimercaptoterephthalic acid-(H
2BDC-2,5SH)) and applied it for selective removal of Hg species
[140]. The Langmuir surface area of
UIO-66-(SH)2 was estimated as 499 m
2 g
−1. The
UIO-66-(SH)2 showed a maximum Hg
2+ adsorption capacity of 236.4 mg g
−1 between pH 3.0–5.0. Due to the presence of -SH group, adsorption of Hg
2+ showed the best fit with Langmuir isotherm and followed the pseudo-second order kinetics. Moreover, adsorption and desorption of Hg
2+ can be extended up to three cycles by using 1 M HCl and 0.66 M thiourea. This work was also applied in waste water-based Hg
2+ removal. The use of thiolated
UIO-66-SH (an archetypal thiolated Zr-based MOF- Zr
6(OH)
4O
4(BDC)
6, where BDC represents benzene-1,4-dicarboxylate) towards Hg species removal applications was also demonstrated by Li and co-workers
[141]. However, the presence of Zn
2+ and Pb
2+ may reduce the adsorption of Hg
2+ by
UIO-66-SH.
Next, Fu et al. employed the post-functionalized
UIO-66-NH2 (Zr-based MOF) with 2,5-Dimercapto-1,3,4-thiadiazole to produce the
UIO-66-DMTD for effective removal of Hg
2+ in water
[142]. Due to the Hg
2+ adsorption over the MOF surface, the calculated BET surface area of
UIO-66-DMTD-Hg decreased from 651 m
2 g
−1 to 42 m
2 g
−1, thereby confirming the adsorbing ability of the proposed MOFs. The maximum adsorption of Hg
2+ was 670.5 mg g
−1 at pH 3. The adsorption kinetic followed the pseudo-second-order and was linearly fitted with Langmuir isotherm. Moreover, selectivity to Hg
2+ by the
UIO-66-DMTD and its analogous (
UIO-66-NH2 and
UIO-66-SO3H) was higher than that of other species as seen in
Figure 10.
Figure 10. Selective removal of Hg
2+ by
UIO-66-NH2,
UIO-66-SO3H and
UIO-66-DMTD (Reproduced with the permission from Ref
[142]).
At a fixed Hg2+ removal time of 120 min, recyclable usage of the UIO-66-DMTD was found to be effective up to 10 times. The Hg2+ removal is highly fascinated and can be effective in the lab wastewater-based extraction due to the high affinity of thiol (-SH) group to Hg2+.
Similar to the MOF-
UIO-66-(SH)2 [140], Ding and co-workers proposed the Zr-based MOF-
Zr-DMBD (synthesized by reacting 2,5-Dimercapto-1,4-benzenedicarboxylic acid (H
2DMBD) and ZrCl
4) for Hg
2+ removal
[143]. However, due to a high degree of similarity to the
UIO-66-(SH)2-based research, this work will not be further discussed. Regarding the effectiveness of thiol functionalized or thiol comprising MOFs towards removal of Hg
2+ species, Li et al. described the utilization of dense thiol arrays containing Zr-based MOF, namely
ZrOMTP (via reacting 4,4′,4″,4‴-(pyrene-1,3,6,8-tetrayl)tetrakis(2,6-dimercaptobenzoic acid)(H
4OMTP) with ZrCl
4), in Ref.
[144]. The BET surface area of
ZrOMTP to N
2 gas was estimated as 1290 m
2 g
−1 and the distribution coefficient (
Kd) for Hg
2+ was calculated as 1.60 × 10
8 mL g
−1, which is far better than that of other thiol containing MOFs. This could be attributed to the dense thiol arrays present in
ZrOMTP framework. Adsorption of Hg
2+ followed the first order kinetic model and was best fitted with Langmuir isotherms. Moreover, this MOFs lowered Hg-based contaminants from ppm to below the allowed drinkable limit of 2 ppb.
Highly dense alkyl thiol comprising MOF-
Zr-MSA was developed by hydrothermally reacting ZrCl
4 and mercaptosuccinic acid (HOOC-CHSH-CH
2-COOH,
MSA) in aqueous phase and was engaged in Hg
2+ removal
[145]. The
Zr-MSA showed an adsorption efficiency of 99.99% to Hg
2+ in a pH range of 0–7 pH within 5 min and was reusable (with 6 M HCl) for up to five cycles. Moreover, the
Zr-MSA showed a maximum adsorption capacity of 734 mg g
−1 and a
Kd value of 1.82 × 10
8 mL g
−1, which was best correlated with Langmuir isotherm. Due to the higher affinity of -SH to Hg
2+, this work reduced the Hg content from 10,000 ppb to 0.11 ppb, which was far below the drinking water limit. In addition to thiol containing MOFs, the
Zr-MOFs (
Zr-MOFs-SH(O)) was synthesized by one-pot reaction of ZrCl
4, meso-tetra(4-carboxyphenyl)porphine (H
2TCPP), and modulators—mercaptoacetic acid (MAA) or alpha lipoic acid (ALA)—and was employed in Hg
2+ adsorption
[146]. For comparison, the
Zr-MOFs-SH(P) was synthesized via post-synthetic modification of the
Zr-MOFs-SH(O) and was engaged in adsorption studies. Due to the higher -SH content in the
Zr-MOFs-SH(O), it showed a higher adsorption capacity (for Hg
2+) of 843.6 mg g
−1 than that of the
Zr-MOFs-SH(P) (138.5 mg g
−1). Hg
2+ adsorption of the
Zr-MOFs-SH(O) followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic model and was best fitted with Langmuir isotherm. In addition, this study showed good selectivity, recyclability, and chemical stability. By functionalizing the
NH2-UIO-66 with L-cysteine, the
Cys-UIO-66 was obtained and was used for Hg
2+ removal from solution
[147]. The
Cys-UIO-66 showed a maximum adsorption capacity of 350.14 mg g
−1 (after 180 min) at pH 5.0 of Hg
2+ adsorption which followed the pseudo-second-order model and was fitted with Langmuir isotherm. Due to the -SH (from cysteine) affinity to Hg
2+, reusability of Hg
2+ adsorption/desorption was up to five cycles (with 0.1 M HNO
3 and 1% thiourea solution). In terms of the capacity and time consumption, this study could need more improvements. By following the similar approach, Liu and co-workers presented the cysteamine functionalized
MOFs-MIL-101-SH (Cr) and
UIO-66-SH (Zr) for Hg
2+ removal
[148]. The MOFs showed adsorption capacities of 10 and 250 mg g
−1 at pH of 5, respectively, with certain reusability.
By utilizing four different types of organic ligands with bulky sulphur side chains, four Zr-based MOFs, namely
Zr-L1,
Zr-L2,
Zr-L3, and
Zr-L4 (Zr(IV)-carboxylate frameworks; where
L1-L4 represents the deprotonated four thioether-equipped carboxylic acid linker molecules), were constructed for selective removal of Hg
2+ ions
[149]. The
Kds values of
Zr-L1,
Zr-L2,
Zr-L3, and
Zr-L4 were estimated as 1.95 × 10
3 mL g
−1, 1.47 × 10
4 mL g
−1, 4.47 × 10
3 mL g
−1, and 2.40 × 10
4 mL g
−1, respectively. Moreover, Hg adsorption of
Zr-L1,
Zr-L2,
Zr-L3, and
Zr-L4 followed the Langmuir isotherm with capacities of 193 mg g
−1, 275 mg g
−1, 245 mg g
−1, and 322 mg g
−1 at pH 6.8, correspondingly. However, this work needs further investigations on interference studies and real time applications. The Zr-based MOF-
DUT-67 (Zr) synthesized by solvothermal reaction of zirconium chloride with 2, 5-thiophene-dicarboxylic acid showed removal efficiencies for Hg
2+ and CH
3Hg
+ from 69% to 90% and from 30% to 77%, respectively
[150]. At pH 6, the
DUT-67 (Zr) showed a great efficiency to Hg
2+ and CH
3Hg
+ with adsorption capacities of 0.0451 mg g
−1 and 0.0374 mg g
−1, respectively. The adsorption followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic model. This work was also demonstrated in river and lake water samples, but mechanism and interference studies require further investigations. The ZrO
2-based
(MOF)-808 synthesized by a sol-gel method was grafted with amidoxime (AO) via wet-chemistry process to afford
MOF-808/AO, which was used in Hg
2+ removal and displayed high efficiencies
[151]. In particular, the
MOF-808/AO showed a higher adsorption efficiency in all pHs. The BET surface area of
MOF-808 and
MOF-808/AO were established as 2152 and 1899 m
2 g
−1, respectively. Moreover, adsorption capacities of
MOF-808 and
MOF-808/AO towards Hg
2+ were estimated as 383.8 mg g
−1 and 343.6 mg g
−1 (at 70 min), correspondingly. The Hg
2+ adsorption in both MOFs followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic model and was fitted with Langmuir isotherms. This work requires more efforts to obtain additional information on the mechanism, interference effect, and real time analysis.
The Zr-based MOFs and Zn-metal nodes comprising MOFs were also engaged in Hg
2+ removal as detailed next. The Zn
2(DHBDC)(DMF)
2·(H
2O)
2, namely
MOF-74-Zn, was synthesized by solvothermally reacting ZnNO
3 and 2,5-dihydroxy-1,4-benzenedicarboxylic acid (DHBDC) and was applied in Hg
2+ removal
[152]. The
MOF-74-Zn showed a maximum adsorption capacity of 63 mg g
−1 (for Hg
2+ at pH 6 in 90 min). The Hg
2+ adsorption followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic model but was best fitted with the Langmuir isotherm rather than the Freundlich isotherm. The -OH group was directly involved in adsorption of Hg
2+. However, this work showed a minimum adsorption capacity and lacked information on the interference effect. Wang and co-workers presented the Zn-based MOF, namely
NTOU-4 (hydro(solvo)thermally synthesized by reacting ZnNO
3 with 1H-1,2,4-triazole-3,5-diamine and 1,4-benzenedicarboxylate organic linkers) for Hg
2+ removal applications
[153]. The
NTOU-4 showed an adsorption capacity of 163 mg g
−1 at 30 min and was operable between pH 3–11. However, the underlying mechanism, kinetic model, and isotherm studies require further clarification. Next, Esrafili et al. described the utilization of dual functionalized Zn-based MOF, namely
TMU-32S (synthesized by incorporation of different percentile of N1,N3-di(pyridine-4-yl) malonamide in
TMU-32 (a Zn containing MOF with urea linkers)), towards Hg
2+ adsorption and removal
[154]. Due to the strong binding forces produced by urea and malonamide functional units, the
TMU-32S showed a high adsorption capacity of 1428 mg g
−1 (in just 17 min) and became more efficient at pH 4.4. The system followed the linear pseudo-second-order model and was linearly fitted with the Langmuir isotherm. Moreover, the material showed adsorption and desorption (with 0.2 M of EDTA) up to three cycles with 65% efficiency. This work requires more studies regarding the interference effect with several metal analytes.
Subsequently, the Cu-based MOFs were authorized as efficient adsorbents for Hg
2+ removal as described next. Wu et al. developed the copper and 3,30,5,50-azobenzenetetracarboxylic acid containing porous MOF, namely
JUC-62, for Hg
2+ removal in tea and mushroom samples
[155]. The adsorption capacity of the
JUC-62 to Hg
2+ was established as 836.7 mg g
−1 at pH 4.6 in 15 min in aqueous media. This work followed the pseudo-second-order model and was fitted with Langmuir adsorption isotherm. Moreover, it was reusable with EDTA up to four cycles. However, further interrogations are required on the interference studies. Mon and co-workers described utilization of a Cu-based MOF, namely
{Cu4II[(S,S)-methox]2}.5H2O (where methox represents bis[(S)-methionine]oxalyl diamide), for HgCl
2 removal studies
[156]. This microporous MOF was decorated with thioalkyl chains, thereby was able to adsorb HgCl
2 efficiently to afford the HgCl
2S
2 adduct. This MOF adsorbed 99.95% of HgCl
2 within 15 min and reduced the Hg
2+ concentration from 10 ppm to below 2 ppb in drinking water. However, this work lacked information on the reusability, kinetic studies, and real applications. Next, the polysulfides functionalized benzene-1,3,5-tricarboxylic acid and Cu containing
Sx-MOF (where MOF represents Cu-BTC (by solvothermal tactic) and S
x2−, X = 3, 4, 6) were described for efficient adsorption of Hg
2+ [157]. Among these materials, the
S4-MOF displayed great selectivity to Hg
2+ with a LOD of 0.13 μg L
−1 and a linear response from 30–200 μg L
−1 at pH 6 in 30 min. The
S4-MOF showed different adsorbing capacities to different metal ions in the following orders: Hg(II) > > Pb(II) > Zn(II) > Ni(II) > Co(II). By means of Hg
2+-S bonding, adsorption was efficient and applicable in sea, tap, and wastewater. However, information regarding kinetic studies is still missing. A copper metallacycle complex, namely
Cu2(PDMA)2(DMF) (comprised of 3,3′-((1E,1′E)-(pyrimidine-4,6-diylbis(2-methylhydrazin-2-yl-1-ylidene)) bis (methanylylidene)dibenzoic acid (H
2PDMA)), was demonstrated for Hg
2+ removal
[158]. Due to the multi ‘N′ binding sites, the MOF showed an adsorption efficiency of 61.4% for Hg
2+ (among Hg
2 +, Mn
2 +, Cd
2 +, Pb
2 + ions) with an adsorption capacity of 300 mg g
−1. Moreover, this MOF was reusable with EDTA. The Hg
2+ adsorption followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic model. Xu and co-workers proposed utilization of the
SH@Cu-MOF towards adsorption of Hg
2+ and Hg
(0) species by grafting dithioglycol from the post-synthetic modified
Cu-MOF (Cu with 5-aminoisophthalic)
[159]. Though the material seems to be impressive compared to others reports, however, its adsorption capacity (173 mg g
−1 in 6 h) was not up to standard. However, this work does point to a new direction for future development of the Cu-based MOFs.
Liang and co-workers described utilization of the sulfur-functionalized Co-based MOF, namely
FJI-H12 (composed of NCS
-, Co(II) and 2,4,6-tri(1-imidazolyl)-1,3,5-triazine (Timt)), for Hg
2+ removal in water
[160]. The
FJI-H12 showed a
Kd value of 1.85 × 10
6 mL g
−1 with an adsorption capacity of 439.8 mg g
−1 at pH 7. The adsorption was efficient because of the Hg
2+ to S (of SCN
-) affinity and it could be applied for continuous removal purpose. Moreover, this work followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic model and was also reusable, thereby is attested a nice work. Jiang et al. designed a stable sulfur containing Co-based MOF {[Co
3(μ
3-OH)(DMTDC)
3(INT)
3]-[Co
2(OH)(H
2O)
2](NO
3)
19-(H
2O)
7(DMA)
11}
n, namely
NENU-401 (where DMTDC, INT, DMF, and DMA represent 3,4-dimethylthieno[2,3-b]thiophene-2,5-dicarboxylic acid, isonicotinate, N,N-dimethylformamide, and N,N-dimethylacetamide), via introducing an INT group in
NENU-400-{[Co
3(μ
3-OH)(H
2O)
3(DMTDC)
3](NO
3)
10-(H
2O)
6(DMF)
6} and utilized it successfully in Hg
2+ removal
[161]. Unlike the
NENU-400, which collapsed easily during Hg
2+ adsorption, the
NENU-401 preserved its structural features, thereby was highly applicable for Hg
2+ extraction. The
Kd value of NENU-401 at 25 °C was estimated as 8.3 × 10
6 mL g
−1 with an adsorption capacity of 596.57 mg g
−1 in 10 min. The
NENU-401 performed far better than many thiol containing MOFs. Moreover, Hg
2+ extraction by the
NENU-401 was recovered up to 90% of its original by thioglycol solution and was reusable for more than four cycles because of the effective coordination between Hg
2+ and ‘-S′ atom. Note that the
NENU-401-based Hg
2+ extraction followed the pseudo-second-order kinetic model and was linearly fitted with Langmuir isotherm. This work demonstrated an impressive approach to improve the structural stability of MOFs. Moreover, it also displayed certain selectivity to Pb
2+ (nearly 70%) but still required further optimization. Recently, Sun′s research group proposed employment of the sulfur-rich two-dimensional (2D) Co-based MOF nanosheets, namely
2D-NCS ({[Co(NCS)
2(pyz)
2]}
n; where pyz represents pyrazine), for exceptional removal of HgCl
2 [162]. The BET surface area of
2D-NCS to N
2 gas at 77K was established as 365 m
2 g
−1 with a maximum adsorption capacity of 1698 mg g
−1 in 15 min and a
Kd value of 2.26 × 10
6 mL g
−1. The MOF nanosheets reduced Hg
2+ concentrations from 10 ppm to 1 ppb within 15 min and were also effective in environmental samples between pH 4–9. This work followed the pseudo-second-order model and was fitted with Langmuir isotherm. Due to the strong Hg–S interactions, extraction was efficient up to five cycles (by thioglycol solution) and could be further tuned towards development of 3D materials for future environmental remediation. Similar to the
FJI-H12 [152], another Co-based MOF- [Co
3(SCN)
6(TPMA)
4]n, namely
FJI-H30 (synthesized by solvothermally refluxing TPMA (tris(pyridin-4-ylmethyl)amine) and Co(SCN)
2), was engaged in Hg
2+ adsorption
[163]. Due to the exceptional interaction between SCN
− groups to Hg
2+, its maximum adsorption capacity reached 705 mg g
−1 with negligible interference. The BET surface area of
FJI-H30 to CO
2 gas at 195K was determined as 221 m
2 g
−1. This material showed a
Kd value of 1.84 × 10
5 mL g
−1 and operated efficiently between pH 4–9 with regeneration (by KSCN solution) of >90% up to three cycles. This work followed the pseudo-second-order model and was fitted with Langmuir isotherm. It can be applied in industrial waste water, thereby is considered a nice work.
Halder et al. engaged the thiocyanato ligand (SCN
−) comprising Ni-based 3D MOF, namely
[Ni(3-bpd)2(NCS)2]n (where 3bpd represents 1,4-bis(3-pyridyl)-2,3-diaza-1,3-butadiene), for effective removal of Hg
2+ in aqueous solution
[164]. Because the uncoordinated S atom of SCN
− was strongly bonded with Hg
2+ and formed the mercuric thiocyanate adduct, therefore, a great adsorption capacity of 713 mg g
−1 was achieved. Nevertheless, this work still requires further optimization for the interference effect, adsorption kinetics, and practicality. A post-synthetic modified tactic was proposed to develop the thiol (-SH) functionalized In-based MOF, namely
SH-MIL-68(In) (primarily
NH2-MIL-68(In) obtained by solvothermally reacting 2-amino-benzene-1, 4-dicarboxylic acid (NH
2-H
2BDC) with In (NO
3)
3 followed by post-synthetic modification), towards Hg
2+ extraction
[165]. The
SH-MIL-68(In) showed a highest Hg
2+ adsorption capacity of 450 mg g
−1 and a large adsorption rate (rate constant
k2 = 1.25 g mg
−1 min
−1). As seen in
Figure 11, the adsorption process took place within 2 min at pH 4 due to the presence of free -SH group.
Figure 11. Schematic of post-synthetic modification of
NH2-MIL-68(In) to afford
SH-MIL-68(In) and its utilization in Hg
2+ extraction (Reproduced with the permission from Ref
[165]).
The material was reusable (in the presence of 0.01 M HCl, 0.1% thiourea) up to five cycles. This work followed the pseudo-second-order model and was linearly fitted with Langmuir isotherm. It is an impressive work considering its short process time and negligible interferences. However, real time applicability still needs to be demonstrated. By means of diffusion and solvothermal strategies, Li et al. developed three thioether-based MOFs, namely
[(ZnCl2)3(L1)2·χ(solvent)]n-(1), [(Cu2I3O2)4(CH4N0.5)4(L1)4(DMA)4·3(H2O)·χ(solvent)]n-(2), and [(CuBr2)2(L2)2 CH3CN·χ(solvent)]n-(3) (where L
1 and L
2 represent 1,3,5-tris((pyridin-4-ylthio)methyl)benzene and 2,4,6-trimethoxy-1,3,5-tris((pyridin-4-ylthio) methyl)benzene; DMA = Dimethylacetamide) to utilize them for effective removal of Hg
2+ in water
[166]. These MOFs removed 90% of Hg
2+ within 5 min at optimum pHs 4 and 5. The maximum adsorption capacities of MOFs
(1),
(2), and
(3) were estimated to be 362.3 mg g
−1, 227.4 mg g
−1, and 341.7 mg g
−1, respectively. The observed higher efficiencies to Hg
2+ was attributed to the strong binding between Hg-S. They were reusable up to five cycles (with Na
2S). This work followed the pseudo-second-order model and was linearly correlated with the Langmuir isotherm. This work is considered a good one because of the negligible interference effect, but further optimization is required to improve the adsorption capacity.
The bi-metallic MOFs were also employed in Hg
2+ removal/extraction as described next. Han and co-workers constructed the heterometallic metal−organic framework (HMOF): {[(CH
3)
2NH
2]InCu
4L
4·
xS}
n, namely
BUT-52 (where L represents 6,6′-dithiodinicotinic acid), to engage in Hg
2+ removal, in which In(COO)
4 and Cu
6S
6 clusters were rationally embedded
[167]. The BET surface area of
BUT-52 to N
2 gas at 77K was 126.2 cm
3 g
−1. It showed 92% of mercury removal efficiency in ethanol. This work requires further optimization in anti-interference, pH, time, and real time application studies. Mon et al. described utilization of the Ca and Cu-based porous bimetallic MOF, namely
{CaIICuII6[(S,S)-methox]3(OH)2(H2O)}·16H2O (where methox represents bis[(S)-methionine]oxalyl diamide), for Hg
2+ and CH
3Hg
+ removal in aqueous media
[168]. This BioMOF reduced Hg
2+ and CH
3Hg
+ contents from 10 ppm to 5 and 27 ppb, respectively, with corresponding adsorbing ability of 99.95% and 99.0% (via Hg–S interactions) for dissolved HgCl
2 and CH
3HgCl salts. However, optimization is required to study the adsorption kinetics and real applications. In parallel with MOFs-based extraction/removal of Hg
2+, a few MOFs were also reported in multiple heavy metal ions, including Hg
2+ [169,170,171,172,173][169][170][171][172][173]. Though those reports demonstrated effective removal of Hg
2+, but they were also affected by interfering effects from other ions. To avoid the interfering effects, complicated masking procedure is required. Therefore, those reports will not be discussed in this review.
11. MOFs for Simultaneous Detection and Removal of Hg2+
As suggested by earlier studies
[153[153][175],
175], MOFs were also engaged in simultaneous detection and removal studies as discussed in this section. For instance, Rudd et al. demonstrated heavy metal ions sensing and removal using solvothermally synthesized Zn-based luminescent MOFs, namely Zn
2(ofdc)
2(tppe)-
LMOFs-261, Zn
2(hfdc)
2(tppe)-
LMOFs-262, and Zn
2(dbtdcO
2)
2(tppe)-
LMOFs-263), where H
2ofdc, H
2dbtdcO
2, and tppe represent [9-oxo-9H-fluorene-2,7-dicarboxylic acid], [dibenzo[b,d]thiophene-3,7-dicarboxylic acid-5,5-dioxide], and 1,1,2,2-tetrakis(4-(pyridine-4-yl)phenyl)ethane, respectively
[195]. Among these MOFs, the
LMOFs-263 displayed the highest luminescent selectivity to Hg
2+ and Pb
2+ with LODs of 3.3 and 19.7 ppb, respectively. Moreover, it showed a maximum adsorption capacity of 380 mg g
−1 (for Hg
2= within 30 min) and the adsorption followed pseudo-second-order kinetics. A
Kd value of 6.45 × 10
5 mL g
−1 was determined for the
LMOFs-263. The effective adsorption was attributed to the strong interaction between Hg
2+ and SO
22− (of H
2dbtdcO
2) and the pore size. The BET surface area of
LMOFs-263 was estimated as 1004 m
2 g
−1 to N
2 gas at 77K, however, further investigations are required to overcome the Pb
2+ interference. Al-based imidazolate framework, namely
NH2-MIL-53(Al), for selective detection and removal of Hg
2+ was reported by Zhang and co-workers
[196]. Because of the coordination of amino (-NH
2) group and ligand-to-metal charge transfer (LMCT) effect with Hg
2+, fluorescent intensity of the
NH2-MIL-53(Al) at 427 nm (λ
ex = 330 nm) was linearly quenched between 1−17.3 μM with a LOD of 0.15 μM. In addition, Hg
2+ sensing ability of the
NH2-MIL-53(Al) was good at pHs 4–10 without any interference. The MOF showed an adsorption capacity of 53.85 mg g
−1 (for Hg
2+) and was reusable with 0.1 M HCl and 10% thiourea eluent. This work followed pseudo second order kinetic model and was linearly correlated with the Langmuir isotherm, thereby is a nice probe.
By loading the (bis(4-(dimethylamino)phenyl)methanethione) probe over the Al-based MOF (which was solvothermally synthesized by reacting Al(NO
3)
3·9H
2O and terephthalic acid), detection and removal of Hg
2+ in water and skin-whitening cosmetics was delivered by Radwan and co-workers
[197]. These thioketone Al-MOFs monitors (
TAM) acted as microporous carriers towards Hg
2+ via fluorescent quenching at 470 nm and enhancement at 610 nm with a linear range from 2 nM to 2.1 µM and a LOD of 4.4 nM. Moreover, the thioketone Al-MOF (
TAM) nanorods were used in effective adsorption of Hg
2+, which showed a maximum adsorption capacity of 1110 mg g
−1 with exceptional applicability in water and skin-whitening cosmetics. Shahat et al. engaged the modified amino-functionalized Al-MOF for optical recognition and removal of Hg
2+ [198]. AlCl
3·6H
2O and 2-amino terephthalic acid was first solvothermally reacted to yield the
MOF-NH2-MIL-101(Al) followed by modification with ninhydrin to obtain the final adduct
Nin-NH-MIL-101(Al). The
Nin-NH-MIL-101(Al) showed a BET surface area of 896.6 m
2 g
−1 for N
2 gas at 77K. It was used as a colorimetric sensory probe for Hg
2+ with a LOD of 0.494 µg L
−1 and was further applied in removal studies. The probe displayed a maximum adsorption capacity of 127.4 mg g
−1 and was recyclable in the presence of 0.1 M thiourea as shown in
Figure 15. This work followed the pseudo second order kinetic model and was linearly fitted Langmuir isotherm. Be noted that the
Nin-NH-MIL-101(Al)-based optical detection and removal of Hg
2+ was not affected by any interference.
Figure 15. Representative design of the
Nin-NH-MIL-101(Al) sensor applied to purification of water polluted with Hg(II) ions and the reversible process by using 0.1 M thiourea solution for several times (reproduced with the permission from Ref
[198]).
By means of hydrothermal reactions, the Cu-based MOFs and amide-functionalized pillar ligands (–NH–CO–), namely
TMU-46,
47, and
48, were synthesized and then decorated with suitable functional group malonamide (S) to produce the labelled dual functionalized materials-
TMU-46S,
TMU-47S, and
TMU-48S, respectively. They were applied towards Hg
2+ sensing and removal
[199]. The BET surface areas of
TMU-46S,
TMU-47S, and
TMU-48S were 510 m
2 g
−1, 520 m
2 g
−1, and 408 m
2 g
−1, respectively. Because of the strong coordination of Hg to S, the
TMU-48S displayed the highest selectivity to Hg
2+ via fluorescent quenching at 480 nm (λ
ex = 330 nm) with a K
SV value of 86,087 M
−1. Moreover, the
TMU-48S showed a maximum adsorption capacity of 714 mg g
−1. However, it also showed some selectivity to Pb
2+ and Ag
+. The CuS particles (
PCuS) were synthesized via wet-treatment of Cu-based MOF-
HKUST-1 and were engaged in colorimetric detection of Hg
2+ in the presence of 3,3′,5′,5-tetramethylbenzidine (TMB) and H
2O
2 (by peroxidase like activity)
[200]. The BET surface area of
PCuS was calculated to be 35 m
2 g
−1 with a linear colorimetric response between 3–40 µM and an established LOD of 0.22 µM. Moreover, the
PCuS showed a maximum adsorption capacity of 2105 mg g
−1. The system followed the pseudo second order kinetic and was linearly fitted with the Langmuir isotherm.
A porphyrinic Zr-based MOF, namely
PCN-221 (by solvothermal reaction between meso-tetra(4-carboxyphenyl) porphyrin (TCPP) and ZrCl
4), was proposed for fluorescent sensing and removal of Hg
2+ in water
[201]. The
PCN-221 showed linear quenching at 436 nm (λ
ex = 280 nm) in the presence of Hg
2+ concentrations from 0 to 300 μM with a K
SV value of 4021.9 M
−1 and a LOD of 0.01 μM. Moreover, sensing ability of DMF by
PCN-221 was also described in this report with extensive Hg
2+ adsorption studies. The
PCN-221 displayed a maximum capacity of 233.65 mg g
−1 towards Hg
2+ adsorption and was highly effective at pH 7. Three adsorption-desorption cycles were achieved in the presence of 0.2 M Na
2EDTA without any interference effect. This study followed the pseudo second order model and was linearly correlated by the Langmuir isotherm. Recently, a 3D-microporous carbon/Zr-2,5-dimercaptoterephthalic acid MOFs (
Zr-DMBD MOFs/3D-KSC) nanocomposite was delivered towards electrochemical detection and removal of Hg
2+ [202]. Sensitivity of the nanocomposite to Hg
2+ was established as 24.58 μA μM
−1 cm
−2 with a linear range of 0.25–3.5 μM and a LOD of 0.05 µM. It was confirmed that specificity and effectiveness of the composite were similar to sensory and other utilities of nanomaterials
[203,204,205,206][203][204][205][206]. This may be due to the presence of thiol (-SH) group of 2,5-dimercaptoterephthalic acid, which has great affinity to Hg
2+. The
Zr-DMBD MOFs/3D-KSC showed a maximum adsorption capacity (for Hg
2+) of 19.3 ± 0.52 mg g
−1 (within 60 min at pH 6) and was reusable up to five cycles with EDTA. This work was also applied in real water samples. However, information regarding adsorption kinetics still needs to be discussed. Apart from specific Hg
2+ sensing/adsorption utilization of MOFs, the Hg-metalated MOF scaffold can be employed for detection of other species. For example, Hg-metalated
PCN-222 was reported as fluorescent and visual sensors for cysteine
[207], which pointed out the possible future direction of MOFs-based Hg
2+ sensors.