You're using an outdated browser. Please upgrade to a modern browser for the best experience.
Managing Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome (ARDS): Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 1 by Samuel Huang and Version 2 by Jason Zhu.

Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome (ARDS) often complicates severe cases of COVID-19, typically as viral pneumonia progresses into diffuse alveolar damage, similar to ARDS from other etiologies. Here’s a structured approach to ARDS management, emphasizing strategies effective in Pneumonia, Sepsis, COVID, etc.

  • Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome

1. Understanding ARDS

ARDS is an acute, inflammatory lung injury where fluid accumulates in the alveoli, impairing oxygen exchange. It commonly results from sepsis, pneumonia, trauma, or other systemic insults. COVID-19 triggers a similar cytokine release, leading to lung inflammation and fluid buildup.

2. Diagnosis: The Berlin Criteria

Diagnosis follows the Berlin criteria:

  • Timing: Within one week of known clinical insult or new/worsening respiratory symptoms.
  • Chest Imaging: Bilateral opacities on chest X-ray or CT, not fully explained by effusion or collapse.
  • Origin of Edema: Exclusion of cardiac causes, favoring non-cardiogenic sources.
  • Severity (PaO₂/FiO₂ ratios):
    • Mild: 200-300 mmHg
    • Moderate: 100-200 mmHg
    • Severe: <100 mmHg

3. Lung-Protective Ventilation

Lung-protective ventilation has been proven to reduce mortality in ARDS, with the main elements being:

  • Low Tidal Volume (VT): 6 mL/kg of ideal body weight to prevent alveolar overdistention.
  • Plateau Pressure: Target <30 cm H₂O to avoid barotrauma.
  • PEEP: Use enough positive end-expiratory pressure to avoid atelectasis, without causing overdistention.
    • PEEP trials: Higher PEEP improves oxygenation in moderate-severe cases, although with no clear mortality benefit.

4. Adjusting Driving Pressure

  • Driving Pressure: Calculated as tidal volume divided by lung compliance or plateau pressure minus PEEP.
  • Goal: Keeping driving pressure low correlates strongly with improved survival, even more than focusing solely on VT or plateau pressures.

5. Managing Ventilator Desynchrony

5. Managing Ventilator Desynchrony

 

 

Sample Questions

  1. COVID-19 and ARDS

Q: Is the ARDS management algorithm specific to COVID-19?

A: No, COVID-19 is a viral pneumonia that can lead to ARDS, but the ARDS management strategies discussed can be applied broadly to ARDS patients, including those with COVID-19.

  1. Definition of ARDS

Q: What is ARDS?

A: Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome (ARDS) is a diffuse, acute inflammatory lung injury caused by a variety of conditions, resulting in excess fluid in both the interstitial spaces and alveoli due to disrupted fluid regulation.

  1. Pathophysiology of ARDS

Q: What causes lung damage in ARDS?

A: Lung injury in ARDS triggers the release of pro-inflammatory cytokines that recruit neutrophils and other mediators, damaging capillary endothelium and alveolar epithelium. This leads to impaired gas exchange, decreased lung compliance, and increased pulmonary arterial pressure.

  1. Diagnosing ARDS

Q: How is ARDS diagnosed?

A: ARDS is diagnosed based on the 2012 Berlin Criteria, which include:

  • Timing: Symptoms begin within one week of a known clinical insult.
  • Chest Imaging: Bilateral opacities on imaging, not explained by effusions or nodules.
  • Origin of Edema: Lung failure not fully explained by cardiac failure or fluid overload.
  • Oxygenation: PaO2/FiO2 ratios define ARDS severity (mild: 200-300, moderate: 100-200, severe: <100 mm Hg).
  1. Lung Protective Ventilation

Q: What is the initial ventilator strategy for ARDS?

A: Start with lung-protective ventilation, specifically using low tidal volumes (4-6 mL/kg ideal body weight), which is proven to reduce mortality.

  1. Importance of Low Tidal Volume

Q: Why are low tidal volumes essential in ARDS management?

A: The ARDSNet trial (2000) showed that low tidal volumes reduce plateau pressures, which leads to lower mortality and more ventilator-free days.

  1. Managing Plateau Pressures

Q: What is the target plateau pressure in ARDS management?

A: Aim to keep plateau pressures under 30 cm H2O to balance the need to avoid atelectasis without causing volutrauma from over-distension.

  1. PEEP in ARDS

Q: Is high PEEP beneficial in ARDS?

A: High PEEP has shown mixed results. Although some RCTs showed no mortality improvement, a meta-analysis suggested it could improve oxygenation and reduce mortality in moderate to severe ARDS.

  1. Understanding Driving Pressure

Q: What is driving pressure and why is it relevant?

A: Driving pressure is the difference between plateau pressure and total PEEP, or tidal volume divided by lung compliance. It reflects the mechanical stress on ventilated lung portions and is closely associated with survival, even more than tidal volume or PEEP.

  1. Ventilator Dyssynchrony

Q: Why address ventilator dyssynchrony in ARDS patients?

A: Ventilator dyssynchrony worsens outcomes by increasing ICU stay, mortality, and ventilator days. Management options include adjusting ventilator modes/settings, increasing sedation, or using paralytics if necessary.

  1. Prone Positioning

Q: How effective is prone positioning in ARDS management?

A: Prone positioning, especially when done for over 16 hours a day early in ARDS (within 48 hours), has been shown to significantly reduce mortality in patients with severe hypoxemia (PaO2/FiO2 < 150).

  1. Neuromuscular Blockade

Q: When should neuromuscular blockade be considered?

A: Consider neuromuscular blockade within 48 hours of ARDS diagnosis, especially if the PaO2/FiO2 ratio is below 150. However, the evidence is mixed, with some trials showing benefits and others not, so clinical judgment is important.

  1. Avoiding De-Recruitment

Q: How can de-recruitment be avoided in ARDS management?

A: Prevent de-recruitment by optimizing mean airway pressure and PEEP. Use PEEP tables tailored to FiO2 levels to maintain open lung units and improve oxygenation.

  1. Recruitment Maneuvers

Q: What are recruitment maneuvers, and when are they used?

A: Recruitment maneuvers (e.g., CPAP with high pressure for short intervals) temporarily increase intrathoracic pressure to re-expand collapsed lung units. They should be done with hemodynamic monitoring due to the risk of reduced cardiac output.

  1. Airway Pressure Release Ventilation (APRV)

Q: What is APRV and when might it be used?

A: APRV is a ventilation mode allowing spontaneous breathing during inspiratory phases, which can be more comfortable for patients. Evidence on its benefits is mixed, so it’s typically considered after other non-inverted pressure control modes have been tried.

  1. Nitric Oxide

Q: Is nitric oxide used in ARDS treatment?

A: Nitric oxide can temporarily improve oxygenation, but it does not improve mortality. It should be considered only after other methods fail, starting at 10 ppm and increasing as needed.

  1. Additional Considerations in ARDS Management

Q: Are there other supportive strategies in ARDS management?

A: Yes, these include:

  • Conservative Fluid Management: Reduces ventilator days.
  • Positioning: Position the good lung down in unilateral lung injury.
  • Cardiac Evaluation: Rule out cardiac dysfunction, especially in cases unresponsive to ARDS interventions.

Additional Questions

  1. Recruitment Maneuvers

Q: What are some examples of recruitment maneuvers in ARDS, and why are they used cautiously?

A: Examples include switching to a CPAP setting at 30-40 cm H2O pressure for 30 seconds or using pressure-controlled ventilation with high pressure (e.g., 40 cm H2O) for brief periods. These maneuvers can improve oxygenation by re-expanding collapsed alveoli but may reduce cardiac output due to increased intrathoracic pressure. Close hemodynamic monitoring is essential during these maneuvers.

  1. Incremental PEEP Trials

Q: How is an incremental PEEP trial conducted, and what is its purpose?

A: In a PEEP trial, PEEP is gradually increased until the optimal lung compliance is achieved, also known as a "PEEP ladder." This trial aims to find the PEEP level that maximizes oxygenation without over-distending the lung.

  1. Airway Pressure Release Ventilation (APRV)

Q: What is APRV, and what is its role in ARDS management?

A: APRV is a ventilator mode allowing spontaneous breaths during the inspiratory phase, often more comfortable for patients. While data on APRV is mixed, some studies suggest it may increase ventilator-free days and improve oxygenation without significantly raising plateau pressures. It's generally used after other ventilation modes have been tried.

  1. Nitric Oxide

Q: When should nitric oxide be considered, and what are the risks?

A: Nitric oxide is considered only when other strategies fail, as it may improve oxygenation but does not reduce mortality or ventilator dependence. Risks include acute kidney injury and methemoglobinemia; daily monitoring is recommended. Start at 10 ppm and increase as needed, weaning gradually when FiO2 stabilizes.

  1. Conservative Fluid Management

Q: Why is conservative fluid management recommended in ARDS?

A: Conservative fluid management helps reduce ventilator days. The ARDS Network trial showed that patients on a conservative fluid strategy had a 7-liter negative fluid balance compared to those on a liberal strategy, leading to more ventilator-free days.

  1. Positional Therapy

Q: How does positioning benefit patients with unilateral lung consolidation in ARDS?

A: Positioning the good lung down can improve the ventilation-perfusion ratio, enhancing oxygenation. This can be done by placing a wedge under the patient’s back to tilt them in bed.

  1. Evaluating Cardiac Dysfunction

Q: Why is it essential to assess cardiac function in ARDS?

A: Cardiac dysfunction can mimic or coexist with ARDS. If ARDS treatments are ineffective, re-evaluating cardiac function may help distinguish between pure respiratory failure and heart-related issues.

  1. ECMO (Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation)

Q: When should ECMO be considered in ARDS?

A: Early consultation with the ECMO team is advisable for patients with severe, refractory ARDS. Studies like the CESAR and EOLIA trials provide mixed evidence on ECMO’s impact on mortality, but ECMO may benefit patients transferred to ECMO centers for comprehensive care.

  1. Other Potential Strategies

Q: What additional strategies might be worth exploring in ARDS management?

A: Esophageal pressure-guided ventilatory management and high-frequency oscillatory ventilation are additional techniques. If these are used in your practice, reviewing where they fit in the ARDS treatment algorithm is beneficial.

 

  • Optimize Ventilator Settings: Adjust rise times for pressure-controlled settings and flow rates for volume control.
  • Sedation and Paralysis: Increase sedation if needed or use neuromuscular blockers in cases with significant desynchrony. Avoid excess tidal volume (>8 mL/kg) where possible.

 

  • Optimize Ventilator Settings: Adjust rise times for pressure-controlled settings and flow rates for volume control.
  • Sedation and Paralysis: Increase sedation if needed or use neuromuscular blockers in cases with significant desynchrony. Avoid excess tidal volume (>8 mL/kg) where possible.

6. Prone Positioning

  • PROSEVA Trial Evidence: Prolonged prone positioning (≥16 hours/day) improves mortality in severe ARDS.
  • Contraindications: Traumatic injuries, recent surgeries, or instability. Proning requires careful teamwork to prevent dislodging endotracheal tubes and monitoring for pressure sores.

7. Neuromuscular Blockade

  • When to Use: If PaO₂/FiO₂ <150, consider early neuromuscular blockade within 48 hours.
  • Evidence: Mixed results; while some trials showed decreased mortality, others (like ROSE) did not. Benefits include decreased ventilator-induced lung injury and increased ventilator-free days.

8. Conservative Fluid Management

  • Reduced Fluid Load: Targeting negative fluid balance is beneficial, with studies showing increased ventilator-free days and less pulmonary edema. Aim for a mean difference of around -7 liters in conservative management groups.

9. Advanced Strategies for Severe ARDS

  • Recruitment Maneuvers: Temporary increases in airway pressure to recruit collapsed alveoli can help in refractory cases. Monitor closely for hemodynamic instability.
  • Airway Pressure Release Ventilation (APRV): Mixed evidence; some studies show improved ventilator-free days.
  • Nitric Oxide and ECMO: Limited to severe refractory hypoxemia due to high costs and specific risks, such as methemoglobinemia for nitric oxide.

10. ECMO for Refractory Cases

  • Consider Early: Early consultation for ECMO in severe, refractory ARDS is recommended, particularly for patients with a PaO₂/FiO₂ <60 despite optimal ventilatory strategies.

Final Notes

For ARDS management in COVID-19 patients, adherence to standard ARDS protocols offers substantial support. Timely adjustment of ventilator settings, patient positioning, and judicious fluid management, along with advanced therapies when necessary, form a robust, evidence-based approach to improving outcomes in these critically ill patients.

Academic Video Service