Ecological-economic efficiency of water use, or water eco-efficiency, relates the economic value created with water to the volume of water consumed and the environmental pressure caused. Water use is more eco-efficient when it yields more output or income per cubic metre while causing less pollution and less damage to aquatic ecosystems. The concept is measured with ratio indicators such as water productivity and SDG indicator 6.4.1, with water footprints and accounts, and with frontier methods such as data envelopment analysis. It guides water allocation, programme evaluation and public audit, especially in water-scarce regions such as Central Asia.
Ecological-economic efficiency of water use, also called water eco-efficiency, is the relationship between the economic value created with water and the water consumed and environmental pressure caused in creating it. A use of water is more eco-efficient when it yields more goods, services or income per unit of water withdrawn or consumed, while generating less pollution and less damage to aquatic ecosystems. The concept therefore joins two questions that are often treated separately: whether water produces enough economic benefit, and whether its use stays within ecological limits.
The term comes from the broader idea of eco-efficiency, promoted in the 1990s by the World Business Council for Sustainable Development as “creating more value with less impact” [1] and adopted by the OECD as a guide for environmental policy [2]. Applied to water, the idea gained weight as water scarcity, pollution and competition among agriculture, industry, households and nature increased. It is now part of the Sustainable Development Goals: SDG target 6.4 calls for a substantial increase in water-use efficiency across all sectors, measured by indicator 6.4.1, the change in water-use efficiency over time [3].
Three groups of methods are used. Ratio indicators divide economic output by water use, for example gross value added per cubic metre of water withdrawn, crop yield or income per cubic metre (water productivity), or SDG indicator 6.4.1, which weights sectoral efficiencies by their share of water use [3]. Ratios are simple and easy to communicate, but they ignore pollution and do not show how far a user is from the best achievable level. Critics argue that indicator 6.4.1 mainly reflects economic productivity and can change with economic structure or prices without any real saving of water [3].
Footprint and accounting methods trace water through production and trade. The water footprint distinguishes blue water (surface and groundwater), green water (soil moisture from rainfall) and grey water (the volume needed to dilute pollution), and makes it possible to compare products, regions and countries [4]. Environmental and water accounts link physical water flows with economic statistics.
Frontier methods, mainly data envelopment analysis (DEA) [5], compare decision-making units such as regions, river basins, farms or utilities with the best performers in the sample. In the total-factor approach, water is treated as one input together with labour and capital, and efficiency is the ratio of the minimum water needed to the water actually used [6]. Later models add undesirable outputs, such as wastewater or pollutant loads, so that the efficiency score reflects both economic and ecological performance. Spatial assessments combine such indicators with maps to show where improvements are most needed [7].
Agriculture is the largest user of water in most dry regions, and raising agricultural water productivity is widely seen as a main way to reduce scarcity [8]. However, research warns that the term efficiency is often used loosely. Water lost from a field through seepage or runoff may return to rivers or aquifers and be used again downstream; only water that evaporates, transpires or becomes polluted is truly consumed [9]. When farmers adopt drip or sprinkler irrigation, the saved water is often used to expand irrigated area or grow more water-intensive crops, so that total consumption increases. Hydro-economic modelling has shown that subsidies for efficient irrigation technology can raise water use at basin scale [10], a result now known as the paradox of irrigation efficiency [11]. Eco-economic efficiency must therefore be assessed at the scale of the basin and in terms of consumption, not only withdrawals at the field level.
Eco-economic efficiency serves several purposes in public management. Governments use it to set targets, allocate water among sectors and evaluate programmes of irrigation modernisation, water supply and wastewater treatment. Public and environmental auditors use efficiency indicators as audit criteria to judge whether budget spending on water produces proportionate physical and ecological results, such as reduced losses, improved water quality or restored river flows. Developing clear criteria of natural resource efficiency that combine economic, environmental and social indicators is a precondition for such audits [12]. Reliable metering and monitoring data are a frequent constraint, and audits often find that programmes report spending and constructed infrastructure but not changes in water use or service quality.
In practice, eco-efficiency indicators are most informative when they are used together. A region or utility may raise its value added per cubic metre of water while still depleting aquifers or discharging untreated wastewater, so ratio indicators should be read alongside data on water quality, return flows and the state of aquatic ecosystems. Frontier methods help to identify realistic benchmarks for comparison, but their results depend on the choice of inputs and outputs and on the quality of the underlying data. For these reasons, assessments of water eco-efficiency increasingly combine several methods and report results at different scales, from individual farms and utilities to river basins and national accounts.
Central Asia illustrates the stakes of the concept. The expansion of irrigated cotton and rice in the Amu Darya and Syr Darya basins in the twentieth century, supplied by canals with large conveyance losses, led to the desiccation of the Aral Sea, one of the largest environmental disasters caused by water use [13]. Today the countries of the region face growing scarcity under climate change, ageing infrastructure and rising demand. In Kazakhstan, studies of rural water supply show that water quality and users’ satisfaction vary strongly with the source and type of supply system [14]. This means that public investment in water must be judged by service outcomes and not only by the volume of spending. Assessing the eco-economic efficiency of water use, at the level of regions, basins and public programmes, is therefore a growing field of research and audit practice in the region.
Ecological-economic efficiency of water use links the economic productivity of water with the ecological cost of its use. It is measured with ratio indicators, water footprints and accounts, and frontier methods such as DEA. Its correct use requires attention to scale and to real water consumption, as the irrigation efficiency paradox shows. For water-scarce regions such as Central Asia, the concept offers a basis for setting policy targets and for auditing whether public spending on water delivers results for both the economy and the environment.
Acknowledgments: During the preparation of this entry, the author used Claude (Anthropic) for drafting and language editing. The author reviewed and edited the content and takes full responsibility for it.