Morella and Myrica Phytochemicals: Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 1 by Maria do Carmo Barreto and Version 3 by Camila Xu.

Myrica and Morella (Myricaceae) are taxonomically close genera, which include species of trees or shrubs with edible fruits that exhibit relevant uses in traditional medicine. A wide array of compounds isolated from different parts of Myrica and/or Morella species possess several biological activities, like anticancer, antidiabetic, anti-obesity, and cardio-/neuro-/hepatoprotective activities, both in vitro and in vivo, with myricanol, myricitrin, quercitrin, and betulin being the most promising. There are still many other compounds isolated from both genera whose biological activities have not been evaluated, which represents an excellent opportunity to discover new applications for those compounds and valorize Morella/Myrica species.

  • Morella
  • Myrica
  • myricanol
  • myricitrin
  • Morella,Myrica,myricanol,myricitrin

1. Introduction

Nature is an important source of new biologically active compounds and molecules with very diverse and unique biological properties and chemical structures, several of them being commercialized as medicines [1]. This diversity is the result of a long and selective evolutionary pressure [2], that led to an array of different biosynthetic pathways producing primary and, in particular, secondary metabolites with a large variety of basic skeletons and functional groups, which have been huge contributors to the improvement of human health [3].

That evolutionary pressure is more intense in plants and other sessile organisms because, since they are unable to move, they are more exposed to the action of herbivores, pathogens. and/or variable sunlight conditions, and therefore need to produce very effective molecules that enable them to survive all of these threats [4]. That fact, allied to the extraordinary biological and chemical diversity within plants, offers a particularly rich potential in biologically active compounds that can be used to provide lead compounds for the production of medications for treating various diseases from migraine to cancer. Twenty-five percent of all prescribed drugs are derived from plants, and of the 252 drugs considered as basic and essential by the World Health Organization, 11% are exclusively of plant origin and a significant number are drugs obtained from natural precursors by semi-synthesis. Thus, medicinal plants and their derived natural compounds are still an increasing topic of investigation and interest [5][6][5,6].

The members of the Myrica and Morella genera are woody shrubs or tree pioneers in nitrogen-poor soils such as sandy soil or gravelly sites, because they are actinorhizal plants able to fix nitrogen through nitrogen-fixing root nodules induced by soil actinomycetes of the genus Frankia, with which they establish a symbiotic relationship [7]. In addition to the economic interest of these species as sources of paper and rope from the bark, as fuel wood, for biomass production, and land reclamation, they are also appreciated because their fruits that can be eaten raw and are used in the production of jams, syrups, and juices [8], and their applications in traditional medicine are also noteworthy.

The Myrica genus comprised, before 2002, circa 97 species with a wide distribution in both temperate and sub-tropical regions [8][9][8,9]. Macdonald [10] [10] presented various reasons for splitting this genus in two, Myrica and Morella, with his arguments only being accepted in 2002 [11]. A taxonomic key was published to allow the simple discrimination between species of the two genera [12]. The splitting of the Myrica genus led to many of the species previously belonging to the Myrica genus being reclassified and included in the Morella genus, which can cause problems when trying to correlate the discovery of secondary metabolites with the plant of origin. Many studies published before 2005 report the isolation of secondary metabolites from Myrica species which are now classified as Morella species, causing misleading reports on secondary metabolites found for the first time in the genus. Another issue is the fact that more recent publications use the previous scientific name, that consequently can lead to a compound not being properly detected in a literature survey.

2. Biological Activities Exhibited by Secondary Metabolites from Morella and Myrica Species

Several of the secondary metabolites isolated from Morella and Myrica species have been studied to evaluate their potential application in human health. Silva et al. [13] [13] reviewed compounds isolated from Morella and Myrica species exhibiting antioxidant and anti-inflammatory activities, reporting the antioxidant potential of various compounds as well as pertinent structure/activity relationships that could direct future research in order to obtain new, more active, and safer molecules. Therefore, this section is focused on other biological activities exhibited by compounds isolated from species of the Morella and Myrica genera. There are two bioactive compounds, myricetin and arjunolic acid, isolated, among others, from Myrica esculenta Buch.-Ham. Ex D. Don [14], whose biological activities have already been revised by Gupta et al. [15] [15] and Gosh et al. [16], ranging from antidiabetic to antibacterial, anticancer, or anti-inflammatory. For that reason, those compounds will not be addressed in this work.

2.1. In Vitro Activities

In vitro studies represent the first step in the evaluation of the pharmacological effects of compounds. They are a simpler and cheaper way to assess the bioactivities of the tested compounds and yield very important and relevant information to direct further investigations on the full pharmacological potential of a compound. The results of in vitro tests performed with compounds isolated from Morella and Myrica are summarized in Table 1, where the compounds are organized by family.

Table 1. In vitro biological activities exhibited by compounds from Morella and Myrica species.

d-Glcpy = d-glucopyranoside.

As seen in Table 1, bioactive compounds are found in every part of the plant, from roots to the leaves, and the same compound can be found in members of both genera, which shows a close chemotaxonomic relationship, resulting from the taxonomic reorganization of the previous genus Myrica [12].

As seen in Table 1, bioactive compounds are found in every part of the plant, from roots to the leaves, and the same compound can be found in members of both genera, which shows a close chemotaxonomic relationship, resulting from the taxonomic reorganization of the previous genus Myrica [12].

A variety of compounds are present, including diarylheptanoids, dihydrochalcones, triterpenoids and flavonoids, but the majority of the bioactive compounds obtained from Morella and Myrica genera are cyclic diarylheptanoids, a class of compounds known by their wide array of biological activities [63]. From the analysis of Table 1 it is also clear that the compounds which have been more widely studied are myricanone (1), myricanol (4), quercitrin (9), myricitrin (10), and betulin (16), so details about the most interesting works and compounds from Table 1 will be discussed in the following paragraphs.

Myricanone (1) presents cytotoxic activity against A549 and HepG2 cell-lines with EC50 of 3.22 µg/mL [25], and 32.46 µM [27], respectively. Myricanone (1) increases the apoptotic rate of A549 tumor cells from 4.13% in untreated cells to 34.9% (after treatment) in a dose-dependent manner, and significantly inhibits colony formation in A-549, by inducing cell-cycle arrest in G1 phase [25]. Although the authors indicate that fluorouracil was used as positive control, and that myricanone (1) is more active than the positive control [25], the EC50 of fluorouracil is not presented, which hinders a more realistic assessment of the potency of myricanone effects against A549 cells.

Myricanol (4) showed cytotoxic activity against HL60 (leukemia), A549 (lung), and SK-BR-3 (breast) cell-lines, with IC50 similar or lower (Table 1) than the positive control cisplatin [18]. The author also demonstrated that induced apoptosis cell via mitochondrial (caspase 3, 8, and 9 were activated) and death receptor pathway in HL-60 cell, suggesting its potential anticancer activity. Similar results were obtained by Dai et al. [33] [33] against A-549 cells.

Myricanol (4) also presents a very interesting activity by inhibiting muscle atrophy and dysfunction caused by dexamethasone in C2C12 myotubes [33]. As seen in Table 1, pretreatment with 4 induces a variety of processes that lead to or are a reflex of the direct activation of Sirtuin-1 [30], a protein that regulates skeletal muscle remodeling, which directly deacetylates and therefore activates PGC-1α to regulate mitochondrial biogenesis [64], induces autophagy to enhance degraded protein clearance and modulates FoxOs transcriptional activity to reduce atrogin-1 and MuRF1 expression, which are responsible for protein degradation, and consequently control loss of muscle mass and function [65]. Since there are only a few molecules approved for the treatment of muscle atrophy, and the majority come with very undesirable side effects like insulin resistance, sodium retention, or possibility of thromboembolisms [66], there is a need to find alternative molecules capable of treating this condition. The results shown by myricanol (4) turn it into a good candidate for that alternative.

Additionally, myricanol shows neuroprotective effects in N2a neuronal cells exposed to H2O2 [32]. Pretreatment with 0.84 mM of 4 increased 80% of cell viability, decreased 40% of intracellular reactive oxygen species (ROS) formation and reduced intracellular calcium concentrations, compared with the H2O2 group.

Quercitrin (9) is one of the most studied among the compounds from Morella and Myrica genera. Despite most of the studies being performed with quercitrin isolated from other sources, the fact that this compound has also been isolated in Morella and Myrica genera, namely Morella adenophora (Hance) J. Herb. [19], is in itself an added value to the biological importance of these genera. Compound 9 is a potent α-glucosidase inhibitor, an enzymatic target used to evaluate antidiabetic effect. It has an IC50 four times lower than acarbose, a commercial inhibitor, which indicates the great potential of quercitrin as a hypoglycemic agent for diabetes treatment [36]. Mercury and lead are considered as threats to human organisms, due to their low elimination rate and high accumulation, which have nefarious effects in several physiological functions, especially of liver and nervous system [67][68][67,68]. A study carried out by Aldana et al. [39] [39] demonstrated the capacity of quercitrin (9) as cytoprotective agent for the HepG2 cell line against both metals. However, on PC12 cells, quercitrin was only able to protect against the effects of lead [39]. Further investigations are necessary to explain the cytoprotective mechanism of the compound.

Quercitrin (9) also presents a moderate antiviral activity by inhibition of neuraminidase (NA) [37], a viral enzyme common in human influenza viruses, which is essential for the virus release from infected cells to the neighboring cells of the respiratory tract [69]. It has also been reported that quercitrin (9) inhibits the activity of myeloperoxidase, with an IC50 of 2.0 µM [38], a result that hints at its possible role in reducing endothelial dysfunction and consequently that the protective effect of 9 should be evaluated in an atherosclerosis model.

A great number of the studies reviewed about the pharmacological activities of myricitrin (10) focused on its effects against cardiovascular problems [43][44][45][43,44,45]. Qin et al. [45] [45] suggest that myricitrin treatment protected human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVECs) against the effects of oxidized low-density lipoprotein (ox-LDL), which results in reduced atherosclerotic plaque formation.

It was also found that 40 µM myricitrin protects H9c2 cardiomyocytes against hypoxia/reoxygenation injury, increasing cell-survival from 65.48% in untreated cells to 87.48% (Table 1) [43]. In addition, there was a reduction in the expression of pro-apoptotic factors, like caspase-3 or Bax, and an increase in the expression of anti-apoptotic factors, like Bcl-2. Likewise, the authors formulated that myricitrin (10) might exert its cardioprotective effects via stimulation of the expression of heat shock protein 90, whose activation promotes the anti-apoptotic PI3-K/Akt signaling pathway [43].

In a model of diabetic cardiomyopathy injury, Zhang et al. [44] [44] found that pretreatment with 53.8 µM of myricitrin significantly decreased advanced glycation end products (AGEs)-induced inflammatory cytokine expression, limited an increase in ROS levels, and reduced cell apoptosis, fibrosis, and hypertrophy in H9c2 cells (Table 1). Overall, the protective effects of myricitrin could be attributed to its antioxidant and anti-inflammatory effects, as well as its ability to activate the Akt signaling pathway [43][44][43,44]. The anti-ROS activity of 10 is also responsible for the neuroprotective activities reported by Shen et al. [17] [17] and Wang et al. [47] [47] as observable by the effects described in Table 1.

Myricitrin (10) is also a potent α-glucosidase (IC50 = 1.1 µM) and β-amylase inhibitor (IC50 = 1.9 µM), being 20- and 10-fold more active than acarbose, respectively [48].

Myricanone (1), myricanol (4), and myricitrin (10) were found to inhibit melanogenesis in B16 mouse melanoma cells (Table 1) [26]. The melanin content found after exposure to the compounds was lower than the positive control, arbutin. However, the mechanism by which this occurred was different. For myricanone (1) and myricanol (4), it was due to their cytotoxic effects on the B16 cells, while 10 exerted its antimelanogenesis effect without killing the B16 cells, similar to the effect of arbutin [26].

Respiration uncoupling seems to be implicated in numerous physiological and pathological processes like autophagy, regulation of ROS production, protein secretion, capacity to carry out physical exercise, and adipose tissue biology [70]. As seen in Table 1, a series of dihydrochalcones, which have been isolated from various species of Morella and Myrica, possess the ability to uncouple the mitochondrial respiratory chain. Myrigalone A (11) and myrigalone G (15) were the best uncouplers, increasing the respiratory rate more than two-fold with respect to the positive control, 2,4-dinitrophenol (DNP) [53]. Although respiratory uncouplers may have some therapeutic interest, they must be evaluated for their safety, and there are no records of such study on the safety of myrigalones 1115 as respiratory chain uncoupling agents.

Myrigalone B (12) and myrigalone G (15) inhibited α-glucosidase activity with IC50 of 19 and 7 µM, respectively, which is lower than the positive control, acarbose (43 µM). For β-amylase inhibition, 12 was again the most active with an IC50 of 8.3 µM against 33 µM obtained with compound 15 (Table 1) [48]. In this case myrigalone B (12) was still more active than acarbose, but not myrigalone G (15), since the IC50 of acarbose for β-amylase inhibition was 19 µM. Despite their potential as antidiabetic compounds, 12 and 15 are still less active inhibitors than myricitrin (10).

Another very interesting compound found in Morella/Myrica genera is betulin (16), which has presented a wide array of antitumor activities (Table 1). Lin et al. [57] [57] reported the anticancer activity against two lines of osteosarcoma, MG-63 and HOS cell lines, with an IC50 of 14.54 and 11.70 µM, respectively. Unfortunately, no positive control was used to compare with the potency of botulin (16). The authors found that the effect of 16 in osteosarcoma cell lines is through the induction of apoptosis and autophagy to suppress cell viability, as well as by the inhibition of mTOR signaling. Betulin (16) is also very active against the NCi-H460 (IC50 = 2.8 µM) and HT29-MTX (IC50 = 1.6 µM) cell lines, being much more active than the positive control podophyllotoxin (22 and 24 µM against these two cell lines, respectively) [58]. Compound 16 was also found to be active against A549 and SK-Br-3 cell lines, with a more potent effect than cisplatin (Table 1), but is less potent against the HL60 cell-line [18].

Betulin (16) also exerts hepatoprotective activity against continuous ethanol exposure [59]. Ethanol-induced HSC-T6 cells treated with 25 µM of 16 suffered a decrease in the expression levels of collagen-I and α-SMA, which indicates that betulin (16) reduces ethanol-induced hepatic fibrosis. The expression levels of TLR4 were decreased after betulin pretreatment and there was an increased activation of STAT3. This modulation of TLR4 and STAT3 pathways is proposed as the mechanism through which 16 protects the hepatocytes against fibrosis.

A good number of the compounds from Table 1 were tested for their anti-tuberculosis activity against Mycobacterium tuberculosis H37Rv, (+)-Galeon (8) being the most active compound with a minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) of 15 µg/mL. However, this value was still higher than the one obtained with the positive control, ethambutol, which has an MIC of 6.25 µg/mL [19]. The second-best compound, 5-deoxymyricanone (2), has an MIC of 25.8 µg/mL, which is more than four times the MIC of the positive control, so it cannot be considered very active.

Morella/Myrica compounds show remarkable pharmacological potential, with a variety of interesting in vitro activities. For further understanding of their full potential and clarification of mechanisms of action, their activities must be confirmed in vivo. The following section focuses on what is already known about the effects of compounds isolated from Morella/Myrica in living organisms.

2.2. In Vivo Tests

In vivo studies are necessary to understand the actual potential of compounds as future therapeutic agents. A few compounds isolated from Morella/Myrica genera reached the in vivo stage of evaluation of their pharmacological effects, which means that research teams recognize their potential and want to prove their full pharmacological value. The main results of those studies are summarized in Table 2, and the most relevant aspects are discussed below.

Table 2. In vivo biological activities exhibited by compounds from Morella and Myrica species.

As expected, the three compounds which have been more extensively studied in vitro and which were reported to be bioactive were the ones selected by researchers to be evaluated concerning their in vivo activity (Table 2). These compounds are myricanol (4), myricitrin (10), and betulin (16), and many of the in vivo studies found in the present literature survey aimed to confirm or to clarify the mechanisms of action found on the in vitro studies.

A dosage of 5 mg/kg of myricanol (4) administered to C57BL/6 mice with dexamethasone-induced muscle wasting led to a reduction of muscle loss in both quadriceps and gastrocnemius muscle (Table 2). In addition, the mice from the treated group showed an improvement of grip strength of about 50 g and almost doubled the forced swim time when compared with the untreated group [30]. Muscle atrophy was inhibited, with muscle fiber diameter increasing almost by 25% when compared with the untreated group. As observed in the in vitro tests, myricanol (4) also prevents dexamethasone-induced muscle atrophy and weakness by activating SIRT1 to reduce muscle protein degradation, enhance autophagy, and promote mitochondrial biogenesis and function in mice [30].

In another study, myricanol (4) at a dosage of 25 mg/kg, when fed to C57BL/6J mice simultaneously with a high fat diet (HFD), was able to reduce body weight and body fat accumulation, when compared with mice fed only with the HFD [71]. Furthermore, compound 4 administration led to a 33% decrease in lipids serum levels and a 50% reduction of fasting insulin levels, which can be explained by the 2-fold increase observed in the insulin sensitivity on the treated group (Table 2). Other effects of 4 in the HFD-fed mice were the activation of a series of pathways, like adenosine monophosphate-activated protein kinase (AMPK), leading to the suppression of adipogenesis and induction of lipolysis and lipid combustion in adipocytes, or insulin receptor substrate 1 (IRS-1), which leads to mitochondrial biogenesis, increases mitochondrial oxidative metabolism, and benefits adenosine triphosphate (ATP) synthesis. Myricanol (4) also increases irisin serum levels, which induces mitochondrial oxidative metabolism, mitochondrial uncoupling, fatty acid oxidation in skeletal muscle [76], and increases energy expenditure in human adipocytes, resulting in reduced lipid accumulation [77]. Altogether, these data show this compound could be developed as a candidate for the treatment of insulin resistance and obesity. The effect of myricanol on lipid accumulation was confirmed by Shen et al. [31], but in a zebrafish model, with their findings showing the inhibition of lipid accumulation by suppressing adipogenic factors, including peroxisome proliferator activated receptor γ (PPARγ) and CCAAT/enhancer binding protein α (C/EBPα).

Myricanol (4) also decreased tumor growth in xenografted BALB/c nude mice at a dosage of 40 mg/kg, by activating the expression levels of pro-apoptotic factors within the tumor cells and downregulating the protein expression of Bcl-2, VEGF, HIF-1α, and survivin, thus increasing the apoptotic rate of tumor cells [72]. These effects led to a reduction in tumor volume of 39.4% after 14 days when compared with the untreated mice, showing the great potential of myricanol to become an anticancer drug.

In a murine model of atherosclerosis, a dosage of 50 mg/kg of myricitrin prevented the formation of Ox-LDL, which represented a reduction of 25% in serum levels of that atherosclerosis promoter [45]. A similar reduction was found in the mice treated with the positive control, probucol, but at a 40-fold higher dose than that of myricitrin, which means the latter is much more effective. By reducing the levels of Ox-LDL, myricitrin (10) led to a reduction of 20% in the expression of caspase-3 in the aortic arch, thus reducing endothelial cell apoptosis. This resulted in a complete inhibition of calcification in the aortic arch of treated mice, and a reduction on the atherosclerotic plaque area (Table 2) [45].

The in vivo investigation of the effects of myricitrin in a model of diabetic cardiomyopathy demonstrated that oral administration of a dosage of 300 mg/kg/day for 8 weeks remarkably decreased the expression of enzymes associated with cardiomyopathy, as well as the expression of inflammatory cytokines and apoptotic proteins [44]. This led to 20–25% improvement of diastolic dysfunction and attenuated histological abnormalities, by inhibiting the destruction of the collagen network, which reduces the fibrotic alterations of the heart. Mechanistically, the authors found that myricitrin (10) attenuated diabetes-induced Nrf2 inhibition via the regulation of Akt and extracellular-signal-related kinase (ERK) phosphorylation in the diabetic heart.

Another in vivo study showed that a dosage of 50 mg/kg of myricitrin (10) improved neuron injury and increased the expressions levels of PSD-95 protein and tyrosine hydroxylase TH protein in lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-stimulated BALB/c mice [74]. Loss of these proteins is found in Parkinson’s disease [78], so the fact that myricitrin increases their expression hints for a possible role in the prevention of this disease. In addition, myricitrin (10) decreased the production of pro-inflammatory factors including IL-1β, IL-6, and TNFα, decreased the level of chemokine MCP-1, and suppressed the expressions of COX-2 and iNOS (Table 2). Meanwhile, myricitrin suppressed HMGB1, TLR4, and MyD88 expression in the nigrostriatum of LPS-stimulated mice, and inhibited NF-κB and mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) signaling pathways activated by LPS [74]. These effects show that myricitrin (10) is efficient in protecting the brain against inflammation and all the nefarious effects it causes.

Myricitrin (10) at a dosage of 100 mg/kg significantly ameliorated CCl4-induced hepatotoxicity in BALB/cN mice [73]. Treatment with this compound caused an increase in serum aspartate transaminase (AST) and alanine transaminase (ALT) levels and prevented histopathological changes in the liver (Table 2). Hepatic oxidative stress was reduced by myricitrin (10), as evidenced by the decrease in lipid peroxidation, with concomitant increase in glutathione (GSH) level and cytochrome P450 2E1 (CYP2E1) expression. Furthermore, cyclooxygenase-2 (COX-2) and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-a) overexpression in the liver was reduced, suggesting the suppression of inflammation [73]. Myricitrin (10) also improved the regeneration of hepatic tissue after CCl4-intoxication, as evidenced by increased proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) expression. The results presented by Domitrovic et al. [73] [73] suggest that the anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects of myricitrin (10) are responsible for its hepatoprotective activity. In fact, all the myricitrin (10) in vivo studies presented in Table 2 strongly indicate that 10 exerts its protective effects through the blockage of inflammation, oxidative stress, and apoptosis [44][45][73][74][44,45,73,74], which confirms myricitrin (10) as a potential candidate for the treatment and prevention of a wide array of disorders related to oxidative stress and inflammation.

Betulin (16) in vivo studies focused on its hepatoprotective effects against both chronic alcohol consumption [75] [75] or acute ethanol induced fatty liver [47]. In the model of chronic consumption, administration of 20 mg/kg of betulin (16) to alcoholic C57BL/6 mice attenuated the increases in serum aminotransferase and triglyceride levels, while significantly inhibiting SREBP-1 expression and activating LKB1-AMPK phosphorylation [75]. Additionally, betulin (16) enhanced the sirtuin 1 (SIRT1) expression mediated by ethanol. Taken together, betulin alleviates alcoholic liver injury possibly through blocking the regulation of SREBP-1 on fatty acid synthesis and activating SIRT1-LKB1-AMPK signaling pathway.

In the acute ethanol-induced fatty liver model, administration of 50 mg/kg of betulin (16) to C57BL/6 mice induced a decrease in serum levels of hepatic enzymes and triglycerides [47]. The expression of SREBP-1, a transcription factor that promotes fatty acid synthesis [79] [79] and whose activation by ethanol leads to fat accumulation on the liver, is reduced by betulin (16) to 75% of the expression levels presented by the untreated groups [47]. Betulin (16) administration also significantly decreased the expression levels of CYP2E1 and TLR4 and increased the activation of STAT3 (Table 2), thus impairing the ethanol induced pro-inflammatory response and, consequently reducing liver steatosis and fibrosis [47].