Your browser does not fully support modern features. Please upgrade for a smoother experience.
Sustainable nanocellulose-aloe adhesive development for packaging applications: Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 1 by Urška Vrabič-Brodnjak and Version 2 by Catherine Yang.

The development of bio-based adhesives as sustainable alternatives to synthetic formulations presents a significant opportunity for advancing environmental sustainability in packaging applications. This research aimed to develop and evaluate a bio-based adhesive derived from bacterial nanocellulose (BNC), aloe vera and its mixtures as a potential replacement for commercial synthetic adhesives. Aloe vera, selected for its polysaccharide-rich composition, served as a natural polymeric matrix, while BNC contributed reinforcing properties. The adhesive formulations, with and without BNC, were compared to a commercial adhesive to assess their mechanical performance. T-peel and shear tests were conducted on smooth and rough paper substrates to evaluate adhesive strength. The bio-based adhesive incorporating BNC demonstrated superior shear and peel strength on rough substrates due to enhanced mechanical interlocking within the fibrous structure of paper, whereas performance on smooth surfaces was hindered by uneven BNC distribution, reducing adhesive-substrate interaction. Although the commercial adhesive achieved higher absolute maximum force values, the bio-based formulation exhibited comparable mechanical stability under specific conditions. These findings underscore the influence of substrate properties and application methods on adhesive performance, highlighting the potential of bio-based adhesives in packaging applications and the need for further formulation optimization to fully realize their advantages over traditional synthetic adhesives.

  • bio-based adhesives
  • polymers
  • packaging applications
  • sustainable materials
  • circularity

1. Introduction

Adhesives are indispensable materials that underpin a vast array of industrial applications by enabling the formation of reliable, durable joints critical to product functionality, structural integrity, and longevity. Among these applications, the packaging sector is one of the largest consumers of adhesives, demanding materials that not only exhibit exceptional mechanical robustness but also meet increasingly stringent environmental and sustainability criteria [[1], [2], [3]]. Historically, synthetic adhesives—predominantly petrochemical-derived polymers—have dominated this sector due to their superior adhesion performance, ease of processing, and cost-effectiveness. However, these materials pose significant environmental concerns related to their non-renewable origin, resistance to biodegradation, and potential ecological toxicity upon disposal or incineration, contributing to pollution and resource depletion. The urgent global imperative to mitigate environmental impact and promote circular economy principles has catalyzed a paradigm shift toward the development of sustainable, bio-based adhesive alternatives [[4]]. Renewable polymers derived from biomass offer promising pathways to reduce reliance on fossil fuels and decrease the carbon footprint of adhesive formulations. Within this context, bacterial nanocellulose (BNC), a highly pure microbial polysaccharide synthesized extracellularly by bacteria such as Gluconacetobacter xylinus, has emerged as an exceptional candidate for bio-adhesive reinforcement [[5]]. BNC is characterized by its nanoscale fibrillar network, which imparts remarkable tensile strength, high crystallinity, flexibility, and biodegradability. Furthermore, its capacity to form strong hydrogen-bonded networks enhances interfacial adhesion within polymeric matrices, thereby improving the mechanical and functional properties of bio-based adhesives [[5]]. Complementing BNC, aloe vera (Aloe barbadensis Miller) is a succulent plant whose mucilaginous gel is rich in bioactive polysaccharides, which exhibit intrinsic adhesive and film-forming properties [[6]]. The gel’s viscous nature and biocompatibility make aloe vera a valuable natural polymeric matrix for adhesive systems. The strategic integration of BNC and aloe vera in adhesive formulations leverages the synergistic interplay between nanofibrillar reinforcement and polysaccharide adhesion, potentially yielding bio-based adhesives with competitive performance metrics relative to their synthetic counterparts [[7]]. The goal of this study was to develop and systematically characterize a bio-based adhesive formulated from BNC and aloe vera, aiming to deliver mechanical performance and adhesion properties comparable to commercial synthetic adhesives while offering enhanced environmental sustainability. The research focused on optimizing adhesive formulations, evaluating their mechanical and interfacial properties on diverse substrates, and assessing their potential as sustainable alternatives for industrial applications, particularly in the packaging sector. Adhesive performance was systematically evaluated against a benchmark commercial synthetic adhesive through mechanical testing on substrates varying in surface roughness and physicochemical properties. This research directly addresses the rising regulatory and market-driven mandates—embodied by policies such as the European Green Deal—that promote sustainable material usage, reduction of environmental impact, and advancement of circular economy strategies. The principal objectives of this work were as follows: (1) to conduct an exhaustive market and literature review of adhesive technologies relevant to packaging; (2) to optimize the cost-efficient biosynthesis of BNC using agro-industrial by-products and alternative nutrient sources; (3) to develop and optimize aloe vera–BNC composite adhesive formulations; (4) to perform mechanical and adhesion strength testing on relevant substrates; and (5) to benchmark these bio-based adhesives against commercially available synthetic adhesives to assess their industrial viability.

The extant research underscores the considerable synergistic potential of combining bacterial nanocellulose and aloe vera to develop bio-based adhesives that meet the dual imperatives of mechanical performance and sustainability. Nonetheless, several challenges must overcome to realize their industrial applicability. These include the high production costs of nanocellulose materials, technological hurdles in large-scale processing, and incomplete toxicological and environmental impact assessments. The advancement of bio-based adhesive technologies based on bacterial nanocellulose and aloe vera presents a promising avenue to reduce dependency on synthetic adhesives, facilitate biodegradability, and foster sustainable innovation in packaging and other industrial sectors. 

2. Sustainable Nanocellulose-Aloe Adhesive Development for Packaging Applications

According to research published in Mocelucles (MDPI): Sustainable Adhesive Formulation and Performance Evaluation of Bacterial Nanocellulose and Aloe Vera for Packaging Applications (https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules30153136)  the resutls have shown that the influence of BNC on the mechanical and adhesive properties of bio-based adhesives formulated from aloe vera and a commercial adhesive. BNC, obtained as a by-product of apple cider vinegar production, proved to be an effective additive for improving adhesive formulations. Physical characterisation of the cardboard substrate demonstrated clear differences between coated and uncoated surfaces. Furthermore, SEM analysis revealed that effective adhesion on the coated surface requires a uniform adhesive layer, whereas the rougher uncoated side enables mechanical interlocking and consequently higher bond strength, provided adequate surface hardness is ensured.
Due to the relatively high production cost of BNC, a concentration of 2 g per 100 ml adhesive mixture was selected to balance performance benefits with economic feasibility. Despite this limitation, the addition of BNC significantly influenced the mechanical properties of both adhesive systems. In T-peel testing, aloe vera-based adhesives with BNC showed statistically significant increases in maximum peel forces on both coated and uncoated sides. A reduction in work of rupture on the uncoated side indicated decreased ductility, while an increase in work of rupture on the coated side was observed but was not statistically significant, suggesting the need for further investigation with larger sample sizes. Conversely, the effects of BNC addition to commercial adhesives were less pronounced, with decreases in work at maximum force on both surfaces, implying increased brittleness or reduced ductility. Statistically significant differences were confirmed only for the work of rupture on the uncoated side. Shear testing of commercial adhesives revealed failure primarily within the cardboard layers rather than the adhesive interface, indicating strong cohesive properties. For aloe vera adhesives, SEM revealed aggregation on the coated surface, potentially creating weak points, while deeper penetration into the matrix was observed on the uncoated side with minimal residue remaining on the surface.

The study encountered limitations, such as cohesive failure during shear testing, suggesting that future evaluations could benefit from adjusting adhesive application areas or using substrates with higher cohesive strength to more accurately assess performance. Although the results highlight the potential of BNC-based adhesives as sustainable alternatives to conventional adhesives, their effectiveness was highly dependent on the homogeneity of the adhesive mixture. In this study, BNC dispersion was achieved through basic mechanical stirring, which likely limited fibre distribution and contributed to variability in adhesive properties. Future work should therefore explore advanced dispersion methods, such as ultrasonication or high-shear mixing, to enhance homogeneity and reduce batch-to-batch variability. Additionally, optimising formulations by testing varying BNC concentrations and potential additives will be essential to balance performance, cost, and processability. The long-term stability and environmental durability of aloe vera-based adhesives remain critical considerations, given their hydrophilic nature and sensitivity to humidity, temperature, and microbial exposure. Future studies should include degradation and shelf-life analyses to evaluate durability and environmental resistance, particularly for practical applications in food and biodegradable packaging. Moreover, economic feasibility and scalability assessments are necessary to support the industrial implementation of BNC-based adhesives. This study establishes a clear correlation between cardboard surface properties, adhesive behaviour, and mechanical joint performance, providing valuable insights for advancing bio-based adhesive development. With continued refinement and comprehensive evaluation, BNC-enhanced adhesives have the potential to match or surpass conventional adhesives while offering notable environmental benefits, including improved sustainability and recyclability.

References

  1. Packaging Adhesives and Sustainability. Packaging Adhesives and Sustainability. Retrieved 2025-12-8
  2. Adhesives innovations driven by VOC and sustainability trends. Adhesives innovations driven by VOC and sustainability trends. Retrieved 2025-12-8
  3. Vrabič-Brodnjak U. Bio-based adhesives formulated from tannic acid, chitosan, and shellac for packaging materials.. Polymers. 2023, 15(5), 1302.
  4. Adhesives And Sealants Market (2025 - 2033). Adhesives And Sealants Market (2025 - 2033). Retrieved 2025-12-8
  5. Production, Processes and Modification of Nanocrystalline Cellulose from Agro-Waste: A Review. Production, Processes and Modification of Nanocrystalline Cellulose from Agro-Waste: A Review. Retrieved 2025-12-8
  6. Sustainable synthesis pathways: Bacterial nanocellulose from lignocellulosic biomass for circular economy initiatives. Sustainable synthesis pathways: Bacterial nanocellulose from lignocellulosic biomass for circular economy initiatives. Retrieved 2025-12-8
  7. Enhancing Barrier and Antioxidant Properties of Nanocellulose Films for Coatings and Active Packaging: A Review. Enhancing Barrier and Antioxidant Properties of Nanocellulose Films for Coatings and Active Packaging: A Review. Retrieved 2025-12-8
More
Academic Video Service