5. Male Fertility and CREM
Two research groups in 1996, one led by Sassone-Corsi and the other by Günther Schütz, concurrently described the first mouse model lacking
Crem; both studies provided compelling evidence for the impact of a CREM deficiency on spermatogenesis, including the loss of the expression of vital genes for spermatogenesis, arrest at the initiation of spermiogenesis and the absence of sperm production
[28][29]. The transcription factor CREM plays a central role in the formation of male haploid cells, as it is responsible for activating genes Involved in meiotic machinery and spermatogenic cell morphogenesis. In a mouse obesity model, a decrease in
Crem, adaptor protein 1 (
Sh2b1), desert hedgehog (
Dhh), insulin-like growth factor 1 (
Igf1) and leptin receptor (
Lepr) transcript levels was observed, resulting in impaired fertility, such as a reduced sperm motility and decreased mating rates of obese males with female mice
[30]. Consequently, it is plausible that CREM homologs may play a similar fundamental role in fertility in other species.
Male fertility also relies on the presence of several CREM cofactors, including ACT, KIF17b and SPAG48, which are crucial for the successful development of spermatogenic cells
[12][31][32]. Studies in infertile populations have revealed the absence or low expression of CREM or its cofactors, contributing to infertility. In the case of the CREM cofactor ACT, studies in infertile patients with azoospermia or oligozoospermia have identified specific single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) resulting in amino acid changes in the ACT coding region, that, combined to the haplotype 204G-211V-243R-12065G, reduce the interaction between ACT and CREM by 45%, as observed in an in vitro double hybrid test
[33]. Similarly, various SNPs found in CREM and its cofactors have been linked to non-obstructive azoospermia (NOA) in patients. SNP rs4934540 in an intron region with a TT or CT genotype confers susceptibility to NOA, while a CT or CC genotype in SNP rs4934540 and an AG genotype of rs2295415 (at the 3′ untranslated end of CREM) reduce the NOA risk. The combination of four CREM SNPs in different haplotypes provides either protection (CGTG) or a high risk (TATG) for spermatogenic failure, as confirmed with expression assays, which showed a low CREM expression
[34].
Patients with Klinefelter syndrome commonly experience hypogonadism, low testosterone levels and fertility problems. Testicular biopsies from these patients with mature sperm have demonstrated a lower expression of genes such as CREM and CSF-1, as well as an absence or reduced expression of protamine compared to azoospermic patients without Klinefelter syndrome but in whom complete spermatogenesis was observed histologically
[35]. Most Klinefelter patients with SCO show no CREM and protamine expression with CSF-1 expression; however, CREM and protamine levels are still detectable in some patients
[35]. Furthermore, alterations in the expression of activating isoforms of CREMτ, namely CREMτ1 and CREMτ2 from the P3 and P4 promoters, respectively, have been observed in patients with spermatogenesis arrest and testicular tumors
[36].
Likewise, the involvement of CREM and ACT in the occupation of CRE sites in the promoters of the target genes
TNP1 and
2, as well as
PRM 1 and
2, in patients with the arrest of round spermatid maturation (SMA) compared to obstructive azoospermia (OA) as a positive control was evaluated. Both
CREM and
ACT are down-regulated in the group of SMA patients, and low levels of expression in the target genes
TNP 1 and
2 and
PRM 1 and
2 were also found. A low occupancy of CREM and ACT was also observed in the promoter regions of the
TNP1 and
2 and
PRM1 and
2 genes in the SMA group, but it could be a result of the low
CREM and
ACT expression
[26]. This confirms CREM’s role as a transcription factor in the development of human spermatogenesis and fertility.
Moreover, the
CREM promoter contains two CpG islands with a total of 73 CpG sites, making it susceptible to methylation. Differentially methylated sites in
CREM have been associated with an impaired sperm DNA integrity in infertile patients
[37]. However, bisulfite sequencing studies did not find significant differences in
CREM promoter methylation in patients with oligozoospermia or abnormal protamination levels, except for two infertile patients who exhibited a distinct pattern of high methylation
[38]. In contrast, a separate pyrosequencing study revealed high levels of DNA methylation in the
CREM promoter in patients with oligozoospermia and abnormal protamination, with a negative correlation to the sperm count, morphology and motility
[38]. Infection with
Toxoplasma gondii has been shown to decrease the reproductive capacity of mice, leading to a noticeable decline in sperm production. An analysis of global methylation in the testicular tissue of infected animals revealed slight differences in methylation levels at specific sites in the
Crem promoter
[39]. These methylation-prone sites in the
CREM promoter can modulate its expression in response to environmental or genotoxic factors, emphasizing their significance as critical determinants of sperm fertility.
6. Impact of Xenobiotics in CREMτ Regulation
Previously, the transcriptional regulation of
Cremτ was discussed. However, diverse studies suggest that CREMτ is also subject to regulation by xenobiotics. Even though these foreign molecules seem to exert both positive and negative effects on fertility
[40][41] extensive research needs to be performed to corroborate if the effect shown in CREMτ levels is due to a lack of a cell population expressing CREM or the direct regulation of the CREM transcript or protein.
6.1. CREM Disruption by ROS Production Xenobiotics
In recent years, there has been increasing evidence linking environmental pollutants to semen quality and spermatogenesis impairment, leading to a rise in male infertility rates
[42][43]. Several studies have suggested that this effect is due to a down-regulation of
CREM pollutants such as solvents, fluoride, pesticides and silica nanoparticles (SiNPs) that seem to be negative regulators of
CREM expression
[43][44][45].
Common pollutants like 1,2-dichloroethane (1,2-DCE), a widely used solvent, and fluoride, a prevalent contaminant in industrialized countries’ drinking water, seem to reduce
CREM expression and its coactivator
ACT in a dose-dependent manner. Interestingly, both pollutants are also associated with a decreased semen quality, including increased sperm malformation and a reduced concentration, viability and motility
[44][45] Additionally, 1,2-DCE exposures have been linked to the vacuolar degeneration of germ cells, sloughing of spermatogenic cells and increased apoptosis in the testes, resembling the phenotype observed in
CREM-knockout mice
[28][29].
The pesticide carbendazim (CBZ), another commonly used chemical, has been found to down-regulate
CREM expression and decrease sperm concentration and motility. Notably, CBZ disrupts epigenetic markers such as H3K27, 5mC and 5hmC, suggesting that certain pollutants may alter the epigenetic regulation of genes involved in spermatogenesis
[45]. Similarly, silica nanoparticles have been shown to reduce sperm quantity and quality by impairing the epigenetic regulation of spermatogenesis and inducing the hypermethylation of the
CREM promoter, resulting in CREM down-regulation
[38].
It is worth noting that not only pollutants but also certain medical treatments can negatively impact
CREM expression. Cistanches herba (CH), a tonic commonly used in Eastern societies, has been found to down-regulate
CREM expression in a dose-dependent manner while reducing the testosterone levels, sperm count and sperm motility, mirroring the phenotype observed in pollutant-induced
CREM down-regulation
[46]. Furthermore, radiation therapy, a known treatment with detrimental effects on the male reproductive system, including permanent infertility, has been shown to decrease
CREM expression, decrease testis weight and induce atrophic seminiferous tubules
[47].
The down-regulation of
CREM by various compounds, whether pollutants or medical treatments, can impair spermatogenesis and lead to male infertility. These xenobiotics likely exert their effects through the production of high levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS), which are associated with testicular damage and male infertility (reviewed in
[48]) (
Figure 4A). Nevertheless, further research needs to be performed to unravel if the deregulation of CREM by these xenobiotics is because of a down-regulation of
Crem per se or due to a lowering of cell populations expressing
Crem.
Figure 4. Effect of xenobiotics on
Crem regulation. (
A) Xenobiotics that produce ROS down-regulate
CREM/ACT expression and damage DNA and protein. This affects sperm quality and reduces sperm concentration and motility. (
B) Antioxidants quench ROS, enhancing
Crem expression. This is associated with better semen quality parameters such as sperm concentration and motility.
6.2. CREM Up-Regulation by Antioxidants
The up-regulation of
CREMτ has been associated with improved semen quality parameters, including sperm concentration and motility
[36][30][33]. Traditional Eastern herbal remedies are promising since they have shown a positive impact on
CREMτ expression. For example, Rubi Fructus (RF), derived from the dried fruit of
Rubus coreanus; Yukmijihwang-tang (YJT), a multiherbal formula used to address male reproductive issues; and MYOMI, a Korean herbal medicine, have traditionally been used to enhance male fertility
[49],
[50],
[51]. Studies administering these formulations to mice have demonstrated an increased sperm concentration and motility, accompanied by an enhancement in
Cremτ mRNA and protein levels
[51][52]. RF constituents are known for their antioxidant properties
[48][52][53][54], while YJT and MYOMI, when tested in combination with cyclophosphamide, a commonly used chemotherapy drug, exhibited a reduced lipid peroxidation, indicating an antioxidant effect
[55][56].
Antioxidant supplementation has been found to have a protective effect on male fertility
[57] For instance, lutein administration following testicular torsion reduced morphological damage to seminiferous tubules and alleviated testicular oxidative stress. Furthermore,
Cremτ expression was restored in lutein-treated mice subjected to testicular torsion
[58]. Another essential antioxidant, folic acid, a B-complex vitamin, enhanced semen quality in older roosters. Aging is known to be a factor contributing to male infertility, and folic acid supplementation increased semen volume, sperm concentration and sperm motility in older roosters. Additionally, it led to enhanced mRNA levels of important genes involved in spermatogenesis, including
Cremτ [59]. Moreover, antioxidant supplementation in patients with idiopathic infertility resulted in the activation of proteins related to the CREM signaling pathway, such as protein kinase cAMP-dependent regulatory subunits (
PRKAR1A,
PRKAR2A and
PRKACA) and lactate dehydrogenase C (
LDHC)
[60]
Taken together, these studies suggest an improvement in semen parameters and
Crem levels due to the ability of antioxidants to quench ROS produced by different types of stress (
Figure 4B)
7. Other CREM Implications in Health and Disease
As previously mentioned,
Cremτ serves as a crucial regulator of spermatogenesis, but it also plays a role in various other molecular mechanisms. Several
Crem isoforms have been identified, each with distinct functions beyond spermatogenesis. Repressive isoforms of Crem are involved in the regulation of genes associated with brain function, β cells and immune responses.
One such isoform, ICER, participates in numerous neurological processes, including long-term memory, neuronal plasticity, apoptosis and epileptogenesis
[61][62][63]. Notably, ICER interacts with brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) and the signal transducer activator of transcription (STAT3) to bind to pCREB in the Gaba α1 promoter, thereby repressing its transcription in cortical neurons
[64][65]. Additionally, ICER modulates adipokine production by inhibiting
Creb and suppressing negative effectors of adiponectin, facilitated glucose transporter 4 (GLUT4) and activating transcription factor 3 (ATF3) in adipocytes
[66][67]. Another metabolic pathway regulated by ICER is insulin production and secretion. ICER binds to the promoters of genes involved in the insulin pathway, and an increased ICER expression induced by oxidized LDL inhibits insulin production and secretion
[68][69]. Furthermore, ICER plays a role in mediating the circadian rhythm in the liver by repressing the period circadian regulator (
Per1) gene promoter
[70]. It is also implicated in vascular smooth muscle cell apoptosis and proliferation
[71].
Another repressive isoform, CREMα, is primarily involved in regulating genes related to the immune system. CREMα acts as a negative regulator of the
Cd68 gene promoter and the interleukin
Il-2 gene. Surprisingly, it increases the expression of
Il17a through epigenetic remodeling
[72][73]. CREMα is implicated in immune disorders such as Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (SLE), where its expression is enhanced by transcription factor SP1 and histone lysine methyltransferase SET1 binding to the
Crem P1 promoter. This results in increased H3K4me3, decreased DNA methyltransferase 3a (DNMT3a) and the subsequent
CREM methylation promoter, leading to the over-expression of CREMα
[73][74]. CREMα also binds to the
Il17f promoter and represses its expression
[75], contributing to accelerated inflammation and autoimmunity
[75][76].
In summary, CREM isoforms play diverse roles in various signaling pathways associated with health and disease. However, further extensive research is necessary to fully understand the involvement of other CREM isoforms in different signaling pathways.